THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


JULY 26, 2000


THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:


HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINION S BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED)


73,846         EX PARTE TIMOTHY JOHN LIMON FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                    (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

73,847         EX PARTE HOWARD CHARLES THOMAS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,848         EX PARTE ANTONIO P. GARCIA FROM BEXAR COUNTY



APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY

REVIEW IS DENIED:



0783-00         TARGUINO, RICHARD HUGO GALVESTON COUNTY 01-98-01316-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



0514-00         ELLISON, EUGENE, JR. CALDWELL COUNTY 03-98-00602-CR

0525-00         HANSON, JAMES ALLEN TARRANT COUNTY 11-98-00138-CR

0566-00         RODRIGUEZ, YIMINSON V. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00118-CR

0603-00         MARTINEZ, RICK A. BRAZOS COUNTY 14-98-01377-CR

0609-00         WHITE, ANTHONY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01071-CR

0655-00         KHODABANDEH, CIROOS TRAVIS COUNTY 03-99-00104-CR

0723-00         HOLIDAY, PRENTICE A. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00807-CR

0746-00         RIVERS, SILVESTER EARL HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00332-CR

0757-00         KELLY, RANDY FERREL HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00972-CR

0758-00         KELLY, RANDY FERREL HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00973-CR

0762-00         DESHAIS, ARMAND PHILIP HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00701-CR

0763-00         ALVARADO, PHILLIP, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00102-CR

0764-00         ALVARADO, PHILLIP, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00103-CR

0765-00         SANDER, JACOB HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00267-CR

0807-00         MCCOY, PRINCE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-02085-CR

0808-00         TRACY, BILLY JOEL ROCKWALL COUNTY 05-98-01618-CR

0809-00         TRACY, BILLY JOEL ROCKWALL COUNTY 05-98-01619-CR

0810-00         TRACY, BILLY JOEL ROCKWALL COUNTY 05-98-01620-CR

0816-00         SHAW, JOHN BEXAR COUNTY 03-99-00253-CR

0817-00         BADER, MICHEAL TRAVIS COUNTY 03-99-00014-CR

0821-00         STEINBERGER, FREDRICK D. ARCHER COUNTY 02-98-00349-CR

0822-00         BASALDU, CRUZ TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00621-CR

0823-00         GOEBEL, WILLIAM DALE DENTON COUNTY 02-99-00014-CR

0825-00         CRUZ, TOMAS FRANCO COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00960-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0826-00         CRUZ, TOMAS FRANCO COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00963-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0827-00         CRUZ, TOMAS FRANCO COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00965-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0829-00         HART, JEROME HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00361-CR

0830-00         JACKSON, STEPHON LAGRAND HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00671-CR

0837-00         HALL, LINDA RUTH HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00307-CR

0839-00         PARKER, LUTHER LEVELL HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00265-CR

0840-00         BURTON, MICHAEL ALLEN HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00458-CR

0841-00         VALENCIA, JOEL PULIDO HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00449-CR

0844-00         SONYA, REED NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-99-00279-CR

0846-00         HAE, SUK YE DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01013-CR

0849-00         RUIZ, JUAN JOSE HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01013-CR

0850-00         WEAVER, CALVIN EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00243-CR

0851-00         JACKSON, WALTER CRAIG HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00823-CR

0852-00         GOMEZ, RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01000-CR

0853-00         GOMEZ, RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01001-CR

0858-00         HICKS, LAURANCE ALLEN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00009-CR

0859-00         HICKS, LAURANCE ALLEN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00010-CR

0860-00         LOWERY, PHILLIP POLK COUNTY 09-99-00071-CR

0863-00         BALDEMAR, JIMENEZ BEXAR COUNTY 07-97-00297-CR

0868-00         HINSON, BILLEY GENE, JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY 06-99-00049-CR

0869-00         BUNN, JOE MICHAEL UPSHUR COUNTY 06-99-00022-CR

0870-00         ZERVOS, THEODORE SAM HOPKINS COUNTY 06-98-00257-CR

0872-00         BENAVIDES, JUAN PENA HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00802-CR

0873-00         BENAVIDES, JUAN PENA HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00803-CR

0877-00         AREVALO, JOAQUIN RUBEN, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01068-CR

0879-00         DAVIS, LOUIS EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00638-CR

0880-00         RODRIGUEZ, EDWARD HERRERA HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00369-CR

0881-00         GUTIERREZ, LOOUIS CANO, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01415-CR

0905-00         THOMPSON, LEWIS DEAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00119-CR

0906-00         THOMPSON, LEWIS DEAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00120-CR

0953-00         METTS, DARRELL WAYNE TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00095-CR

0954-00         METTS, DARRELL WAYNE TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00096-CR

0998-00         FLAHERTY, RICHARD AARON GRAYSON COUNTY 05-97-01970-CR

0999-00         NAKEDHEAD, TOM DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01170-CR

1000-00         PORTS, EX PARTE KENNETH BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00705-CR

1003-00         COURTNEY, RANFORD L. HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00353-CR

1004-00         NEWSOM, BILL DON TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00204-CR

1007-00         CHAMBERS, DONNA MARIE MIDLAND COUNTY 08-99-00404-CR

1008-00         JACKSON, MORRIS WAYNE ELLIS COUNTY 10-98-00270-CR

1009-00         TUNISON, TIMMY TODD TARRANT COUNTY 10-99-00088-CR

1012-00         FLECK, MARCUS STEPHEN HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00768-CR

1036-00         WILSON, ROCKY ALLEN COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-00284-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

1038-00         JOHNSON, ELLOYD DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01387-CR

1039-00         BEAN, CHARLES FELIX HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00092-CR

1045-00         SCHMIDT, GREGORY JOSEPH GALVESTON COUNTY 14-98-00497-CR

1052-00         ROSS, JERRY LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01396-CR

1059-00         TRAYLOR, CLIFFORD WAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01264-CR

1060-00         TRAYLOR, CLIFFORD WAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01265-CR

1061-00         TRAYLOR, CLIFFORD WAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01266-CR

1065-00         BEASLEY, WILLIE DONNELL HENDERSON COUNTY 12-99-00117-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



0429-00         YOUNG, MUHAMMAD L. (DA#1) LAMAR COUNTY 06-97-00017-CR

                       (JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

0429-00         YOUNG, MUHAMMAD L. (SPA#2) LAMAR COUNTY 06-97-00017-CR

                       (JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

0845-00         CAMPBELL, JONATHAN R. HARRIS COUNTY 12-99-00335-CR

0862-00         LARY, KELVIN LEE DALLAS COUNTY 07-99-00237-CR



APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0834-00         DELGADO, EX PARTE MARIO EL PASO COUNTY 08-99-00050-CR 0835-00 SALINAS, RICARDO DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00360-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:



1230-00         ERIC BERNARD THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00346-CR

1288-00         BARBER, RODNEY CHARLES AUSTIN COUNTY 01-99-00506-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0536-00         HOPKINS, III, DOUGLAS LEROY HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00190-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

0656-00         CHEN, BAILEY LISHIAN DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00632-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0522-00         STEWART, DALTON B. (DA#1) MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-99-00130-CR

                       (GRANTED ON NO.1 ONLY)

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

0522-00         STEWART, DALTON B.(SPA#2) MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-99-00130-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)











APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:





17,356-05         MARVIN LORINAE BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

17,891-04         RICKIE CLYDE PATTERSON EL PASO COUNTY

17,891-05         RICKIE CLYDE PATTERSON EL PASO COUNTY

29,839-03         CHARLES EUGENE WRIGHT BEXAR COUNTY

31,084-02         JESSE MONROE CALDWELL COUNTY

37,341-03         HOMER PEREZ SALDIVAR BEXAR COUNTY

37,341-04         HOMER PEREZ SALDIVAR BEXAR COUNTY

37,341-05         HOMER PEREZ SALDIVAR BEXAR COUNTY

37,341-06         HOMER PEREZ SALDIVAR BEXAR COUNTY

37,491-03         MARCUS RILES BEXAR COUNTY

37,549-03         EDWARD CLAYTON BROOKSHIRE SMITH COUNTY

45,032-01         RAYFORD EARL MILLER PANOLA COUNTY

45,150-01         BOBBY PEDROZA DALLAS COUNTY

45,474-01         KEVIN LEWIS LEON COUNTY

45,612-01         ALFRED ALRIDGE HARRIS COUNTY

45,747-01         JOSHUA LEE HALE BEXAR COUNTY

45,767-01         JULIAN BENITO BENAVIDEZ DEAF SMITH COUNTY

45,890-01         ALBERT VIRES BEXAR COUNTY

45,923-01         ROBERT ROBINSON TRAVIS COUNTY

46,008-01         RUBEN SANCHEZ RUSK COUNTY

46,024-01         JAMES RHYMES DALLAS COUNTY

46,063-01         DONALD RAY WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY

46,066-01         LESTER L. MORRIS RANDALL COUNTY

46,072-01         LUIS CARLOS LUJAN EL PASO COUNTY

46,077-01         FRASHUNDON LEWETTE KING BRAZORIA COUNTY

46,117-01         JEFFERY RAY CLARK DALLAS COUNTY

46,122-01         RODNEY SALONE TARRANT COUNTY

46,136-01         RAYMUNDO MENDIOLA MADISON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

17,999-03         ENNIS RAY EVANS HARRIS COUNTY

19,977-03         HOWARD TYRONE CONNOR HARRIS COUNTY

25,052-02         ARMANDO VELASQUEZ NUECES COUNTY    

28,381-02         CLEMENT DAVIS JONES BEXAR COUNTY

28,623-04         PAUL JAMES SANDERS BRAZOS COUNTY

28,623-05         PAUL JAMES SANDERS BRAZOS COUNTY

28,623-06         PAUL JAMES SANDERS BRAZOS COUNTY

29,198-03         JIMMIE LEE WALTON DALLAS COUNTY

3,338-10           JOHN ALBERT MILES HARRIS COUNTY

30,196-04         JOHN MICHAEL DILLARD HARRIS COUNTY

35,006-05         SHANNON LEFEVERE RUNNELS COUNTY

40,661-03         ELIGAH DARNELL TARRANT COUNTY

41,342-01         JUAN MANUEL MUNOZ CAMERON COUNTY

42,691-02         VAUGHN RAY LEVY HARRIS COUNTY

43,911-01         MARTIN HEPNER DENTON COUNTY

44,413-02         HENRY SHELTON BENJAMIN DALLAS COUNTY

44,888-01         JOHN EARLE POST WILSON COUNTY

45,028-01         BRENT HAROLD PIERCE LUBBOCK COUNTY

45,182-01         ERIC LYNN DANIELS HUNT COUNTY

45,438-01         RANDOLPH EUGENE ARLEDGE NAVARRO COUNTY

45,604-02         ROBERT LEE ROSALES LUBBOCK COUNTY

45,676-01         BRIAN EDWARD MEGGINSON GREGG COUNTY

45,690-01         THAVIXAY INTHASONE DALLAS COUNTY

45,691-01         HAROLD BREEDLOVE HARRIS COUNTY

45,805-01         LAMONT DEMENTRIA DOSS DALLAS COUNTY

45,862-01         JERRY CROLEY GREGG COUNTY

45,926-02         JOHN JEFFERY PIERCE HARRIS COUNTY

45,927-01         BOBBY W. ALBRITTON CHAMBERS COUNTY

45,943-01         JAMES FRANKLIN CARNEY TRAVIS COUNTY

45,948-01         DAVID SEDA BEXAR COUNTY

45,952-01         LESLEY WAYNE SHILLINGS HARRIS COUNTY

45,981-01         HAROLD GEORGE SAYRIE JEFFERSON COUNTY

45,993-01         ANTHONY RASHAD FLEMMING HARRIS COUNTY

46,021-01         JOSEPH TRINIDAD DAVILA DALLAS COUNTY

46,026-01         WILLIE MACK THOMPSON TARRANT COUNTY

46,052-01         CLIFTON JAMES HOLLEY HARRIS COUNTY

46,075-01         ROBERT CRAIG DYER DALLAS COUNTY

46,079-01         JOE NATHAN STUART DALLAS COUNTY

46,080-01         JESSICA LYNN GULSBY DALLAS COUNTY

46,094-01         JIMMIE O'BRIEN CONCHO COUNTY

46,095-01         LEROY J. JONES BOWIE COUNTY

46,101-01         JESUS JESSE GONZALEZ HARRIS COUNTY

46,111-01         BEAUHAMMA BROADNAX WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                         (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,112-01         LONNIE GOODEN III WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,123-01         RODNEY GLENN WILKERSON MONTGOMERY COUNTY

46,152-01         ANTHONY ROY PICKETT HARRIS COUNTY

46,192-01         JAMES FORREST BEXAR COUNTY

46,192-02         JAMES FORREST BEXAR COUNTY

46,223-01         BRIAN LOUIS PYRON HARRIS COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)

44,666-01         RAFAEL TORRES SCURRY COUNTY

45,526-01         JAMES ARNETTE ROUGHLEY DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

17,999-04         ENNIS RAY EVANS HARRIS COUNTY

18,413-02         DON ALTON DURST FAYETTE COUNTY

37,615-04         GILBERTO MELCHOR RUIZ BEXAR COUNTY

43,159-01         MICHAEL S. MURPHY TARRANT COUNTY

44,030-01         HERBERT LADALE WILEY POLK COUNTY

44,768-02         RICKY DALE MINOR HOOD COUNTY

45,642-01         MARION ROBERSON TARRANT COUNTY

45,891-01         JONATHAN O. BYNER TARRANT COUNTY

45,922-01         MANUEL GONZALES JR. BEXAR COUNTY

45,930-01         KENNETH JAY BENSON TARRANT COUNTY

45,945-01         JESSE CHARLES LUNA BEXAR COUNTY

45,998-01         MARCUS D. TURNER TARRANT COUNTY

46,005-01         WILBERT J. JONES JR. ELLIS COUNTY

46,018-01         KENNETH TRAPP ANGELINA COUNTY

46,039-01         RODERIC LYNN SCOTT TARRANT COUNTY

46,044-01         GASPER DELACRUZ NUNEZ MCLENNAN COUNTY

46,049-01         RICARDO RAMIREZ JR. EL PASO COUNTY

46,049-02         RICARDO RAMIREZ JR. EL PASO COUNTY

46,049-03         RICARDO RAMIREZ JR. EL PASO COUNTY

46,049-04         RICARDO RAMIREZ JR. EL PASO COUNTY

46,062-01         EUGENE MAXWELL DAWSON COUNTY

46,070-01         DAVID LEE LOGAN BOSQUE COUNTY

46,081-01         MICHAEL YOUNGER DALLAS COUNTY

46,086-01         GABRIEL LEOS REEVES COUNTY

46,106-01         DAMON REINHARDT TAYLOR COUNTY

46,116-01         SHEDRICK DEQUINCY LEMONS DE WITT COUNTY

46,131-01         ANTHONY GREEN TARRANT COUNTY

46,134-01         NORBERTO GARCIA ACEVEDO GILLESPIE COUNTY

46,134-02         NORBERTO GARCIA ACEVEDO GILLESPIE COUNTY

46,147-01         TONY MOLINA BEXAR COUNTY

46,153-01         ANTHONY HERNANDEZ GUADALUPE COUNTY

46,167-01         DANNY LEE TURNER TARRANT COUNTY

46,169-01         JESSE ANTONIO RODRIGUEZ TARRANT COUNTY

46,182-01         WILLIAM ANTHONY CLARK TARRANT COUNTY

46,188-01         WENDEL JAMES CHAMPAGNE HARRIS COUNTY

46,191-01         EDWARD GALLOW JR. LIBERTY COUNTY

46,219-01         DAVID FRANKLIN ASHWORTH JOHNSON COUNTY

46,314-01         GILBERT SALINAS LOPEZ HIDALGO COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

14,921-11         ARTHUR E. JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

45,440-01         CLAYTON SIMS MOTLEY COUNTY

45,666-01         CURTIS WILKERSON GRIMES COUNTY

46,133-01         ERNEST ANTHONY ROGERS DALLAS COUNTY

46,225-01         RAY MCKINLEY WELCH HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

12,825-09         LEON CALVIN PORTER DALLAS COUNTY

2,820-07           CHARLIE ALEXANDER DALLAS COUNTY

20,399-09         TOMMY LEE JACKSON BELL COUNTY

22,407-04         ARCENIO GARZA HARRIS COUNTY

23,857-06         DONALD RAY RICHARDSON MCLENNAN COUNTY

23,893-05         SAM E. HENSON TARRANT COUNTY

28,280-03         JERRYL JAMES JONES JEFFERSON COUNTY

30,010-03         MICHAEL DEWAYNE BOOKMAN DALLAS COUNTY

34,054-02         JAMES WAYNE HENSON EASTLAND COUNTY

40,868-02         KENNETH ANDREA CLARK WALLER COUNTY

40,921-05         LUIS ALFREDO GUTIERREZ HARRIS COUNTY

42,675-02         CHARLES RAY BARRON DALLAS COUNTY

43,824-02         CHARLES EDWARD POOL TARRANT COUNTY

45,379-02         CLAY ATKINSON HOWARD COUNTY

8,581-11         WILLIE CRAWFORD BENNETT DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:



42,584-01         LARRY JOSEPH GRASS JR. HOOD COUNTY

43,614-03         LARRY MORENO MARQUEZ HARRIS COUNTY

44,213-01         LANCE EDWARDS FORT BEND COUNTY

45,032-02         RAYFORD EARL MILLER PANOLA COUNTY

45,341-01         PETE VILLEGAS HARRIS COUNTY

45,425-01         CARLOS ESTEBAN VALLES EL PASO COUNTY

45,530-01         MARIO SANCHEZ LA SALLE COUNTY

45,533-01         MARIO ABEL SALAZAR CAMERON COUNTY

45,570-01         KEITH DUANE TOWLES PARKER COUNTY

45,614-01         BRUCE HICKS DALLAS COUNTY

45,618-01         DONALD LEN YOUNG TARRANT COUNTY

45,963-01         DENNIS ALEXANDER TRAVIS COUNTY

46,076-01         WENDELL RAY BAINES VICTORIA COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

14,921-12         ARTHUR E. JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

42,238-02         THAI NGUYEN HARRIS COUNTY

44,986-02         IVO NABELEK HARRIS COUNTY

45,077-02         RONALD MOOREFIELD GAINES COUNTY

45,445-01         TONY WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

45,604-01         ROBERT LEE ROSALES LUBBOCK COUNTY

45,926-01         JOHN JEFFERY PIERCE HARRIS COUNTY

45,933-01         GERRY D. DICKENS HARRIS COUNTY

46,119-01         RODNEY LEE FEGANS DALLAS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

27,372-04         DONALD EARL HENRY HARRIS COUNTY

33,592-02         ALBERT LUDLOW JR. HARRIS COUNTY

45,333-01         ALONZO TRAYLOR DALLAS COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



46,103-01         JASON NOBLE JEFFERSON COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:



9,349-05           HOWARD CHARLES THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY

37,406-03         TIMOTHY JOHN LIMON WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

45,717-01         ANTONIO P. GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY