THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



JANUARY 10, 2001



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





73,908         EX PARTE LUIS GERARDO GARCIA FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT SET ASIDE;

CAUSE REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



73,938         EX REL. BILL HILL, RELATOR FROM DALLAS COUNTY

MANDAMUS RELIEF CONDITIONALLY GRANTED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)



73,994         EX PARTE ALBERT RAMIREZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY

73,995         EX PARTE THOMAS MICHAEL VANCE FROM DENTON COUNTY

73,996         EX PARTE JESSE DAN CATES FROM STEPHENS COUNTY

73,997         EX PARTE DAVID JOHN MAURIN FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,998         EX PARTE KEITH DUANE TOWLES FROM PARKER COUNTY

73,999         EX PARTE NOE GARCIA, JR. FROM GALVESTON COUNTY

74,000         EX PARTE PAUL WILLIAM SEAR FROM HARRIS COUNTY

74,001         EX PARTE ROCKY DEONDRE BAILEY FROM HARRIS COUNTY



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:

73,132         JOHN WADE ADAMS FROM DALLAS COUNTY

                    (JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0281-00         THOMAS RAY BATTS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

   DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

   NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:



0894-00         ROBERT CLINTON REEVES HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01097-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1310-00         DAVID M. DONOVAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00427-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1329-00         DARLENE HROMADKA HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00685-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT NOT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1485-00         WILLIAM MITCHELL (SPA'S #2) BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-00643-CR

                        (ORAL ARGUMENT NOT PERMITTED)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1416-00         GARCIA, ELIDA COMACHO LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-99-00210-CR

1447-00         LISTER, RAYMOND SIDNEY HARRIS COUNTY 13-99-00680-CR

1540-00         EVANS, JOHN DANIEL HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00705-CR

1542-00         PALACIOS, RUBEN HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01014-CR

1548-00         SANCHEZ, OSCAR ISMAEL, JR. BELL COUNTY 03-99-00612-CR

1590-00         CLIFTON, JOE LEE TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00546-CR

1592-00         HERNANDEZ, JUAN NUECES COUNTY 13-99-00098-CR

1606-00         GUARDIOLA, ALFREDO B. (No. 1) HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-01073-CR

1668-00         MUNOZ, JOSE ALFREDO HARRIS COUNTY 01-94-00266-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1424-00         UPCHURCH, BRIAN PATRICK HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00683-CR

                       (JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY WOULD GRANT)

1485-00         MITCHELL, WILLIAM (DA'S NO. 1) BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-00643-CR

1574-00         CRENSHAW, JONATHAN CASEY BRAZOS COUNTY 01-99-00540-CR

                       (SPA'S)

1597-00         CABRERA, GERARDO P. (DA'S #1) HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00594-CR

                       (JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

1597-00         CABRERA, GERARDO P. (SPA'S #2) HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00594-CR

                       (JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

1606-00         GUARDIOLA, ALFREDO B. HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-01073-CR

                       (DA'S NO. 2)

1630-00         BRYANT, EDWARD R. BELL COUNTY 03-99-00787-CR



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



20,787-02         ANDREW HENRY THOMAS PANOLA COUNTY

26,047-05         LARRY GENE STRHAN DALLAS COUNTY

28,909-02         JAMES ALPHONSO MOORE GRAYSON COUNTY

31,370-02         ANTHONY WAYNE SANDLES HARRIS COUNTY

33,278-03         RICKEY JASON LITTLE HOPKINS COUNTY

34,463-02         JIMMY MEEK NUECES COUNTY

41,654-02         EDDIE D. MOORE TARRANT COUNTY

42,266-02         JO JESUS GONZALES JR. CROSBY COUNTY

42,388-02         CORDELL JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

43,457-02         LEROY EDWARD WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

44,074-02         RUSSELL M. COLLINS STEPHENS COUNTY

44,213-02         LANCE EDWARDS TRAVIS COUNTY

45,157-02         LUIS SANTOS LAGAITE WALKER COUNTY

45,345-03         LARRY STEVEN CRAIG LIBERTY COUNTY

46,360-02         GREGORY ALAN WHITE MIDLAND COUNTY

47,116-02         JOHN W. KENDRICK HARRIS COUNTY

47,388-01         ROY OUDEMS DALLAS COUNTY

47,540-01         SCOTT RYAN BERRY HARRIS COUNTY

47,568-02         KEVIN C. CORMIER DALLAS COUNTY

47,586-01         TIMOTHY JOSEPH JOST VICTORIA COUNTY

47,788-01         CHRISTOPHER WILBON LUBBOCK COUNTY

47,820-01         OPLE LEE YOUNG TARRANT COUNTY

47,863-01         JUAN JOSE GARCIA ECTOR COUNTY

47,863-02         JUAN JOSE GARCIA ECTOR COUNTY

47,917-01         GERALD F. ZANDERS DENTON COUNTY

48,004-01         JOSE ANGEL ROSALES HOCKLEY COUNTY

48,008-01         JOSE ORTIZ GARCIA HIDALGO COUNTY

48,016-01         AMECHE JAMAR SIMMONS GALVESTON COUNTY

48,021-01         ROCKY LYNN MCELWRATH WOOD COUNTY

48,026-01         CARL J. NICHOLS DALLAS COUNTY

48,072-01         CEDRIC ANTHONY REVIS HARRIS COUNTY

48,088-01         ROBERT STEPHEN ALBRIGHT WALKER COUNTY

48,112-01         JOHN MARCUS GORDY TRAVIS COUNTY

48,135-01         MICHAEL WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

12,025-02         RONALD LEE ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY

20,131-05         ARNOLD DAVILA SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

20,131-06         ARNOLD DAVILA SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

23,041-05         BOBBY MERRILL BERRY DALLAS COUNTY

29,970-02         JIMMIE CLEVELAND JESSIE, JR. DALLAS COUNTY

32,578-03         CURTIS LEE EDWARDS DALLAS COUNTY

32,800-03         PAUL D. EDWARDS JR. BEXAR COUNTY

34,008-03         RICHARD JOHN CHUBA HARRIS COUNTY

34,008-04         RICHARD JOHN CHUBA HARRIS COUNTY

40,443-02         JOHN ALBERT ESTRADA SR. DALLAS COUNTY

40,545-01         GILBERT ZAMORA BEE COUNTY

41,173-02         TERRY RAY YATES LAMAR COUNTY

42,413-03         KEVIN MOREHEAD HARRIS COUNTY

42,511-01         EARNEST DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY

43,362-04         NATHANAIL SHAW HARRIS COUNTY

46,177-02         JOHN E. NOLLEY TARRANT COUNTY

46,473-02         RONNEY EARL WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

46,817-02         MICHAEL ANDERSON DALLAS COUNTY

47,055-02         PAUL MICEK LIBERTY COUNTY

47,358-01         JOSE HUMBERTO VASQUEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,374-02         ESTEBAN DAVILA HARRIS COUNTY

47,552-01         STEVEN RENE VALADEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,554-01         TERRY SMITH JR. BELL COUNTY

47,560-01         TERRY LEE HICKS BRAZORIA COUNTY

47,582-01         DIONICIO OLIVARES CAMERON COUNTY

47,625-01         DAVID WAYNE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,625-02         DAVID WAYNE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,654-01         JUAN PABLO BARAHONA HARRIS COUNTY

47,731-01         BRENT ALAN DALTON HARRIS COUNTY

47,782-01         WENDELL T. MCCRARY DALLAS COUNTY

47,799-01         WILLIE NAPOLEON WILBURN LUBBOCK COUNTY

47,833-01         PETER HOWARD FLOYD HARRIS COUNTY

47,919-01         ALEX T. YTUARTE BEXAR COUNTY

47,920-01         LEONARD J. WALLACE DALLAS COUNTY

47,962-01         HAROLD SPURLOCK HARRIS COUNTY

47,973-01         MATEO REYMUNDO FLORES TOM GREEN COUNTY

47,989-01         DANIEL PARDON LEAL DALLAS COUNTY

47,991-01         MARCUS WAYNE HARDGE HARRIS COUNTY

47,997-01         JERMAINE LEE SCHOOLER HARRIS COUNTY

48,000-01         LUIS AGUILAR GALVESTON COUNTY

48,009-01         WILLIAM LEO DAVIS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

48,010-01         JIM WESLEY DAVIS DALLAS COUNTY

48,023-01         ERIC HINKLE TARRANT COUNTY

48,036-01         LOUDEAN CALHOUN JEFFERSON COUNTY

48,057-01         LEE MATA HARRIS COUNTY

48,064-01         RAYMOND CLOUD HARRIS COUNTY

48,070-01         RAUL MANCILLAS JR. HARRIS COUNTY

48,084-01         GILBERTO CARRIZALEZ BARRAGAN FAYETTE COUNTY

48,093-01         JOSE CAYETANO GONZALEZ HARRIS COUNTY

48,093-02         JOSE CAYETANO GONZALEZ HARRIS COUNTY

48,093-03         JOSE CAYETANO GONZALEZ HARRIS COUNTY

48,096-01         PATRICK ALBERT DOWNING LIBERTY COUNTY

48,099-01         BEN BENAVIDEZ NUECES COUNTY

48,103-01         JAMES ELMER ALSTON HARRIS COUNTY

48,116-01         ANDRES ORTIZ HARRIS COUNTY

48,119-01         TORRES D. BAILEY BELL COUNTY

48,142-01         GARY DEAN MARTINEZ TOM GREEN COUNTY

8,882-02           EMMANUEL DEAN GREENWOOD HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

22,802-03         GERALD DONNELL JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

26,922-06         DARRELL BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

29,892-09         ROY LOUIS SMITHWICK JR. WEBB COUNTY

43,057-01         GERALD WAYNE FURLOW JR. HOPKINS COUNTY

43,057-02         GERALD WAYNE FURLOW JR. HOPKINS COUNTY

43,425-01         TIMOTHY JORDAN MURPHY DALLAS COUNTY

43,615-02         MARVIN LEE THOMPSON HENDERSON COUNTY

44,156-01         STEVEN WAYNE KAY SR. TITUS COUNTY

44,682-01         BRIAN SCOTT EDDINGS TARRANT COUNTY

44,693-08         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

47,368-02         MICHAEL LEON BELL DALLAS COUNTY

47,517-01         DALE WOLF HARRIS COUNTY

47,971-01         ONEL IVAN HINOJOSA WEBB COUNTY

48,017-01         ERVIN PHILLIP TURNER DALLAS COUNTY

48,025-01         JOSEPH LEWIS DALLAS COUNTY

48,073-01         MICHAEL DEAN HAWTHORNE TARRANT COUNTY

48,110-01         CARLOS NORBERTO ARZU HARRIS COUNTY

48,114-01         NORRIS HOUSE ANGELINA COUNTY

48,141-01         ROBERT WAYNE OLVERA HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

47,787-01         JESSE S. VILLANUEVA COMAL COUNTY

47,858-01         RANDALL KEITH HARABEDOFF WICHITA COUNTY

47,935-02         THOMAS FREDERICK BONNER WOOD COUNTY

48,039-01         WINDELL FOUNTAIN SMITH COUNTY

48,085-01         FERNANDO MALDONADO DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

24,297-06         MICHAEL ANTHONY HUGHES DALLAS COUNTY

24,297-07         MICHAEL ANTHONY HUGHES DALLAS COUNTY

28,496-05         DANNIE LEE MITCHELL LUBBOCK COUNTY

32,517-03         RONALD E. WOODCOCK MCLENNAN COUNTY

35,903-05         MICHAEL WAYNE OSBORNE JEFFERSON COUNTY

43,041-02         QUINCY EDWARDS JEFFERSON COUNTY

43,517-02         RICHARD W. LUECK MONTGOMERY COUNTY

44,693-06         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-07         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-09         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,992-03         BILLY DARNELL JACOBS CASS COUNTY

9,534-19           WILLIAM E. SPAULDING III JACKSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

11,620-02         CARL HOORNEART JEFFERSON COUNTY

13,455-04         ERVIN EDWARD KINGSBURY, III TARRANT COUNTY

37,914-02         RODDIE DARRELL TAVE TARRANT COUNTY

46,011-02         JOHN LEDESMA CORYELL COUNTY

47,361-05         ROMONA MINGETTI HARRIS COUNTY

47,392-02         RANDY BURK JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

47,537-02         LAURA ANN MILLER HARRIS COUNTY

47,790-01         RANDY ROBERT MARAS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,915-01         RICHARD C. FININEN DALLAS COUNTY

47,924-01         DAVID HANCHEY TARRANT COUNTY

47,924-02         DAVID HANCHEY ORANGE COUNTY

47,924-03         DAVID HANCHEY ORANGE COUNTY

47,924-04         DAVID HANCHEY ORANGE COUNTY

47,924-05         DAVID HANCHEY POLK COUNTY

47,983-01         JIM JAMES MOST DALLAS COUNTY

48,006-01         WILLIAM A. VANWINKLE III KAUFMAN COUNTY

48,022-01         JOHN THOMAS JONES TARRANT COUNTY

48,024-01         DANIEL LESTER TARRANT COUNTY

48,028-01         DANIEL RAY JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY

48,030-01         JEAN MARION CHAVEZ BRAZORIA COUNTY

48,041-01         BRYAN EDWARD BOATRIGHT NUECES COUNTY

48,049-01         NOAH TENNON JUNIOR DALLAS COUNTY

48,068-01         TERRENCE DARNEL WILLIAMS MCLENNAN COUNTY

48,078-01         MELVIN JENKINS III ECTOR COUNTY

48,094-01         ALLEN GAY AUSTIN BELL COUNTY

48,101-01         RODNEY DEWAYNE FLADD HENDERSON COUNTY

48,106-01         BADIH AHMAD TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:



45,553-01         JIMMY THOMAS MCBRIDE DENTON COUNTY

46,011-01         JOHN LEDESMA MCLENNAN COUNTY

47,144-01         GARLAND FLEMING DAWSON COUNTY

47,485-01         ANTHONY HYPOLITE HARRIS COUNTY

47,585-01         TIMOTHY ERIC DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

45,570-01         KEITH DUANE TOWLES PARKER COUNTY

46,664-01         THOMAS MICHAEL VANCE DENTON COUNTY

47,373-01         JESSIE CATES STEPHENS COUNTY

47,382-01         NOE GARCIA JR. GALVESTON COUNTY

47,907-01         ROCKY DEONDRE BAILEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,931-01         DAVID JOHN MAURIN DALLAS COUNTY

47,984-01         ALBERT RAMIREZ BEXAR COUNTY

48,071-01         PAUL WILLIAM SEAR HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

22,072-33         RONALD RAY REID COUNTY

26,047-04         LARRY GENE STRHAN DALLAS COUNTY

34,008-02         RICHARD JOHN CHUBA HARRIS COUNTY

43,655-04         RAFAEL ALVARO PRIETO TARRANT COUNTY

44,992-02         BILLY DARNELL JACOBS COUNTY

46,244-02         CARL NOLDEN COUNTY

46,573-01         RICHARD JAXSON LUBBOCK COUNTY

46,817-01         MICHAEL ANDERSON DALLAS COUNTY

47,132-01         JIMMY CLYD DAUGHTERY DALLAS COUNTY

47,368-01         MICHAEL LEON BELL DALLAS COUNTY

47,374-01         ESTEBAN DAVILA HARRIS COUNTY

47,392-01         RANDY BURK JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

47,568-01         KEVIN C. CORMIER DALLAS COUNTY

48,179-01         MICHAEL SNEED TAYLOR COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

36,313-02         DONTRAUN DEMOND HOLLINS DENTON COUNTY

44,751-02         CHARLES R. WHITE HARRIS COUNTY

46,301-02         MATTHEW PAUL LESLIE DALLAS COUNTY

46,301-03         MATTHEW PAUL LESLIE DALLAS COUNTY

46,819-01         MICHAEL ALLEN JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

48,018-01         LORENSO SOLOSANO BURNET COUNTY

48,077-01         LEON HARRISON HARRIS COUNTY

48,098-01         WYLMON BOUDREAUX HARRIS COUNTY

48,121-01         KEVIN WAYNE DICKSON DALLAS COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



47,444-02         MARIA DOLORES ALCORN FORT BEND COUNTY