THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



SEPTEMBER 20, 2000



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:









73,199         IGNACIO GOMEZ FROM EL PASO COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION



73,205         COY WAYNE WESBROOK FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK JOINED)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGES PRICE, HOLLAND AND JOHNSON JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)



73,906         EX PARTE ADOLPH DIAZ FROM NUECES COUNTY

73,907         EX PARTE CHARLES L. WILSON, JR. FROM MATAGORDA COUNTY



OPINION ON APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING:



73,058         CHUONG DUONG TONG FROM HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED--PER CURIAM OPINION

JUDGES WOMACK AND JOHNSON DISSENT FROM THE DENIAL OF APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING.

PUBLISHED OPINION









ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



1521-9        STEVEN TROY CURRY FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE MEYERS JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



0412-99       PHILLIP GEORGE O'HARA FROM JIM WELLS COUNTY (SPA'S)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGES MEYERS, PRICE AND HOLLAND JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



1321-99       BILLY LEE WALTER FROM TOM GREEN COUNTY (SPA'S)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED:

JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT REINSTATED--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION



1521-99       STEVEN TROY CURRY FROM HARRIS COUNTY (SPA'S)

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE MEYERS JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



0727-00         CHAVEZ, ALEJANDRO EL PASO COUNTY 08-97-00269-CR

0832-00         TILLMAN, JONATHAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00993-CR

0833-00         TILLMAN, JONATHAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00994-CR

0842-00         DIAZ, TRINIDAD HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00507-CR

0882-00         ANDERSON, DALE TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00471-CR

0895-00         SCOYOLA, WALDEMAR REFUGIO COUNTY 13-97-00907-CR

APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0950-00         GOLDSBERRY, MICHAEL DEAN HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00890-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

1566-00         ZUNIGA, ALBERT BEXAR COUNTY 03-99-00249-CR

1567-00         PATTON, JAMES EVERETT BANDERA COUNTY 03-99-00250-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0693-00         LOUIS ANTHONY GUTIERREZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01017-CR

                       (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



0861-00         RICKY HERNANDEZ LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-98-00322-CR

                       (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

                        (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1089-00         CRAIG E. MENDENHALL FREESTONE COUNTY 10-98-00109-CR

                        (GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

                        (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



0818-00         JOHN BEENY HERNANDEZ BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00664-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1017-00         MARIO REY RAMIREZ JACKSON COUNTY 13-97-00769-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



13,905-10         CHARLES YOUNG WICHITA COUNTY

20,076-02         RICHARD SYLVESTER LOCKMAN TARRANT COUNTY

21,440-04         DENNIS RAY WALKER NUECES COUNTY

27,089-02         MARCUS FRANCHAT WATSON BRAZOS COUNTY

27,089-03         MARCUS FRANCHAT WATSON BRAZOS COUNTY

27,089-04         MARCUS FRANCHAT WATSON BRAZOS COUNTY

27,979-05         JOSE DEJESUS GARCIA HARRIS COUNTY

34,856-04         JESSE BENJAMIN ARTIS RANDALL COUNTY

34,856-05         JESSE BENJAMIN ARTIS RANDALL COUNTY

39,700-02         DAVID WALKER WEBB COUNTY

41,385-01         MYRON LAMONT RHODES POLK COUNTY

41,385-02         MYRON LAMONT RHODES TARRANT COUNTY

41,385-03         MYRON LAMONT RHODES POLK COUNTY

41,749-03         JUAN RIOS GUADALUPE COUNTY

45,809-04         ROBERT R. MAGGARD HARRIS COUNTY

45,939-01         FRANCIS AWUKU MALLET DENTON COUNTY

46,212-01         TONY D. ROSEMOND TARRANT COUNTY

46,322-01         ALEXANDER GILBERT MENDOZA POTTER COUNTY

46,395-01         PAULA LOUISE BARNES RAINS COUNTY

46,444-01         ROBERT CHEEK JR. TARRANT COUNTY

46,459-01         ERVIN JOSEPH KENNERSON GALVESTON COUNTY

46,459-02         ERVIN JOSEPH KENNERSON GALVESTON COUNTY

46,480-01         CARL BUTLER HARRIS COUNTY

46,483-01         DAVID ALAN ADAMS DALLAS COUNTY

46,528-01         JOSHUA BONNER HARRIS COUNTY

46,552-01         JOSHUA PATRICK MEIS TARRANT COUNTY

46,599-01         GREG JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY

46,599-02         GREG JOHNSON TARRANT COUNTY

46,668-01         HALE LIGHTSEY JR. CASS COUNTY

46,673-01         HENRY EDWARD JOHNSON DENTON COUNTY

46,696-01         JOE BILL TURNER COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,704-01         RONALD BATTLE JR. HOPKINS COUNTY

46,716-01         JOHN PECKHAM III WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,724-01         TIMOTHY DARRYL MCQUAIG ECTOR COUNTY

46,731-01         JESUS LUIS AVILES MEDINA COUNTY

46,737-01         DAVID O. WILLIAMS TARRANT COUNTY

46,780-01         ALLEN RAY HERRON TARRANT COUNTY

46,787-01         ANTHONY HERNDON CAMP COUNTY

46,790-01         RANDALL DALE DORMIER ROCKWALL COUNTY

46,791-01         OMAR FERNANDO ESCAMILLA DENTON COUNTY

46,792-01         DEUNDRE GREEN FORT BEND COUNTY

46,800-01         DAVID WAYNE HILL TRAVIS COUNTY

46,801-01         JAMES E. CRAWFORD DALLAS COUNTY

46,802-01         ROBERT E. FIELDS JR. GREGG COUNTY

46,813-01         THOMAS WISFORD HARRIS COUNTY

46,822-01         SHAWN RONALD HICKS GALVESTON COUNTY

46,827-01         TRAVIS ORLANDO MERCY HARRIS COUNTY

46,827-02         TRAVIS ORLANDO MERCY HARRIS COUNTY

46,840-01         SHANE PAUL GUZIEC EL PASO COUNTY

46,847-01         BLAIR DUANE WRIGHT LIBERTY COUNTY

46,848-01         WILLIAM USEY JEFFERSON COUNTY

46,857-01         MARVIN EARL FURR LIBERTY COUNTY

46,871-01         GARY WAYNE ODOMS HARRIS COUNTY

46,889-01         BENJAMIN SANCHEZ CAUDILLO LUBBOCK COUNTY

46,893-01         DAVID G. PETRUS SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

46,903-01         LARRY EVANS MORRIS COUNTY

46,908-01         JASON EARL VAUGHAN GALVESTON COUNTY

46,909-01         JOE ANTHONY MARTINEZ VICTORIA COUNTY

46,918-01         PAUL PHELPHS TRAVIS COUNTY

46,971-01         DARRYL JOHN PARTRIDGE GALVESTON COUNTY

7,014-10         BILL RUTHERFORD DEAF SMITH COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

16,917-04         TERRY O''NEIL JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

19,740-03         RONALD CLAY JOHNSON KAUFMAN COUNTY

27,084-04         JAMES RUFUS JORDAN LIBERTY COUNTY

32,566-06         ALFRED GUADALUPE DEASES HARRIS COUNTY

36,813-02         ERIC ROBERTO ACOSTA HARRIS COUNTY

37,636-02         BOBBY JOE DANIELS DALLAS COUNTY

39,864-04         GEORGE W. RODGERS DALLAS COUNTY

40,118-02         GARY W. DANIELS TARRANT COUNTY

40,956-02         JOE ESPARZA DALLAS COUNTY

41,108-02         MIKE VESPA HARRIS COUNTY

42,785-03         ROBERT EUSTACIO LEE BEXAR COUNTY

42,785-04         ROBERT EUSTACIO LEE BEXAR COUNTY

43,730-01         OSCAR ROSARIO HARRIS COUNTY

44,692-02         JULIE MARQUEZ BEXAR COUNTY

45,760-01         BETTY CARLENE J. EASLEY MARION COUNTY

46,230-01         TRACY LEROY WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY

                          (JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,311-01         JORGE COBON GRUESO HARRIS COUNTY

46,325-01         DANIEL ZAPATA BEXAR COUNTY

46,332-01         KELLWIN ORLANDO GREEN DALLAS COUNTY

46,336-01         DARRELL LEE HARPER HARRIS COUNTY    

46,428-02         HUBERT SHARP HARRIS COUNTY

46,472-01         ISAAC RODRIGUEZ III HARRIS COUNTY

46,472-02         ISAAC RODRIGUEZ III HARRIS COUNTY

46,472-03         ISAAC RODRIGUEZ III HARRIS COUNTY

46,472-04         ISAAC RODRIGUEZ III HARRIS COUNTY

46,474-01         ROBERT OLIVER PARMER BELL COUNTY

46,479-01         JERRODE LACHANCE MCCLAIN HARRIS COUNTY

46,479-02         JERRODE LACHANCE MCCLAIN HARRIS COUNTY

46,500-01         JOHNNY PINEDA HARRIS COUNTY

46,503-01         CHRISTOPHER CHANCE ROGERS HARRIS COUNTY

46,504-01         KARL ALLEN SMITH LAMAR COUNTY

46,505-01         JERRY DEVON GRAY HARRIS COUNTY

46,545-01         DAVID LEE WELCH SMITH COUNTY

46,550-01         OZIE RAMBO DALLAS COUNTY

46,617-01         JOSE MONTENEGRO ESTRADA EL PASO COUNTY

46,667-01         PAUL RAKISH HARRIS COUNTY

46,673-02         HENRY EDWARD JOHNSON COOKE COUNTY

46,679-01         HANI HUSSEIN AL-RUB GALVESTON COUNTY

46,680-01         WILLIAM MCGILL JR. GALVESTON COUNTY

46,681-01         BILLY EARL HEATH DALLAS COUNTY

46,683-01         MARCUS CISNEROS DALLAS COUNTY

46,686-01         PAUL LAMONT JACKSON DALLAS COUNTY

46,689-01         DANIEL GARCIA HINOJOSA DALLAS COUNTY

46,705-01         SERVANDO CERVANTES BEXAR COUNTY

46,739-01         RICHARD DE LA O GONZALES BEXAR COUNTY

46,741-01         LINDELL PREJEAN DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY

46,743-01         TIMOTHY LEON HARDIMAN HARRIS COUNTY

46,744-01         TAM HUU NGUYEN HARRIS COUNTY

46,772-01         ROCKLAND BRUCE JEFFERSON COUNTY

46,782-01         HERMAN THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY

46,793-01         GABRIEL FIGUEROA CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY

46,809-01         MICHAEL WAYNE HUGHES ELLIS COUNTY

46,818-01         CLYDE RAY MASON HARRIS COUNTY

46,824-01         JIMMY A. MARTINEZ BEXAR COUNTY

46,829-01         PAUL GREGORY HENRY WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,842-01         PAUL RAMOS DALLAS COUNTY

46,851-01         ANTHONY PALMER MIDLAND COUNTY

46,855-01         TONY VANNESS WILLIAMS GREGG COUNTY

46,866-01         LARRY CHARLES BATTLE HARRIS COUNTY

46,877-01         DONALD ALFRED ROGERS HARRIS COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

10,516-08         JAMES EDWARD RAMSEY PARKER COUNTY

35,328-02         WILLIAM JONES MARION COUNTY

37,587-03         VERNON LEE HUNT TOM GREEN COUNTY

45,261-03         CECIL WAYNE TOLBERT DENTON COUNTY

46,180-01         MICKIL CRENSHAW ECTOR COUNTY

46,327-01         IRVIN LEWIS DUKES BEXAR COUNTY

46,327-02         IRVIN LEWIS DUKES BEXAR COUNTY

46,501-01         ROBERT WOODARD HARRIS COUNTY

46,674-01         ONESIMO FRAIRE OCHOA JACKSON COUNTY

46,713-01         ERNESTO BRICENO RUIZ ROCKWALL COUNTY

46,789-01         JOE ISAAC JR. JOHNSON GALVESTON COUNTY

46,828-01         GREGORY ALAN HALE HARRIS COUNTY

46,834-01         JOHN WAYNE LYTLE JOHNSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

46,874-01         JERRY WAYNE WHITENER HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

25,524-02         CEPHAS LADAY JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY

26,313-05         MIGUEL G. BRUNO MADISON COUNTY

29,558-03         ARMANDO BENAVIDEZ COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

30,398-02         TERRY LYNN JACKSON KAUFMAN COUNTY

30,849-03         JOHN CLIFTON WILBANKS LIBERTY COUNTY

33,643-10         RICKY G. MORENO TARRANT COUNTY

33,923-08         CHESTER RAY JOHNSON BOWIE COUNTY

34,245-02         ANTHONY K. CHATMAN TARRANT COUNTY

37,582-04         ROLAND VALLE BEXAR COUNTY

37,582-05         ROLAND VALLE BEXAR COUNTY

37,582-06         ROLAND VALLE BEXAR COUNTY

38,823-05         JAMES EUGENE GOEN GREGG COUNTY

4,587-09         JOHNNY RAY JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

4,611-13         SAMUEL LOUIS HAYES MATAGORDA COUNTY

44,045-02         JOZEF UHLIK BEXAR COUNTY

6,899-12         STEVEN DOUGLAS HAMILTON DALLAS COUNTY

6,899-13         STEVEN DOUGLAS HAMILTON DALLAS COUNTY

8,535-14         JOHNNIE L. WALKER TRAVIS COUNTY







APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

12,805-04         HOWARD WAYNE FLIPPO GUADALUPE COUNTY

13,628-16         DAVID LEWIS ADAMS POTTER COUNTY

36,066-02         FRANK UTSEY BOWIE COUNTY

36,203-03         RICKEY LOUIS JACKSON KAUFMAN COUNTY

37,441-02         GREGORY DONNELL COLEMAN NAVARRO COUNTY

38,271-02         RICHIE CHARLES WISHUM HARRIS COUNTY

39,851-02         ROY LEE LAKE TARRANT COUNTY

40,136-09         PAUL STURGEON HARRIS COUNTY

40,828-06         BILLY DALE WALKER TARRANT COUNTY

44,112-02         CHARLES DEWAYNE MOTEN TARRANT COUNTY

45,404-02         MICHAEL RAY LONG TARRANT COUNTY

45,545-03         LANCE STANLEY TRAVIS COUNTY

45,545-04         LANCE STANLEY TRAVIS COUNTY

45,922-02         MANUEL GONZALES JR. BEXAR COUNTY

46,188-02         WENDEL JAMES CHAMPAGNE HARRIS COUNTY

46,289-01         ROBERT L. LINDER BEXAR COUNTY

46,490-01         CHESTER BELL DALLAS COUNTY

46,567-01         RICHARD CARTER SMITH COUNTY

46,595-01         WILLIAM HAROLD BAKER TRAVIS COUNTY

46,657-01         WILEY MCGIRT COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,671-01         JEFFERY KENT MCLAURIN LYNN COUNTY

46,677-01         STEVEN DAVID ALARID POTTER COUNTY

46,740-01         PABLO RESENDEZ GUTIERREZ JR. BEXAR COUNTY

46,788-01         JESSE LEE HART NACOGDOCHES COUNTY

46,795-01         RANCE DUANE SHELTON ERATH COUNTY

46,796-01         RICKY HOWARD SCHEDULE GALVESTON COUNTY

46,796-02         RICKY HOWARD SCHEDULE GALVESTON COUNTY

46,810-01         DENNIS WAYNE PLEMMONS CLAY COUNTY

46,814-01         ANTHONY RICE DALLAS COUNTY

46,815-01         CARLOS ANTONIO ALLEN HARRIS COUNTY

46,825-01         FELIPE GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

46,825-02         FELIPE GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

46,856-01         NATHANIEL ROLLINS LIBERTY COUNTY

46,867-01         PERRY ALLUMS TARRANT COUNTY

46,868-01         KENNETH F. BROEDER TARRANT COUNTY

46,888-01         RANDY WEBB BRAZORIA COUNTY

46,892-01         MICHAEL ROBERT YOUNG OCHILTREE COUNTY

46,911-01         MATTHEW LOGSDON TARRANT COUNTY

46,916-01         JAMES ANTHONY HAZLETT TARRANT COUNTY

46,943-01         JOE BRANDY MEDLOCK KERR COUNTY











APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

35,498-02           GRADY RICHARD FRANCIS PANOLA COUNTY

                           (JUDGE WOMACK DISSENTS)

46,179-01           JOSEPH L. REESE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                            (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

46,637-01           ARTHUR LEE JONES DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

44,483-01         CHARLES WILSON MATAGORDA COUNTY

45,319-01         ADOLPH DIAZ NUECES COUNTY

46,218-01         LUIS GERARDO GARCIA HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

14,958-04         DAVID RAETZSCH COUNTY

24,583-07         FRANK DWIGHT CARTER LUBBOCK COUNTY

26,373-09         LEE ROGER SIMPSON, JR. FALLS COUNTY

37,268-02         JAMES O. BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

40,136-08         PAUL STURGEON HARRIS COUNTY

40,190-04         MICHAEL CAMPBELL DALLAS COUNTY

44,163-02         JOSE JIMENEZ SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

46,436-01         LOYCE CARLTON MEANS HARRIS COUNTY

46,477-02         NARCISO GARCIA MIRANDA HARRIS COUNTY

46,513-01         CHRISTOPHER PAUL GONZALEZ BEXAR COUNTY

46,671-02         JEFFERY KENT MCLAURIN LYNN COUNTY

46,766-01         ROBERT COOPER DALLAS COUNTY

46,820-01         GEORGE MORENO BEXAR COUNTY

9,690-03           THOMAS EDWARD SHELBY TRAVIS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

44,564-01         JOSEPH ROLAND LAVE DALLAS COUNTY

                         (JUDGES KELLER AND PRICE NOT PARTICIPATING)

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

44,149-02         RICHARD COONS EL PASO COUNTY

45,702-01         FREDERICK L. MCCORMICK HARRIS COUNTY

45,988-01         CEDRIC F. SPATES COUNTY

46,714-01         DWIGHT TERREL HARRIS COUNTY

46,816-01         JUAN ESTRADA HARRIS COUNTY









MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION ON COURT'S OWN MOTION OF APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



45,764-01         WILLIAM BURGESS BELLOMY TARRANT COUNTY

                           (DENIED 9-14-00)



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



46,511-01         HEATHER GARCIA NUECES COUNTY