THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS

DECEMBER 15, 1999




THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:

72,775         HOWARD PAUL GUIDRY FROM HARRIS COUNTY

                    AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

                    (JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN POINTS 13 & 14 AND OTHERWISE JOINS)

                    (PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KELLER CONCUR)

                    CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND

                    PUBLISHED OPINION

73,101         WILLIAM E. WYATT FROM BOWIE COUNTY

APPEAL ABATED--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

73,180         EX PARTE NORMAN EDWARD CARRIO FROM HARRIS COUNTY

RELIEF DENIED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

(JUDGE MEYERS DISSENTS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

73,181         EX PARTE NORMAN EDWARD CARRIO FROM HARRIS COUNTY

RELIEF DENIED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

(JUDGE MEYERS DISSENTS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

73,653         JERRY FRANK BIRDWELL HARRIS COUNTY

RELIEF DENIED--OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURS WITH NOTE)

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURS)

PUBLISHED OPINION



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,649         EX PARTE MARCUS ONEIL RAY FROM DALLAS COUNTY

73,650         EX PARTE RYAN CANTRELL AYLESWORTH FROM COLEMAN COUNTY

73,651         EX PARTE JOHN ELLIOTT BUTLER FROM ECTOR COUNTY

73,652         EX PARTE ARMANDO REYNA FROM GREGG COUNTY

STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING DENIED: (SPA'S)

0996-98         JERRY T. SMITH FROM GARZA COUNTY

  DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK

  (JUDGES MANSFIELD, KELLER AND KEASLER JOIN)

  PUBLISHED OPINION

ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1426-98      WILLIAM EDWARD PLANTER FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT--OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

PUBLISHED OPINION

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0297-98       KYLE WALKER WRIGHT FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE PRICE JOINS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

1947-98       ERVIN JEROME DICKEY FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

JUDGMENT OF TRIAL COURT AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGES MANSFIELD AND HOLLAND JOIN)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE PRICE JOINS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

0786-99       DIONICIO VEGA GARZA FROM TARRANT COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

PUBLISHED OPINION

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1131-99       SANDERS, STEPHEN CHRISTIAN POTTER COUNTY 07-98-00298-CR

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINS)

1255-99         LAGAITE, LUIS SANTOS WALKER COUNTY 01-96-01302-CR

1264-99         ECHEVERRY, RUBEN DARIO JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00481-CR

1431-99         AGUILAR, EVANGELICA NUECES COUNTY 13-97-00348-CR

1626-99         MCCOY, GREGORY LEE GALVESTON COUNTY 14-96-01418-CR

1651-99         CASTRO, VICTOR BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00373-CR

1668-99         MASS, EUARL D. BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00693-CR

1688-99         VASQUEZ, JUAN ALBERTO HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00376-CR

1693-99         WHEELER, ALLEN CHRIS NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-98-00229-CR

1696-99         PAINTER, MARK ANTHONY DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00846-CR

1697-99         PAINTER, MARK ANTHONY DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00847-CR

1720-99         BARNES, LARRY HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00374-CR

1721-99         EMORY, GREGORY LYNN HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01381-CR

1725-99         GUSTAFSON, MEGAN BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00497-CR

1726-99         KIRK, JOSEPH MARSALES, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 04-98-00318-CR

1727-99         KIRK, JOSEPH MARSALES, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 04-98-00319-CR

1746-99         TAYLOR, GLENN EVERETT HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01396-CR

1751-99         MORALES, CRISPIN COLLIN COUNTY 06-98-00302-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

1757-99         GAMBRELL, BRUCE HAYS COUNTY 03-98-00349-CR

1760-99         BROWN, EPHRAM DONALD HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01296-CR

1761-99         CARTER, JOE SIRMONE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00556-CR

1767-99         PARKER, KATINA WALKER COUNTY 01-97-00200-CR

1768-99         BENFORD, BLANCHE HELENE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00231-CR

1770-99         FARRIS, CARL DWAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-00437-CR

1773-99         ALLEN-JONES, CATHERINE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-00467-CR

1774-99         HAWKINS, CHRISTOPHER EMILE BRAZOS COUNTY 01-98-00429-CR

1775-99         DUNN, DAVID FREESTONE COUNTY 10-98-00023-CR

1776-99         DUNN, DAVID FREESTONE COUNTY 10-98-00024-CR

1777-99         DUNN, DAVID FREESTONE COUNTY 10-98-00025-CR

1778-99         DUNN, DAVID FREESTONE COUNTY 10-98-00026-CR

1779-99         WHITE, JAMES PAUL TARRANT COUNTY 07-98-00122-CR

1816-99         HANFORD, RODNESSEUS ANDRE TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00575-CR

1819-99         PAYNE, RICHARD WILLIAM TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00123-CR

1820-99         PAYNE, RICHARD WILLIAM TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00124-CR

1821-99         PAYNE, RICHARD WILLIAM TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00125-CR

1918-99         RODRIGUEZ, JASON ANDY BEXAR COUNTY 04-95-00476-CR

1922-99         MARTIN, WADE AYLAR HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01436-CR

1942-99         MORRIS, WILLIAM DAVID IV DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-02014-CR

1944-99         WALLACE, ALPHONZO DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00045-CR

1945-99         WALLACE, ALPHONZO DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00046-CR

1946-99         WALLACE, A. CHRISTOPHER DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00047-CR

1949-99         DUPREE, LADONYA DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01979-CR

1958-99         FORBES, DANIEL AUGUSTUS DALLAS COUNTY 04-98-00174-CR

APPELLEE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1780-99         CLEMMER, MICHAEL ROBERT GUADALUPE COUNTY 07-97-00298-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0000-00         JAMES ALLEN FELDER DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01674-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

1254-99         BENJAMIN LEON BLUE HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00771-CR

                      (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1701-99         DONTAE ROBINSON BEXAR COUNTY 10-98-00194-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

1618-99         RODNEY DEE ROSS (SPA) AUSTIN COUNTY 14-98-00680-CR

                       (ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

12,903-04         STEVEN E. FINK TAYLOR COUNTY

21,769-02         WILLIE HOWARD ANDREWS, JR. HOUSTON COUNTY

25,184-02         MARCUS EARL JONES TARRANT COUNTY

25,863-06         WILLIAM L. KISSAM UPSHUR COUNTY

28,075-18         JONATHAN NATHAN BROCK BEXAR COUNTY

29,973-01         CLYDE DURBIN, JR. BURNET COUNTY

30,374-07         ROBERT WHITFIELD FREESTONE COUNTY

32,977-02         MASINURA MEICOMI PRICE DENTON COUNTY

34,413-02         MARK HENRY DILLON VAL VERDE COUNTY

34,413-03         MARK HENRY DILLON VAL VERDE COUNTY

38,185-02         RONALD D. WILLIS HARRIS COUNTY

39,569-02         MARK A. DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

41,711-02         MARCOS HERNANDEZ GALINDO REEVES COUNTY

42,510-02         LARRY BRINSON WICHITA COUNTY

42,814-01         JOHNNY RAY GOODEN ROCKWALL COUNTY

43,370-02         TIMOTHY PAUL DUKE DENTON COUNTY

43,481-02         JAMES MCCARTER HOUSTON COUNTY

43,668-01         ALFREDO PARDON LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,670-01         DARRELL WILSON TARRANT COUNTY

43,700-01         DAVID RODRIGUEZ BEXAR COUNTY

43,701-01         CHARLES KENT MILLER TARRANT COUNTY

43,705-01         WILLIAM T. WOOLVERTON ARANSAS COUNTY

43,710-01         BRIAN CARLYLE CLINE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,718-01         MALCOLM ABDUL MADDEN GREGG COUNTY

43,723-01         PAUL WESLEY TAYLOR CROCKETT COUNTY

43,725-01         PERRY WILLIAM FARWELL DALLAS COUNTY

43,740-01         KENNETH R SHED LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,747-02         LUZ DE LOS SANTOS HOWARD COUNTY

43,755-01         KENNETH EUGENE OVERTON TRAVIS COUNTY

43,760-01         JOHN EDWARD CRENSHAW POTTER COUNTY

43,774-01         RICK ROLDAN POTTER COUNTY

43,777-01         DENNIS WELBORN FRANKLIN VICTORIA COUNTY

43,777-02         DENNIS WELBORN FRANKLIN VICTORIA COUNTY

43,779-01         JOHNNIE LEE HENSLEE POTTER COUNTY

43,780-01         MICHAEL HUBBARD SMITH COUNTY

43,783-01         ALVIN DWIGHT ROUNDTREE VICTORIA COUNTY

43,785-01         DAVID EARL SMITH TARRANT COUNTY

43,787-01         VINCENT WILLIAMS TARRANT COUNTY

43,795-01         WADE A. PETERSON POTTER COUNTY

43,798-01         MANUEL LAVARIO MORALES ECTOR COUNTY

43,802-01         BOBBY ROBINSON SMITH TARRANT COUNTY

43,810-01         KENNETH L. GRAHAM TARRANT COUNTY

43,812-01         JERRY MATA HALE COUNTY

43,819-01         RAYMOND R. JARVIS POTTER COUNTY

43,820-01         JUAN PABLO ZUMAYA JACKSON COUNTY

43,823-01         KEVIN ROYCE CLARK TARRANT COUNTY

43,824-01         CHARLES EDWARD POOL TARRANT COUNTY

43,826-01         JIMMIE ROY BUSH TITUS COUNTY

43,828-01         TRACY LEE PATTERSON KERR COUNTY

43,829-01         BUDDY NEAL MATHENY CHEROKEE COUNTY

43,830-01         GREGORY CROUSE EL PASO COUNTY

43,830-02         GREGORY CROUSE EL PASO COUNTY

43,845-01         JIMMY WAYNE WILLELL EL PASO COUNTY

43,847-01         MILTON LEE GARDNER FREESTONE COUNTY

43,849-01         CHRISTOPHER LYNN HAMPTON TARRANT COUNTY

43,855-01         ALCARIO S. REYNA RANDALL COUNTY

43,867-01         ARNOLD TREVINO NUECES COUNTY

43,869-01         DAVID URQUIZA GUADALUPE COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

17,002-03         RALPH PAUL WILLIAMSON, JR. MONTGOMERY COUNTY

17,823-04         JAMES HENRY ELLIS DALLAS COUNTY

26,427-02         ARMANDO SIMON BRAZORIA COUNTY

28,586-02         RICHARD BRYAN KUSSMAUL MCLENNAN COUNTY

30,500-02         RAY CHARLES DAVIS TRAVIS COUNTY

36,614-02         ROBERT THOMAS VIDAL KLEBERG COUNTY

38,383-05         JIMMY LYNN BRUTON TOM GREEN COUNTY

38,383-06         JIMMY LYNN BRUTON TOM GREEN COUNTY

38,812-01         RAE ELLEN KILLEBREW DALLAS COUNTY

39,529-02         LARRY C. PEROT DALLAS COUNTY

40,293-02         RAYMOND T. JONES TRAVIS COUNTY

41,206-02         EDWARD CLAY MCCABE GALVESTON COUNTY

42,071-02         RICARDO HERNANDEZ LOPEZ JR. ELLIS COUNTY

42,071-03         RICARDO HERNANDEZ LOPEZ JR. ELLIS COUNTY

42,071-04         RICARDO HERNANDEZ LOPEZ JR. ELLIS COUNTY

42,501-02         RUBEN CANTU JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY

42,662-02         DANIEL DEVON JOHNSON BRAZORIA COUNTY

43,213-02         ARTURO RIVERA NUECES COUNTY

43,662-01         JERRY LEE EDWARDS BEXAR COUNTY

43,679-01         KYLE MCDONALD TOM GREEN COUNTY

43,698-01         KENDALL MCMAHON BANDERA COUNTY

43,707-01         MARK GUEVARA BEXAR COUNTY

43,720-01         DICKIE WAYNE PILKINGTON SMITH COUNTY

43,729-01         GERALD DOUGLAS TARRANT COUNTY

43,736-01         MICHAEL RAY COOPER LAMAR COUNTY

43,749-01         THOMAS EDWARD MEDLIN DALLAS COUNTY

43,762-01         WILLIE BEAVER DALLAS COUNTY

43,765-01         RONNIE BRINSON TRAVIS COUNTY

43,769-01         LELAND JOHNSON BELL COUNTY

43,771-01         JOE NATHAN WHITE GRAYSON COUNTY

43,773-01         JESSE ELMER WHITED JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

43,784-01         CHRISTOPHER DARRELL SHAW MCLENNAN COUNTY

43,786-01         HERMAN CHARLES WHITE TARRANT COUNTY

43,809-01         DOLPH BOEN MCLENNAN COUNTY

43,817-01         BOBBY LEE MCELROY DALLAS COUNTY

43,818-01         BERNARD LEDON BEXAR COUNTY

43,825-01         WAYMON LEE GARRETT BELL COUNTY

43,866-01         MICHAEL A. WOOD TOM GREEN COUNTY

43,871-01         JESSE GARCIA DAVILA BEXAR COUNTY

43,872-01         DAVID B. HERNANDEZ BEXAR COUNTY

43,873-01         ANTHONY PAUL JOHNSON SMITH COUNTY

43,877-01         MARTY A. HOSSEINI BEXAR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)

25,863-05         WILLIAM L. KISSAM SMITH COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

42,833-01         PETER MINIEL HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

13,364-05         ELMER LOCKETT BRAZOS COUNTY

15,186-04         DOUGLAS BROWN TRAVIS COUNTY

25,042-04         VERNON WALTER ROBERTS HARRIS COUNTY

37,037-01         PETE VARDAS WALKER COUNTY

43,744-01         BILLY DEWAYNE JONES DALLAS COUNTY

43,778-01         ROY LEE FULLER BEXAR COUNTY

43,788-01         SCHUSKEY FLYNN MILO RANDALL COUNTY

43,792-01         RUBEN DURAN BEXAR COUNTY

43,864-01         KENNETH ALLEN RIOS CAMERON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

31,069-02         HENRY CHRISTOPHER COSBY DALLAS COUNTY

43,794-01         WALLACE J. EATON GREGG COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

18,794-04         ISRAEL MORA TAYLOR COUNTY

20,263-07         WILLIAM BOYD PIERCE DENTON COUNTY

29,392-05         JOHN THOMAS BAGLEY DALLAS COUNTY

36,117-02         RAYMOND YOUNG MCLENNAN COUNTY

42,136-02         VERNA IRENE MARQUEZ POTTER COUNTY

9,993-09         EDDIE FRANKLIN DOUGLAS TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

11,518-02         HENRY LEE COLBERT WICHITA COUNTY

22,012-07         TONY LEE WILLIAMS DALLAS COUNTY

29,973-02         CLYDE DURBIN, JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

41,866-01         HECTOR REYNA RUIZ LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,159-01         MICHAEL S. MURPHY TARRANT COUNTY

43,180-01         RUSSELL LESLIE WALLACE ANDERSON COUNTY

43,568-01         NORMAN RUSSELL LEWIS CASS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

33,569-01         JERRY FRANK BIRDWELL HARRIS COUNTY

35,984-02         GREGORY BUTLER ECTOR COUNTY

43,567-01         MARCUS ONEIL RAY DALLAS COUNTY

43,658-01         ARMANDO REYNA GREGG COUNTY

43,734-01         RYAN CANTRELL AYLESWORTH COLEMAN COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

25,631-12         DONALD FRENCH COUNTY

26,037-18         JOHNNY DWAYNE STATEN TARRANT COUNTY

26,037-19         JOHNNY DWAYNE STATEN TARRANT COUNTY

26,037-20         JOHNNY DWAYNE STATEN TARRANT COUNTY

30,875-04         FELIX GARCIA WEBB COUNTY

43,150-02         WILLIE LEE WILLIAMS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

43,355-01         ARTHUR LARKINS HARRIS COUNTY

43,490-02         ANSON VERNON MOORE II TARRANT COUNTY

43,746-01         CLARENCE S. DANGLER BEXAR COUNTY

43,791-01         RICHARD ANCIRA TRAVIS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

12,952-03         LARRY KEITH ROBISON TARRANT COUNTY

                         (STAY OF EXECUTION OF AUGUST 17, 1999 IS VACATED)

2,264-04         CARL EDWARD NAPIER HARRIS COUNTY

42,639-01         ROBERT CHARLES LADD SMITH COUNTY

43,659-01         JERMARR CARLOS ARNOLD NUECES COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

43,696-01         JERRY SIMMONS HARRIS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

9,227-03         SAMMIE FELDER, JR. HARRIS COUNTY

(DENIED 12-10-99)

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

11,202-11         FREDDIE LOUIS BREWER HARRIS COUNTY

41,467-04         RICHARD EARL GAMBLES LUBBOCK COUNTY

35,711-02         ROBERT JAMES FOX DALLAS COUNTY