THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
DECEMBER 2, 1998
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT:
73,237 EX PARTE RUDY CERVANTES GRACES FROM BEXAR COUNTY
73,238 EX PARTE RUDY CERVANTES GRACES FROM BEXAR COUNTY
73,239 EX PARTE RUBEN ESCALERA FROM BEXAR COUNTY
73,240 EX PARTE BENNY WHITE FROM DALLAS COUNTY
73,241 EX PARTE STEPHEN WHITMAN FROM BELL COUNTY
73,242 EX PARTE ADOLPH CECIL HAMILTON FROM MCLENNAN COUNTY
73,243 EX PARTE RODNEY JENKINS FROM SMITH COUNTY
73,244 EX PARTE HILLMAN LESLIE TROTTER FROM DALLAS COUNTY
73,245 EX PARTE ALEX DELEON CAMPOS FROM LEE COUNTY
73,246 EX PARTE RAYMOND H. GREENHAW, JR. FROM HENDERSON COUNTY
73,247 EX PARTE SERGIO SOTO FROM EL PASO COUNTY
73,248 EX PARTE CARLOS ANTONIO SIMPSON FROM DALLAS COUNTY
73,249 EX PARTE COREY LEE PAYNE FROM HARRIS COUNTY
73,250 EX PARTE CLINTON ODELL BONNER FROM BELL COUNTY
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED:
72,245 RON SHAMBURGER FROM BRAZOS COUNTY
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
1176-95 ARNOLDO ROBERTO GARCIA FROM CAMERON COUNTY
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD
(JUDGE HOLLAND CONCURS IN THE JUDGMENT)
(JUDGE OVERSTREET DISSENTS)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE WOMACK JOINS)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BAIRD
PUBLISHED OPINION
1177-95 ARNOLDO ROBERTO GARCIA FROM CAMERON COUNTY
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD
(JUDGE HOLLAND CONCURS IN THE JUDGMENT)
(JUDGE OVERSTREET DISSENTS)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE WOMACK JOINS)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BAIRD
PUBLISHED OPINION
1178-95 ARNOLDO ROBERTO GARCIA FROM CAMERON COUNTY
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD
(JUDGE HOLLAND CONCURS IN THE JUDGMENT)
(JUDGE OVERSTREET DISSENTS)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE WOMACK JOINS)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BAIRD
PUBLISHED OPINION
ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0382-97 LATONYA DENISE HARRELL FROM HARRIS COUNTY
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT AFFIRMED--PER CURIAM OPINION
(JUDGE BAIRD DISSENTS WITH NOTE)
(JUDGE OVERSTREET DISSENTS)
(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)
PUBLISHED OPINION
1424-98 ANTOINE UHURA JAMES FROM GREGG COUNTY
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 5;
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION
(JUDGE KELLER CONCURS AND DISSENTS WITH NOTE)
GROUNDS 1 THROUGH 4 AND 6 ARE REFUSED
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW
DENIED:
1179-98 ACOSTA, ERIC ROBERTO FROM HARRIS COUNTY
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
1205-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE FROM DALLAS COUNTY
1206-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE FROM DALLAS COUNTY
1207-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE FROM DALLAS COUNTY
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0981-98 CROW, JOHN BRADFORD HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00449-CR
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BAIRD
(JUDGE OVERSTREET JOINS)
1060-98 SANTACRUZ, JAVIER RAMIREZ GRAY COUNTY 07-97-00184-CR
1303-98 VIZCARRA, TOMAS EL PASO COUNTY 08-97-00103-CR
1305-98 PATTERSON, RICKY EL PASO COUNTY 08-97-00025-CR
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
1311-98 GRIFFIN, LESLIE LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00680-CR
1329-98 GUAJARDO, FRANK, JR. BEXAR COUNTY 07-97-00284-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1357-98 ANDERSON, AUBREY DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01802-CR
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
1379-98 EMPTY, WILLIE EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00224-CR
1380-98 EMPTY, WILLIE EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00225-CR
1400-98 ADAMS, KERPATRICK HAROLD HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01381-CR
1401-98 ADAMS, KERPATRICK HAROLD HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01382-CR
1403-98 GUERRA, EX PARTE GEORGE NUECES COUNTY 13-97-00269-CR
1404-98 KOLB, HOWARD W. JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-96-00375-CR
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)
1405-98 MOORE, CHARLES EDWARD DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01129-CR
1416-98 MCCOY, JASON RAY HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-00589-CR
1445-98 JACKSON, MARLON LYNEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00185-CR
1451-98 ROYTAN, MICHAEL JOSEPH PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-97-00211-CR
1462-98 DAVIS, TOM TRAVIS COUNTY 03-97-00176-CR
1471-98 MOLINA, MOISES HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01114-CR
1479-98 DELGADO, JUSTO B. TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00384-CR
1481-98 WILLIAMS, BILLY EARNEST, JR. MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-96-00317-CR
1514-98 JONES, MARVIN DWAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 11-97-00162-CR
1519-98 ROBINSON, PHILLIP EARL DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00402-CR
1548-98 TRAMMELL, CHRISTOPHER D. BELL COUNTY 03-97-00598-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1316-98 FITZSIMONS, BEN ECTOR COUNTY 08-97-00375-CR
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
0000-98 LEWIS, JOSEPH DEWITT COUNTY 13-96-00535-CR
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1390-98 JOHNSON, RESHAWN LEWAYNE LUBBOCK COUNTY07-97-00471-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
1430-98 PEREZ, ORLANDO JAVIER (SPA #1) CAMERON COUNTY13-97-00095-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
1430-98 PEREZ, ORLANDO JAVIER (DA#2) CAMERON COUNTY 13-97-00095-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
11,730-02 DONALD BRUCE JENSEN DALLAS COUNTY
21,089-04 RODNEY LOWELL MOORE TARRANT COUNTY
27,641-03 WILLIAM OWENS JR. LEON COUNTY
29,550-05 SIDNEY GLENN SPILLAR TARRANT COUNTY
29,550-06 SIDNEY GLENN SPILLAR TARRANT COUNTY
31,862-02 DAVID BJORN BRAZIEL JOHNSON COUNTY
35,693-02 ANDREW EARL WILLIAMS BRAZOS COUNTY
37,539-02 DONALD RAY RHODES BELL COUNTY
38,873-01 DORSEY L. ANDERSON SMITH COUNTY
38,898-01 BOBBY JAMES WHITE TARRANT COUNTY
38,920-02 HERMAN CHESTER JORDAN HARRIS COUNTY
39,018-01 TERRY D. SELLERS VICTORIA COUNTY
39,047-01 PHILLIP DAVID TAYLOR DALLAS COUNTY
39,588-01 ALONZO LOPEZ BEXAR COUNTY
39,633-01 MICHAEL JAY ALDRIDGE ECTOR COUNTY
39,642-01 BOBBY RAY WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
39,644-01 MORRIS EUGENE MATHIS TARRANT COUNTY
39,645-01 BOBBY DALLAS SHORTNACY TARRANT COUNTY
39,660-01 WILLIS ANTHONY DAVIS DALLAS COUNTY
39,681-01 CHARLES S. JOHNS HARRIS COUNTY
39,692-01 DAVID ZINGMARK BELL COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
10,916-08 SYLVON GATE FRANK HARRIS COUNTY
14,650-04 RICKEY WAYNE TOLBERT DALLAS COUNTY
18,753-02 JERRY JEFFERSON JR. HARRIS COUNTY
23,784-02 BOBBY LEONARD HARRIS COUNTY
30,636-03 TOMMIE LEROY FLORENCE DALLAS COUNTY
31,103-02 CLARENCE BROWN HARRIS COUNTY
33,881-02 WILLIE V. WILLIAMS GREGG COUNTY
34,780-01 MATTHEW BARNES DALLAS COUNTY
37,935-01 DONALD RAY DENNIS TARRANT COUNTY
38,696-01 KELLY LESLIE FLANNERY BRAZORIA COUNTY
38,926-01 BENJAMIN CARLTON HUDSON HARRIS COUNTY
38,932-01 RUBEN MENDEZ COLLIN COUNTY
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
38,946-01 COREY OISTAD HARRIS COUNTY
39,000-02 JIMMY RAY WATSON DALLAS COUNTY
39,012-01 ROBERT PENA YSASSI DALLAS COUNTY
39,107-01 JOHNNY JUDKINS JEFFERSON COUNTY
39,268-01 CHRISTINE EVON PAIGE HARRIS COUNTY
39,337-01 RICHARD LEE MEEKS HARRIS COUNTY
39,339-01 JEFFREY MCGILL MORRIS COUNTY
39,406-01 KERRY BURDITT TRAVIS COUNTY
39,423-01 ALFREDO LEAL MACHUCA CAMERON COUNTY
39,476-01 WILLIAM AMES MCCULLOCH HARRIS COUNTY
39,477-01 JUAN ANTONIO QUINTERO HARRIS COUNTY
39,497-01 BRANDON DESHON RICHARDSON MIDLAND COUNTY
39,561-01 JUAN FLORES VEGA DALLAS COUNTY
39,564-01 MARTHIC WHITE DALLAS COUNTY
39,566-01 DAVID BRANTLEY GREVENBERG HARRIS COUNTY
39,581-01 CLAUDE ALLEN LACY SMITH COUNTY
39,603-01 HENRY LEON MAXWELL MILAM COUNTY
39,618-02 MICHAEL GAONA DALLAS COUNTY
39,629-01 GENE J. NOLAN JEFFERSON COUNTY
39,649-01 JOE PATRICK MODDY BEXAR COUNTY
39,664-01 ERIC RAMOS SANTANA DALLAS COUNTY
39,665-01 ANTHONY TONELL WALKER DALLAS COUNTY
39,679-01 THOMAS WILLIAM SHEARER GILLESPIE COUNTY
39,679-02 THOMAS WILLIAM SHEARER GILLESPIE COUNTY
39,679-03 THOMAS WILLIAM SHEARER GILLESPIE COUNTY
39,682-01 GREGORY GENE RUFFIN HARRIS COUNTY
39,695-01 JUAN GARZA GARCIA FOARD COUNTY
39,716-01 MARK EUGENE CONOVER HARRIS COUNTY
39,733-01 JAMES HEBER RITCHIE TARRANT COUNTY
39,738-01 KEVIN DEWAYNE LEE TARRANT COUNTY
39,741-01 KERRY LYNN PRUDHOMME HARRIS COUNTY
5,421-12 LANDON RAY WARMSLEY TAYLOR COUNTY
7,361-02 ROBERT JONES CORTEZ SR. BEXAR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
20,370-03 JAMES RAY COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY
36,667-01 GREGORY K. HAWKINS GREGG COUNTY
37,719-01 KELVIN JEROME JEFFERSON MONTGOMERY COUNTY
38,903-01 WILLIAM GROOVER BEXAR COUNTY
38,907-01 KEVIN JACOB MORIN NUECES COUNTY
38,971-01 ANTHONY SEAN JOHNSON COLLIN COUNTY
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
39,129-01 SAUL DANIEL FLORES BEXAR COUNTY
39,659-01 JIMMIE RAY CARTER DALLAS COUNTY
39,661-01 HARRY THOMAS BLASSER DALLAS COUNTY
39,735-01 RODERICK DESHON CRENSHAW BRAZOS COUNTY
39,746-01 NOE ROBLEDO URESTI CAMERON COUNTY
5,789-02 JACKIE FIELD RALPH TARRANT COUNTY
7,355-03 MELVIN LOUIS ADAMS TARRANT COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
32,339-03 CHRISTIAN LARUE DALLAS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
17,257-06 FREDDY RAY HODGE DALLAS COUNTY
18,018-07 SHANE MCCLAIN CAIN GUADALUPE COUNTY
24,099-24 KEVIN LYNN REVELS HOUSTON COUNTY
27,934-03 OTIS PRICE DALLAS COUNTY
28,693-03 JIMMY LESLIE MCCOY HARRIS COUNTY
32,468-02 WALLY OWENS LUBBOCK COUNTY
35,329-02 LESTER EARL COLEMAN HARRIS COUNTY
37,919-02 LEON FLETCHER HALE COUNTY
5,421-11 LANDON RAY WARMSLEY TAYLOR COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
33,603-02 JUAN YRUEGAS YBARRA CROCKETT COUNTY
37,758-01 JOHNNY DEWAYNE HALL BRAZOS COUNTY
37,758-02 JOHNNY DEWAYNE HALL BRAZOS COUNTY
38,097-01 RANDY JOE BURSON WILLIAMSON COUNTY
(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)
38,109-01 DAVID WEEKS JEFFERSON COUNTY
38,163-01 DONALD LEE MCLEAN ERATH COUNTY
38,163-02 DONALD LEE MCLEAN ERATH COUNTY
38,952-01 JOHN RICHARD LILES TARRANT COUNTY
39,253-01 MICHAEL D. HOPSON BRAZOS COUNTY
39,372-01 PETE GARCIA BRAZOS COUNTY
39,528-01 EDWARD CHARLES FIGGERS BRAZOS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
16,556-03 KENNETH WAYNE THOMAS DALLAS COUNTY
(FILED AND SET ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD FILE AND SET ON GROUND NOS. 1 &2)
18,124-02 RAYMOND H. GREENHAW JR. HENDERSON COUNTY
36,568-01 ADOLPH C. HAMILTON MCLENNAN COUNTY
37,638-01 CARLOS ANTONIO SIMPSON DALLAS COUNTY
37,846-01 BENNY WHITE DALLAS COUNTY
38,525-01 ALEX DELEON CAMPOS LEE COUNTY
38,536-01 RUDY CERVANTES GRACES BEXAR COUNTY
39,023-01 RUBEN ESCALERA BEXAR COUNTY
39,367-01 CLINTON ODELL BONNER BELL COUNTY
39,394-01 STEPHEN WHITMAN BELL COUNTY
39,553-01 COREY LEE PAYNE HARRIS COUNTY
39,606-01 SERGIO SOTO EL PASO COUNTY
39,617-01 HILLMAN LESLIE TROTTER DALLAS COUNTY
39,627-01 RODNEY JENKINS SMITH COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
25,417-05 DAVID GLEN HARRIS TARRANT COUNTY
27,909-03 TROY DEWAYNE JOHNSON COUNTY
30,617-03 DEBRA LYNN PATMORE COUNTY
33,979-02 LYDELL WHITE DALLAS COUNTY
36,679-03 EMETERIO MARTINEZ HIDALGO COUNTY
37,805-01 JOHN E. SCOTT DALLAS COUNTY
38,490-01 JESUS MORIN JR. HIDALGO COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
37,950-01 JAMES BLAKE COLBURN MONTGOMERY COUNTY
39,495-01 WINDELL BROUSSARD JEFFERSON COUNTY
ORDER AFFIRMING TRIAL COURT'S DETERMINATION OF NO GOOD CAUSE FOR FILING
UNTIMELY APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS:
20,203-03 HENRY WATKINS SKINNER GRAY COUNTY