THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


MARCH 15, 2000



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:



72,807         RAYMOND LEVI COBB FROM WALKER COUNTY

REVERSED AND REMANDED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK

(JUDGES KELLER AND KEASLER JOIN)

PUBLISHED OPINION

73,045         MARK SAM ARTHUR FROM HARRIS COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,731         EX PARTE JOSEPH JOHN JACKSON FROM POTTER COUNTY

73,732         EX PARTE ERVIN LOUIS STARKS FROM AUSTIN COUNTY

73,733         EX PARTE TRAVIS BERNARD STERLING FROM JOHNSON COUNTY

73,734         EX PARTE ROBERT BATY FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,735         EX PARTE JESSE LEE CLINTON, JR. FROM BELL COUNTY

73,736         EX PARTE CHRISSY ANN LOZANO FROM GUADALUPE COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0004-00         CRAMER, DENNIS LEE DALLAS COUNTY 08-97-00599-CR

0008-00         MCCRARY, WENDELL TODD DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00755-CR

0009-00         LUMPKIN, CHARLES RAY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01076-CR

0010-00         HERNANDEZ, GAIL PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-98-00215-CR

0011-00         HERNANDEZ, GAIL PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-98-00216-CR

0013-00         NORTON, EDWIN KIEST, JR. COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00668-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0015-00         WELCH, RAY MCKINLEY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01244-CR

0016-00         HASKIN, MICHELLE LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00730-CR

0017-00         LOPEZ, DEMETRIO HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00060-CR

0019-00         COUCH, AUDIE EUGENE PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-98-00165-CR

0020-00         COUCH, AUDIE EUGENE PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-98-00166-CR

0021-00         SLATON, PAUL LENARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00679-CR

0023-00         FERGUSON, MARLOUS BARNARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00857-CR

0024-00         ESCOBAR, SERGIO FORT BEND COUNTY 14-97-01295-CR

0028-00         TRIPLETT, STEPHEN MARK HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00515-CR

0029-00         HARRIS, CARL BERNARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01375-CR

0030-00         WALLER, ANTHONY WASHINGTON COUNTY 14-97-00532-CR

0031-00         MORENO, DOMINGO JOSEPH BROWN COUNTY 11-98-00149-CR

0032-00         CROCKER, CHARLES RICHARD YOUNG COUNTY 02-98-00246-CR

0033-00         PORTER, MICHAEL DEAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00533-CR

0035-00         STEWART, JOHN RANDALL SMITH COUNTY 12-98-00288-CR

0041-00         LAVON, DAMON HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00298-CR

0042-00         CHEUNG, ALEN LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00975-CR

0043-00         ALVARADO, JOHNNY HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-01507-CR

0044-00         RANDOLPH, CLARENCE DUTCH HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00777-CR

0046-00         GARZA, RAUL HECTOR HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01308-CR

0151-00         ARNOLD, PRESTON BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 11-97-00393-CR

0152-00         ARNOLD, PRESTON BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 11-97-00394-CR

0153-00         ARNOLD, PRESTON BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 11-97-00395-CR

0236-00         CASTRO, BART GONZALES TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00570-CR

0241-00         ESPINOSA, FELIX MOJICA HALE COUNTY 07-99-00465-CR

0245-00         ELLIS, JOSEPH JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00274-CR

0338-00         LOPEZ, JOSE OMAR HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01441-CR

1826-99         MURATALLA, AGUSTIN, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00486-CR

1841-99         VALLE, GILBERTO HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00359-CR

                       (JUDGE KELLER WOULD GRANT)

1940-99         COUCHMAN, ANTHONY ALLAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00116-CR

2141-99         GUFFEY, CHRISTOPHER ANGELINA COUNTY 09-99-00140-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0089-00         BACK, EX PARTE BRIAN NAVARRO COUNTY 10-99-00266-CR

0150-00         ARNOLD, PRESTON BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY 11-97-00392-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0552-00         GARCIA, ELOY UVALDE COUNTY 04-99-00101-CR


STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

1682-99         DANA MARIE CONTRERAS POTTER COUNTY 07-97-00487-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

33,098-02         JAMES DAVID GRAHAM TRAVIS COUNTY

37,617-03         DANNY GENE ESTES NAVARRO COUNTY

37,617-04         DANNY GENE ESTES NAVARRO COUNTY

37,629-02         ADICUS LYNN MERCER ECTOR COUNTY

38,189-02         EARNEST LUM JR. DENNIS CHEROKEE COUNTY

42,838-02         WELTON KING III DALLAS COUNTY

44,348-01         MARTIN VALENZUELA TARRANT COUNTY

44,370-01         MILTON HILL GREENLAND HARRIS COUNTY

44,425-01         TIMOTHY SHA'MELL NEWSOME TARRANT COUNTY

44,439-01         DONALD WAYNE JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY

44,466-01         CHARLEY N. WHITE NUECES COUNTY

44,470-01         CARLOS PACHECO TARRANT COUNTY

44,531-01         MIGUEL GARZA NUECES COUNTY

44,591-01         JAMES DOYLE STEPHENS TARRANT COUNTY

44,625-01         ERNEST SMITH JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

44,649-01         MANUEL CLERKLEY ANDERSON COUNTY

44,667-01         NATHAN DWIGHT GRANT DALLAS COUNTY

44,668-01         ZACHARY BRAHM TRAVIS COUNTY

44,676-01         KENNETH GEASLIN NOLAN COUNTY

44,678-01         DANIEL FRED BROWN POTTER COUNTY

44,678-02         DANIEL FRED BROWN POTTER COUNTY

44,714-01         JUAN FLORES DEAF SMITH COUNTY

44,715-01         VICTOR RAMON PAZ DALLAS COUNTY

44,716-01         ANTHONY ELIFF MADISON COUNTY

44,717-01         JEAMES L. SPURLOCK SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

44,722-01         KENNETH PEARSON VICTORIA COUNTY

44,722-02         KENNETH PEARSON VICTORIA COUNTY

44,723-01         CHRISTOPHER PAUL BOCKHOLT FORT BEND COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

16,835-02         THOMAS ANTHONY BROUSSARD HARRIS COUNTY

22,654-03         ZACHARY VON DAVIS BELL COUNTY

44,323-01         JOSE M. GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

44,323-02         JOSE M. GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

44,417-01         TONY GARCIA ROSALES DALLAS COUNTY

44,427-01         ERVIN L. WHIPPLE JR. BEXAR COUNTY

44,427-02         ERVIN L. WHIPPLE JR. BEXAR COUNTY

44,429-01         CECIL CAYCE TRAVIS COUNTY

44,438-01         PHILLIP EDWARD LINDSTROM GALVESTON COUNTY

44,447-01         DARRELL O'KEEFE GARRETT DALLAS COUNTY

44,494-01         GIANG VAN TRAN TARRANT COUNTY

44,496-01         ROBERT CHAPA BEXAR COUNTY

44,573-01         JUAN GABRIEL GARCIA CAMERON COUNTY

44,587-01         MARCOS SAVEDRA DALLAS COUNTY

44,588-01         JOHNNY B. WILLIAMSON JR. TOM GREEN COUNTY

44,602-01         JOSE ANGEL JASSO CAMERON COUNTY

44,604-01         EDUARDO ARRIETA DALLAS COUNTY

44,638-01         TONY BARGAS DALLAM COUNTY

44,653-02         STEPHEN ALLEN FOX PALO PINTO COUNTY

44,656-01         EUGENE CHRISTOPHER DOLD BELL COUNTY

44,658-01         BRYAN SCOTT HEUER BRAZOS COUNTY

44,658-02         BRYAN SCOTT HEUER BRAZOS COUNTY

44,658-03         BRYAN SCOTT HEUER BRAZOS COUNTY

44,665-01         EARNEST CARL WRIGHT WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

44,693-01         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-02         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-03         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-04         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,693-05         ARTURO BEJARANO EL PASO COUNTY

44,703-01         GREGORY ALAN KELLEY DALLAS COUNTY

44,734-01         LAMONT A. BUGGS TRAVIS COUNTY

44,745-01         JEREMY WADE LANGE HARRIS COUNTY

44,746-01         GEORGE JOSEPH MUDGE DALLAS COUNTY

44,755-01         JOSE ARTURO MONTOYA WARD COUNTY

44,758-01         KEITH ALLEN FORD BELL COUNTY

44,828-01         CRAIG CHRIST JEFFERSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)

39,022-02         WILLIAM CHAVEZ BEXAR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

42,209-02         FREDDIE LONGORIA MATAGORDA COUNTY

44,437-01         CATHI ANNE LOFTUS TARRANT COUNTY

44,459-01         DANIEL JAY SANFORD TARRANT COUNTY

44,623-01         LOUIS MORALES JR. GALVESTON COUNTY

44,635-01         LUIS ALEJANDRO ORTIZ EL PASO COUNTY

44,636-01         CLARENCE R. BRYANT WICHITA COUNTY

44,655-01         JAMES DEAN BAXTER DALLAS COUNTY

44,685-01         JACKIE TERRY DEAF SMITH COUNTY

44,702-01         BELEN VILLARREAL FERNANDEZ DEAF SMITH COUNTY

44,704-01         PAUL EUGENE SAMPSON BRAZORIA COUNTY

44,708-01         DENORICE FLEMMING DALLAS COUNTY

44,712-01         RANDALL WAYNE BRADBERRY TAYLOR COUNTY

44,718-01         JOHN DUHART NUECES COUNTY

44,720-01         GEORGE B. FAREMOUTH III BURLESON COUNTY

44,726-01         RICKEY RAY DISNEY JOHNSON COUNTY

44,727-01         MARK DALE DUGAS JASPER COUNTY

44,729-01         DEXTER JENKINS DALLAS COUNTY

44,731-01         RUSSELL KEITH OVERDIRTH ELLIS COUNTY

44,735-01         JOE DALE GIBSON YOUNG COUNTY

44,736-01         WINDELL RAY CORNELIUS OCHILTREE COUNTY

44,739-01         LEON WESLEY MULLHATTEN ECTOR COUNTY

44,791-01         ELWIN ANTHONY COOK MILAM COUNTY

44,795-01         BRYAN SCOTT CAVETT HAMILTON COUNTY

44,823-01         HOWARD RENAE SHEPPARD JR. WICHITA COUNTY

44,824-01         MARSHALL VANDYKE MATAGORDA COUNTY

7,718-03         LARRY WHITTLEY TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

19,721-07         CALVIN RAY HYDER DALLAS COUNTY

20,786-06         RUBIN NOTHA MCNEELY DALLAS COUNTY

20,786-07         RUBIN NOTHA MCNEELY DALLAS COUNTY

22,480-05         JEROME HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY

43,401-02         RAUL MARTINEZ BEXAR COUNTY

43,962-02         JOSEPH THOMAS COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

19,704-02         RICHARD MALLARD, JR. DALLAS COUNTY

35,958-03         ZACK HAMILTON HARRIS COUNTY

44,160-01         DONALD EARL NICHOLS HOPKINS COUNTY

44,231-01         WILBERT WALKER HOUSTON COUNTY

44,559-01         JOSE LUIS GRANADO BALDERRAMA CASTRO COUNTY

44,603-01         DAVID MARTINEZ SOSA CAMERON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

42,592-01         ERVIN LOUIS STARKS AUSTIN COUNTY

43,309-01         CHRISSY ANN LOZANO GUADALUPE COUNTY

43,558-01         JOSEPH JOHN JACKSON POTTER COUNTY

44,320-01         TRAVIS BERNARD STERLING JOHNSON COUNTY

44,420-01         ROBERT BATY HARRIS COUNTY

44,605-01         JESSE LEE CLINTON BELL COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

25,869-30         RONALD DWAYNE WHITFIELD HARRIS COUNTY

30,265-03         THOMAS BUSTER TRAVIS COUNTY

42,838-03         WELTON KING, III DALLAS COUNTY

44,338-01         ANTHONY MONTGOMERY HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

43,025-02         DEVIN PAUL COLE JEFFERSON COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

06,208-09         RICKY EUGENE MORROW DALLAS COUNTY