THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



APRIL 24, 2002





THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:









73,963         EXZAVIER LAMONT STEVENSON FROM HARRIS COUNTY

                    AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:



73,654         DOUGLAS ALAN FELDMAN FROM DALLAS COUNTY



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



2124-00       RAFAEL GARZA MARTINEZ JACKSON COUNTY 13-99-00351-CR

REMAND TO THE COURT OF APPEALS-OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE WOMACK DISSENTED)

DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGE HERVEY JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



0420-01       KENT G. WASHBURN BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00927-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS-PER CURIAM OPINION

(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION





ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0373-01       LIONEL SIMPSON ANDERSON COUNTY 12-00-00235-CR

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON GROUNDS 1 & 2);

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS-PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:



1181-01         SHIRLEY CLARK LABLANCHE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-01363-CR

1735-01         HENRY VONDRA WILBORN DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-00721-CR

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



2099-01       RANDALL NORMAN KELLAR DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01963-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 3 ONLY)

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

2181-01       JACQUELINE G. STEVENSON-GRAY BRAZOS COUNTY 14-00-00996-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 1 & 2 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

2243-01         JOHN THOMAS MITSCHKE BRAZOS COUNTY 14-99-00747-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0499-01         LEON HAMPTON, JR. ECTOR COUNTY 08-00-00045-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

 

2058-00         HALBROOK, WILLIAM DENTON COUNTY 02-99-00267-CR

                       (JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

1727-01         PELICAN, BELINDA RENAE HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-01398-CR

2233-01         BUERGER, MARK E. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00928-CR

2234-01         JOHNSON, ALFRED EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01130-CR

2235-01         JOHNSON, ALFRED EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01131-CR

2236-01         WILSON, JACKIE GALVESTON COUNTY 14-99-01077-CR

2449-01         JONES, FREDDY TAMON DALLAS COUNTY 08-00-00021-CR

2481-01         HARDGE, R. T. HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01095-CR

                       (JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)

2482-01         ELLIOTT, TORRY WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-00847-CR

2489-01         WITHERSPOON, EDWIN HORTON TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00524-CR

2505-01         WILLIAMS, KARIS FELIX SMITH COUNTY 12-99-00172-CR

0020-02         VARGAS, JUAN C. EL PASO COUNTY 08-99-00344-CR

0041-02         GREEN, LEONARD EARL HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00710-CR

0047-02         WEATHERBY, NICK EUGENE TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00219-CR

0075-02         ARAUS, ROGOBERTO GONZALES HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01362-CR

0109-02         CONTRERAS, DANA MARIE POTTER COUNTY 07-97-00487-CR

                       (JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

0139-02         GOTTSCHLICH, DEVI CLAIRE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00324-CR

0140-02         PIAZZA, NICOLE RENEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01958-CR

0141-02         PHY, MELISSA KAYE DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01959-CR

0150-02         NINO, ANGELA PATE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00327-CR

0249-02         OTT, JEFFREY MICHAEL DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01840-CR

0250-02         OTT, JEFFREY MICHAEL DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01841-CR

0251-02         REED, MICHAEL DOUGLAS DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01812-CR

0282-02         MCDERMOTT, HERBERT CURTIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-01268-CR

0288-02         SHILLING, CHARLES MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-00-00379-CR

0468-02         VINEYARD, JAY BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00728-CR

0496-02         GREEN, JIMMY JOE, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01642-CR

0499-02         LILES, JOHN RICHARD BELL COUNTY 03-02-00060-CR

0500-02         LILES, JOHN RICHARD BELL COUNTY 03-02-00081-CR

0505-02         ABRAMS, MIA HARRIS COUNTY 14-00-01295-CR

0540-02         JACKSON, KENNETH E., JR. VAN ZANDT COUNTY 12-00-00312-CR

0541-02         MCNEAL, STEVE D. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00267-CR

 

 

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

 

2337-01         SMITH, WILLIE ROBERT, JR. BRAZOS COUNTY 14-00-01356-CR

2504-01         CHAMPION, ANTHONY J. NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00383-CR

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

 

 

0061-02         LUKASIK, KENNETH ALLEN G. COMAL COUNTY 03-01-00125-CR

0167-02         ROBERTSON, MICHAEL LEE DALLAS COUNTY 12-99-00239-CR

0168-02         ROBERTSON, MICHAEL LEE DALLAS COUNTY 12-00-00076-CR

0204-02         CRUZ, ANDRES GUTIERREZ STARR COUNTY 04-99-00801-CR



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

10,625-08         GARY REED WALP DALLAS COUNTY

13,315-06         JERRY GLENN MORRIS TRINITY COUNTY

14,137-05         NATHANIEL WASHINGTON TARRANT COUNTY

17,545-05         STEVEN GILBERT JASPER COUNTY

33,007-06         BURNS TILTON BOYD CHEROKEE COUNTY

35,392-03         ERMONT D. MILES BEXAR COUNTY

37,099-04         LELAND ZANE WOODARD TARRANT COUNTY

38,382-02         JACKIE RAY FULLER UPSHUR COUNTY

42,225-02         SHAYNE CROSBY TARRANT COUNTY

43,391-02         ROSENDO MONTANA JR. HOWARD COUNTY

46,964-02         JANIE M. SENEGAR WASHINGTON COUNTY

46,966-02         NATE JUAREZ TARRANT COUNTY

47,132-04         JIMMY CLYDE DARUGHTERY DALLAS COUNTY

48,927-02         TOMMY LEE POWELL HARRIS COUNTY

48,942-02         RONALD EUGENE TRADWELL HARRIS COUNTY

48,942-03         RONALD EUGENE TRADWELL HARRIS COUNTY

49,443-02         JESSE CLAY SCOTT BEXAR COUNTY

49,474-02         VALENTIN MORENO JR. HIDALGO COUNTY

49,784-03         SANTIAGO JR. RAMIREZ EL PASO COUNTY

50,205-03         DAVID ALAN HYDER COLLIN COUNTY

50,881-02         MARKEITH DONUAL JACKSON DALLAS COUNTY

51,294-01         ANDY NAVARRO EL PASO COUNTY

51,436-01         IDEHEN AMAS IGBINOBA DALLAS COUNTY

51,436-02         IDEHEN AMAS IGBINOBA DALLAS COUNTY

51,436-03         IDEHEN AMAS IGBINOBA DALLAS COUNTY

51,436-04         IDEHEN AMAS IGBINOBA DALLAS COUNTY

51,744-01         DARRIN HUNTER DALLAS COUNTY

51,769-01         KEVIN LLOYD MCCUISTION BASTROP COUNTY

51,775-01         DONALD RAY WILSON HARRIS COUNTY

51,785-01         JOHN HEARN NOLLIE HARRIS COUNTY

51,878-01         JUAQUIN YSLA JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

51,945-01         SHAWN HOWARD BEXAR COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

51,946-01         MARK VERNON RODRIGUES JEFFERSON COUNTY

51,946-02         MARK VERNON RODRIGUES JEFFERSON COUNTY

51,950-01         ROBERT VILLANUEVA TRAVIS COUNTY

51,966-01         RICARDO WALTER DANES TARRANT COUNTY

51,977-01         MARVIN LESTER WINDOM HARRIS COUNTY

51,989-01         KEITH ANDREW GILBERT MATAGORDA COUNTY

52,007-01         CALVIN RAY ELKINS COLLIN COUNTY

52,013-01         PATTON RANDALL STEPP JOHNSON COUNTY

52,048-01         DARIAN RECHARD BROUSSARD DALLAS COUNTY

52,051-01         JOSE NAUN ZUNIGA HARRIS COUNTY

52,073-01         TROY GLENN JONES POLK COUNTY

52,079-01         LUIS CARLOS ALVARADO EL PASO COUNTY

52,102-01         WILLIAM IVEY FOSHEE JR. NUECES COUNTY

52,116-01         SHONQUE RA-DON LUKE TARRANT COUNTY

52,124-01         VICTOR CANTU JR. COLLIN COUNTY

52,124-02         VICTOR CANTU JR. COLLIN COUNTY

52,131-01         JOHN CHARLES HOYO DENTON COUNTY

52,131-02         JOHN CHARLES HOYO DENTON COUNTY

52,139-01         PAUL CHARLES STIMEL JACKSON COUNTY

52,190-01         BARI JEROME SKINNER JR. GREGG COUNTY

52,230-01         MARION PHILLIPS FREESTONE COUNTY

52,230-02         MARION PHILLIPS FREESTONE COUNTY

52,231-01         BRUCE JAMES STREY GUADALUPE COUNTY

52,232-01         TYRONE ANTHONY HUTCHINSON TRAVIS COUNTY

52,234-01         FLOYD EUGENE BURROUGHS TARRANT COUNTY




APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

 

12,647-03         JOHN HENRY MONEY, JR. DALLAS COUNTY

27,836-19         GEORGE W. RIECK JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

42,718-02         JAMES CHARLES SMITH HARRIS COUNTY

45,832-02         HENRY DEE GILMORE GALVESTON COUNTY

48,212-02         KELVIN DEARL DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY

48,260-03         JEFFERSON RICHARD ROBINSON BEXAR COUNTY

50,993-02         AARON RUTLEDGE DALLAS COUNTY

51,260-03         BENJAMIN ARGUS DIEZ TOM GREEN COUNTY

51,260-04         BENJAMIN ARGUS DIEZ TOM GREEN COUNTY

51,341-01         JOHN ALAN CONROY FREESTONE COUNTY

51,465-02         SAMUEL CHAMBERS DALLAS COUNTY

51,485-02         EVERADO VASQUEZ HARRIS COUNTY

51,677-01         LAUD RICHARD NELSON HARRIS COUNTY

51,741-01         CLINTON WAYNE BASS HARRIS COUNTY

51,835-02         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-03         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-04         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-05         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-06         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-07         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-08         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-09         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-10         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-11         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-12         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-13         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-14         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-15         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

51,843-01         DONALD EDWARD PERKINS HARRIS COUNTY

51,870-01         JESUS ANTONIO ARBALLO-MARQUEZ MIDLAND COUNTY

51,892-01         JOHN EARL PATTERSON DALLAS COUNTY

51,923-01         JERRY JERMAINE WHITE TARRANT COUNTY

51,925-01         JOSEPH BROOKS HARRIS COUNTY

51,940-01         WILLIE JR. LLOYD TOM GREEN COUNTY

51,969-01         MANTRA EVANS MCLENNAN COUNTY

51,972-01         TOMMY LYNN JAMES HARRIS COUNTY

51,986-01         RAYMOND FITZPATRICK HARRIS COUNTY

51,996-01         JOSE LOPEZ VILLARREAL BRAZORIA COUNTY

51,996-02         JOSE LOPEZ VILLARREAL BRAZORIA COUNTY

51,998-01         FERRELL RAY GOODWIN MCLENNAN COUNTY

52,002-01         JEREMY COLE HARRIS COUNTY

52,028-01         CARLOS ISAIAS ESTRADA DALLAS COUNTY

52,089-01         ANTHONY JOSEPH GREEN JEFFERSON COUNTY

52,121-01         JAVIER RAMIREZ SANTACRUZ GRAY COUNTY

52,123-01         TELISA DEANN BLACKMAN DALLAS COUNTY

52,180-01         WILLIAM MAVERICK SHAW HARRIS COUNTY

52,191-01         GERALD WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

52,194-01         LLOYD KOEHLER HARRIS COUNTY

52,201-01         GILBERTO CABEZAS VALENCIA HARRIS COUNTY

52,203-01         ROBERT CHARLES BATISTE HARRIS COUNTY

52,220-01         BENJAMIN LEONARD BLACKBURN TRAVIS COUNTY

52,269-01         DEXTER BROWN HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

33,007-05         BURNS TILTON BOYD CHEROKEE COUNTY

33,295-08         ROBERTO GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

52,100-01         DERELL DWAYNE ANDERSON DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

 

 

14,921-16         ARTHUR E. JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

50,574-01         JOSEPH RAYMOND COPLEY HARRIS COUNTY

52,015-01         EDWARD K. LAFONTAINE CAMERON COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

 

 

14,286-05         FRANKLIN HENRY THOMPSON COLEMAN COUNTY

15,097-09         ZACHARY ALEXANDER DALLAS COUNTY

20,032-03         RANDALL EARL COLLINS DALLAS COUNTY

20,039-07         CHRIS LEE WEST HARRIS COUNTY

22,550-07         BARRY NEAL WOODS COLORADO COUNTY

22,735-20         ALFRED LEE STONE POTTER COUNTY

23,518-03         WILLIE EARL JOHNSON HUNT COUNTY

25,942-04         CHARLES EDWARD MCCLOUD DALLAS COUNTY

26,085-06         LOUIS BRADLEY STREDIC BRAZORIA COUNTY

26,242-02         JOSEPH K. BLACK TRAVIS COUNTY

27,554-03         ERICE LEWIS MACK DALLAS COUNTY

28,002-09         FREDERICK LOUIS PUGH HARRIS COUNTY

30,187-10         DONALD PENCE PRUITT DALLAS COUNTY

34,471-03         FRED ANDREW BERRY COMANCHE COUNTY

40,341-05         KENNETH DEWAYNE FORD DALLAS COUNTY

43,767-02         JIMMY LEE TRAHAN BEXAR COUNTY

                         (JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

44,027-02         EARL ALBERT KIRSOVALDEZ HARRIS COUNTY

45,195-02         LEON TRAVIS HURD DALLAS COUNTY

45,852-02         JAMES ROLAND MARTIN DENTON COUNTY

48,218-02         AARON DEWAYNE FLETCHER HARRIS COUNTY

49,833-02         KENNETH ENGLISH JR. DALLAS COUNTY

50,205-02         DAVID ALAN HYDER COLLIN COUNTY

50,533-04         LUCAS BERMEA CONSTANCIO HALE COUNTY

51,482-02         MICKEY WAYNE BRANDON TARRANT COUNTY

 



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

 

 

15,045-04         HERMAN PALMER JEFFERSON COUNTY

51,930-01         HARVEY AUBREY ROBERTSON NEWTON COUNTY

51,965-01         DUSTIN LEBLANC ORANGE COUNTY

51,980-01         CLARENCE EUGENE JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

52,017-01         CRAIG GLOUDE JEFFERSON COUNTY

52,041-01         PATRICK DEWAYNE MCDONALD TRAVIS COUNTY

52,088-01         JAMES CALVIN BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

52,113-01         KENNETH WAYNE MADDUX MONTGOMERY COUNTY

52,167-01         CURTIS SPRUELL TRAVIS COUNTY

52,212-01         RICHARD GATEWOOD TARRANT COUNTY

52,216-01         JAMES SEITH GRUBBS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

52,249-01         FREDDIE LEE JOHNSON MONTGOMERY COUNTY

52,266-01         L.C. SMITH JR. TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

 

51,838-01         ARTURO DANIEL POTTER COUNTY

51,838-02         ARTURO DANIEL POTTER COUNTY

52,066-01         RICKEY DEAN ROBINSON KAUFMAN COUNTY

52,153-01         AURELIO VEGA PALACIOS HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

 

36,709-03         JOSEPH FREDERICK DUCRE HARRIS COUNTY

50,487-02         MARK ANTHONY BURGESS COUNTY

51,953-01         FELIX DAVID HERRERA COUNTY

52,004-01         ANTHONY F. HOUSTON HARRIS COUNTY

52,114-01         WAVIL BERNARD LEWIS HIDALGO COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

11,623-05         DAVID WAYNE FORD GREGG COUNTY

12,287-06         WILLIAM LAWRENCE BARBEE JACKSON COUNTY

12,375-12         HERBERT FEIST JEFFERSON COUNTY

14,226-03         LEE C. BLUITT HARRIS COUNTY

16,427-84         DAMON HENRY DOWNS HARRIS COUNTY

25,182-05         TERRANCE HOWARD HAZEL TRAVIS COUNTY

26,626-06         ROBERT JUNIUS FREEMAN HARRIS COUNTY

27,821-07         LESLIE RAY FOSTER COUNTY

35,322-05         EDWARD HILL ORANGE COUNTY

35,392-04         ERMONT D. MILES COUNTY

37,938-02         SAUL MARINO PATINO COUNTY

39,585-02         BILLY RAY WELCH SAN AUGUSTINE COUNTY

44,130-02         JERRY DALE COLEMAN TARRANT COUNTY

45,048-02         RONALD C. CURTIS TRAVIS COUNTY

50,187-02         RICHARD WAYNE GRAY JR. COUNTY

50,993-01         AARON RUTLEDGE DALLAS COUNTY

51,616-02         WINFRED JEROME JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

51,699-01         RONNIE BENFORD DALLAS COUNTY

51,835-01         CHRISTOPHER ALBERT ZELENS DALLAS COUNTY

52,152-01         WENDELL EUGENE HENRY DALLAS COUNTY

52,160-01         ROBERT DONALD BOREN CARSON COUNTY

52,181-01         DON SHELBY FANNIN COUNTY

52,222-01         JUAN ANTONIO GUERRA JR BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

 

46,736-02         NANON MCKEWN WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY



ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



36,380-02             GERALD DEWIGHT CASEY MONTGOMERY COUNTY

(MOTION FOR STAY OF EXECUTION DENIED)

(JUDGES WOMACK, JOHNSON AND HOLCOMB NOT PARTICIPATING)

(DENIED APRIL 18, 2002)

 

48,152-02             GARCIA GLEN WHITE HARRIS COUNTY



ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



35,410-02         WILLIE TERION WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

                          (REMANDED ON SECOND ALLEGATION)



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



44,026-03         CHEYENNE PATE LIMESTONE COUNTY



ORDER ENTERED ON REQUEST FOR ANSWERS TO CERTIFIED STATE CRIMINAL LAW QUESTIONS:



30,119-09         WARREN PIERRE CANADY HARRIS COUNTY