THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS




OCTOBER 8, 2003




THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:

 

 

AP-74,253

SPEER, WILLIAM FROM BOWIE COUNTY

AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

AP-74,357

HALE, EX PARTE ANTONIO DWINAL FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY

HC RELIEF GRANTED-OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

AP-74,575

SMITH, PATRICK BERNARD FROM HARRIS COUNTY

AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED-OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON PUBLISHED OPINION)

 

AP-74,771

HIGGINS, EX PARTE ANDIE M. FROM ROCKWALL COUNTY

 

 

AP-74,773

JOSEPH, EX PARTE LESTER CHARLES FROM CHAMBERS COUNTY

 

 

AP-74,774

CERDA, EX PARTE ROBERT LEE FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY

 

 

AP-74,775

HINOJOSA, EX PARTE JAMES FROM NUECES COUNTY

 

 

STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:

 

AP-74,432

HARMON, EX PARTE RICKY DALE FROM DALLAS COUNTY

 

(WITH PUBLISHED PER CURIAM ORDER)

 

(ORIGINAL PER CURIAM OPINION DATED SEPTEMBER 25, 2002, IS ORDERED PUBLISHED)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

(JUDGE KEASLER JOINED )

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

 

PD-0561-02

GONZALEZ, ALFONZO FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-97-00745-CR

AFFIRMED COA-OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED )

(JUDGE KEASLER JOINED )

(JUDGE WOMACK DISSENTED WITHOUT OPINION)

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1196-02

LANEY, LAURIN STUART FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-00-01299-CR

AFFIRMED COA-OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

(JUDGE PRICE JOINED )

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1313-02

SIMS, MICHAEL FROM NAVARRO COUNTY - 10-01-00236-CR

AFFIRMED COA-OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE PRICE JOINED )

(JUDGE WOMACK CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1665-02

TAYLOR, JUSTUS LARUE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-01-00505-CR

AFFIRMED COA-OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

CONCURRING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGE PRICE JOINED )

(JUDGE HOLCOMB JOINED )

(JUDGE COCHRAN JOINED )

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

 

PD-0201-02

TEXAS, STATE OF V. PETERSON, JAMES FROM COLLIN COUNTY - 05-01-01093-CR

VACATED COA; REMANDED-PER CURIAM OPINION

(JUDGE COCHRAN CONCURS IN THE JUDGMENT)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MICHAEL KEASLER

(JUDGE BARBARA HERVEY JOINED )

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BARBARA HERVEY

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER JOINED )

(JUDGE MICHAEL KEASLER JOINED )

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1532-02

PIERCE, CHERYL STRINGER FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-95-00725-CR

REMANDED TO COA-OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER CONCURRED IN THE JUDGMENT)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-0479-03

TEXAS, STATE OF V. SHOE, EX PARTE THOMAS FRANKLIN FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-02-00099-CR

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW IS GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 3 ONLY;

VACATED COA; REMANDED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

 

PD-2053-01

HERNANDEZ, ARTURO CHAVEZ FROM KLEBERG COUNTY - 13-00-00065-CR

(JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

 

PD-0424-03

GUEVARA, JAMES GEORGE FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-00-00340-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

 

PD-0568-03

DANG, TUAN ANH FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-00-00560-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

 

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

 

PD-0950-03

NELSON, ALEXIUS JAMALL FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 07-01-00425-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 2, 3 & 4 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT IS PERMITTED)

 

 

PD-1085-03

GUEVARA, RACHEL L. FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-02-00568-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

PD-1863-02

MARSHALL, CHARLES FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-01-00376-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0319-03

KIMBROUGH, KAREEMA S. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-01-00358-CR

 

 

PD-0331-03

WOODEN, TRAYSON L. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-01-00395-CR

 

 

PD-0499-03

PEREZ, JOE MICHAEL FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-01-00552-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0500-03

PEREZ, JOE MICHAEL FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-01-00553-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0513-03

LAMB, MONTY WAYNE FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 11-00-00295-CR

 

 

PD-0748-03

STITT, SAMUEL DEAN FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 06-02-00080-CR

 

 

PD-0784-03

MITCHELL, TOMMY LAMONT FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY - 03-01-00658-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0786-03

MITCHELL, TOMMY LAMONT FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY - 03-01-00659-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0802-03

BONNEY, HAROLD FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00433-CR

 

 

PD-0804-03

AVILA, OMAR ALI FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-01-01244-CR

 

 

PD-0824-03

EMBREE, GRANT AUSTIN FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-01-01052-CR

 

 

PD-0825-03

EMBREE, GRANT AUSTIN FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-01-01053-CR

 

 

PD-0847-03

JAMES, REMONA LIL FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-01019-CR

 

 

PD-0848-03

QUIGLEY, LYNN EARL FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-00294-CR

 

 

PD-0880-03

LETBETTER, SIDNEY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00677-CR

 

 

PD-0937-03

JIMINEZ, CARLOS FROM TOM GREEN COUNTY - 03-02-00733-CR

 

 

PD-1005-03

ZIDLE, JONATHAN ALAN FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-01011-CR

 

 

PD-1009-03

RUTLEDGE, HARRY JR. FROM TRAVIS COUNTY - 03-02-00812-CR

 

 

PD-1070-03

IVERY, CHRISTOPHER LEE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00337-CR

 

 

PD-1080-03

CORMIER, DWIGHT FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-00256-CR

 

 

PD-1095-03

SMITH, FREDDRICK FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00660-CR

 

 

PD-1108-03

HARRIS, REGINALD LYNN AKA HARRIS, REGINALD FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-01-00348-CR

 

 

PD-1111-03

DWIGHT, STEPHEN ALLEN FROM BELL COUNTY - 03-02-00731-CR

 

 

PD-1147-03

ADKINS, JOHNNY RAY JR. FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-00680-CR

 

 

PD-1150-03

YBARRA, PEDRO FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00667-CR

 

 

PD-1151-03

YBARRA, PEDRO FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00668-CR

 

 

PD-1171-03

KEELE, LARRY EDLIN FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-02-00132-CR

 

 

PD-1172-03

BAILEY, EARL FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-02-00204-CR

 

 

PD-1195-03

BAKER, DEBRA LYNN FROM CLAY COUNTY - 02-02-00391-CR

 

 

PD-1224-03

WYATT, TROY LEE FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-01-00146-CR

 

 

PD-1233-03

GARCIA, FABIAN RENE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-00583-CR

 

 

PD-1234-03

MCGOWEN, JOSEPH K. FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-00416-CR

 

 

PD-1235-03

LEAL, TIMOTHY GONZALEZ FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-02-00139-CR

 

 

PD-1250-03

SILVA, JORGE LUIS FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-01136-CR

 

 

PD-1257-03

CARTER, RICKEY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-00830-CR

 

 

PD-1258-03

DIGGLES, ZANE KASSIDY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-99-00793-CR

 

 

PD-1303-03

GONZALEZ, ARMANDO ARREGUIN AKA ARREGUIN, ARMANDO G. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-02-00291-CR

 

 

PD-1356-03

GUERRERO, RICHARD FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-03-00101-CR

 

 

PD-1357-03

GUERRERO, RICHARD FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-03-00102-CR

 

 

PD-1358-03

GUERRERO, RICHARD FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-03-00103-CR

 

 

PD-1461-03

GOODRUM, RANDY EDWARD FROM BRAZORIA COUNTY - 01-01-00950-CR

 

 

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

PD-0331-03

WOODEN, TRAYSON L. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-01-00395-CR

(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0487-03

YOUNG, MARION FROM BURLESON COUNTY - 01-01-01235-CR

(JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

 

 

PD-0945-03

SOSA, ROSALIO FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00242-CR

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER::

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT)

 

PD-1019-03

EDWARDS, KENNETH DEWAYNE FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-00036-CR

 

 

PD-1020-03

EDWARDS, KENNETH DEWAYNE FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-00037-CR

 

 

PD-1078-03

SMITH, DAVID L. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-03-00007-CR

(STRUCK WITH PREJUDICE)

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE WOMACK DISSENT)

(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)

 

 

PD-1082-03

SMITH, DAVID L. FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-03-00008-CR

(STRUCK WITH PREJUDICE)

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE WOMACK DISSENT)

(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)

 

 

PD-1259-03

MOYER, GARY LANE FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY - 03-02-00459-CR

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,793-01

SISK, MICHAEL L. ORANGE COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,098-01

TRACY, WARREN DUANE HUTCHINSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,114-01

SEPULVEDA, JESSIE EDWARD COMAL COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,124-01

CAMPBELL, DAVID ROBERT HARRISON COUNTY

 

 

WR-49,617-02

MORRISON, WILLIAM DEAN HUNT COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,917-02

CAPDVILLE, CHARLES G. DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,098-02

TRACY, WARREN DUANE HUTCHINSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-41,057-03

TURNER, MICHAEL OSHEA PALO PINTO COUNTY

 

 

WR-43,416-05

HOLDER, MICHAEL HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-43,416-06

HOLDER, MICHAEL HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-35,808-11

RIEDNER, JEFF PAUL BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-35,808-12

RIEDNER, JEFF PAUL BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-35,808-13

RIEDNER, JEFF PAUL BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-35,808-14

RIEDNER, JEFF PAUL BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (ON TRIAL COURT'S FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

WR-55,063-01

JESTER, CHAD WAYNE UPSHUR COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,783-01

GUTIERREZ, DARREL CHRIS DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,099-01

DICKSON, MARVIN TOM GREEN COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,101-01

BARRERA, ALEXANDER BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,143-01

ROREX, JAMES NORMAN III SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-46,078-02

WATKINS, JAMES DAVID TOM GREEN COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,410-02

IBARRA, ALEJANDRO DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,101-02

BARRERA, ALEXANDER BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,117-03

SMITH, DONALD WAYNE AKA WHITE, DONNIE SWISHER COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,117-04

SMITH, DONALD WAYNE AKA WHITE, DONNIE SWISHER COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (ART. 11.07, SEC. 4)

 

WR-46,467-02

PETE, CALVIN JOSEPH JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-52,269-04

BROWN, DEXTER HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-29,405-05

LY, TUAN VAN HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-30,119-10

CANADY, WARREN PIERRE HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-11,265-13

RANDLE, RICHARD JAMES ANDERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-44,986-16

NABELEK, IVO HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-44,986-17

NABELEK, IVO HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (TEX.GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081(b))

 

WR-56,773-01

MARTINEZ, BENANCIO FORT BEND COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,141-01

CLARK, ELLEN MARIE A/K/A ELLEN MOORE CLARK COLLIN COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,181-01

HORNER, MICHAEL STEPHEN DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-53,632-02

SHAMBLIN, RALPH WALLACE HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED FOR NONCOMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,979-01

CAILLETT, ROBERT ANTHONY GRAYSON COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

WR-56,412-01

WELCH, PHOEBE CASTRO COUNTY

 

 

WR-49,222-03

LAFFOON, JEFFREY ALLAN SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-54,577-03

SHAFER, MICHAEL PATRICK ROCKWALL COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

 

WR-55,571-01

CERDA, ROBERT LEE LUBBOCK COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,843-01

JOSEPH, LESTER CHARLES CHAMBERS COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,892-01

HIGGINS, ANDIE ROCKWALL COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,585-01

HINOJOSA, JAMES NUECES COUNTY

 

 

WR-39,622-07

RETZLAFF, THOMAS CHRISTOPHER BELL COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,197-01

JOHNSON, LONNIE EARL HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,947-01

JOHNSON, DERRICK LAMONE DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,987-01

GRIFFITH, MICHAEL DURWOOD HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-50,662-02

WILLIAMS, JEFFREY DEMOND HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-40,874-02

SMITH, ROBERT HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-47,911-02

RICHARD, MICHAEL HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,343-01

ROCKWELL, EDDIE TITUS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,946-01

CANTU, ARMANDO JESUS DALLAS COUNTY