THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS






JANUARY 21, 2004






THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:

 

 

AP-74,294

GARCIA, FRANK MARTINEZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY

AFFIRMED-OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB

(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

AP-74,760

CESAR DELEON, ET AL & EDUARDO CHAVEZ, ET AL FROM EL PASO COUNTY

MANDAMUS RELIEF CONDITIONALLY GRANTED-OPINION JUDGE HERVEY

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER DISSENTED)

PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED-OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON PUBLISHED OPINION)

 

AP-74,866

LEIVA, EX PARTE EDUARDO FROM TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

AP-74,867

KINCANON, EX PARTE AARON LYNN A/K/A AARON LYNN KINCANNON FROM HUTCHINSON COUNTY

 

 

ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

 

PD-1038-03

MOORE, RANDY LEE FROM POTTER COUNTY - 07-97-00489-CR

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

VACATED COA; REMANDED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1039-03

MOORE, RANDY LEE FROM POTTER COUNTY - 07-97-00490-CR

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

VACATED COA; REMANDED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

PD-1213-03

BOOKSH, JAMES FROM TRAVIS COUNTY - 03-02-00200-CR

 

APPELLANT'S MOTION TO DISMISS IS GRANTED:

DISMISSED-PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

 

PD-1298-03

HARRIS, JONATHAN MERCHANT FROM COLLIN COUNTY - 05-02-01761-CR

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

PD-0650-03

DELARUE, LANCE COREY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-01-01182-CR

 

 

PD-1081-03

REISTER, ROGER FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00373-CR

 

 

PD-1156-03

RAMOS, JOSE FROM ANGELINA COUNTY - 09-02-00090-CR

 

 

PD-1201-03

HAWKINS, PRESTON DENVER FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY - 13-01-00576-CR

 

 

PD-1226-03

HILLS, WILLIE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00379-CR

 

 

PD-1227-03

NEWKIRK, SUZANNE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00537-CR

 

 

PD-1313-03

BELLAIRE, HARRY G. FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00501-CR

 

 

PD-1315-03

MANOR, CARL FROM TRAVIS COUNTY - 03-02-00455-CR

 

 

PD-1328-03

CARMONA, RUDY FROM TRAVIS COUNTY - 03-02-00201-CR

 

 

PD-1332-03

MCDONALD, LARRY FROM TRAVIS COUNTY - 03-02-00582-CR

 

 

PD-1378-03

DODD, ROGER LAVOY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-03-00552-CR

 

 

PD-1449-03

BOSLEY, ROBERT RAY FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-02-00328-CR

 

 

PD-1464-03

BAKER, JEROME FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY - 07-01-00203-CR

 

 

PD-1467-03

PAYNE, MARANTZ BRANDON FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 04-02-00514-CR

 

 

PD-1469-03

WRIGHT, GERALD LOYD FROM POTTER COUNTY - 07-02-00308-CR

 

 

PD-1549-03

BENITEZ, JAMIE FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY - 07-02-00252-CR

 

 

PD-1597-03

HENNIGAN, MELTON WAYNE FROM ORANGE COUNTY - 13-01-00572-CR

 

 

PD-1622-03

MOSLEY, KEITH O'BRYANT FROM WALLER COUNTY - 07-02-00179-CR

 

 

PD-1638-03

GAUTHIER, MAURICE FROM TARRANT COUNTY - 02-02-00326-CR

 

 

PD-1652-03

WOMACK, CLYDE EDWARD FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-02-00908-CR

 

 

PD-1708-03

HOOKER, VAN DARON FROM NACOGDOCHES COUNTY - 12-02-00173-CR

 

 

PD-1709-03

WASHINGTON, DAMIEN FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-01095-CR

 

 

PD-1710-03

ESPARZA, RIGEOBERTO SANCHEZ FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-01117-CR

 

 

PD-1711-03

HAWKINS, MARCUS S. FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00717-CR

 

 

PD-1712-03

MANNING, CHARLES EDWARD, JR. FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00892-CR

 

 

PD-1713-03

CHIA-OCHOA, LUIS ALBERTO FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00857-CR

 

 

PD-1732-03

MCKOY, KEVIN HENRY FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-01-01403-CR

 

 

PD-1735-03

MIMMS, RICKY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-01196-CR

 

 

PD-1737-03

JOSHUA, HERMAN LEE FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00730-CR

 

 

PD-1740-03

JANG, JO SIC AKA JANG, HO SIK FROM COLLIN COUNTY - 05-02-01343-CR

 

 

PD-1741-03

JANG, JO SIC AKA JANG, HO SIK FROM COLLIN COUNTY - 05-02-01344-CR

 

 

PD-1742-03

JANG, JO SIC AKA JANG, HO SIK FROM COLLIN COUNTY - 05-02-01345-CR

 

 

PD-1744-03

GARZA, LINDA A/K/A LINDA NELSON FROM GALVESTON COUNTY - 14-02-00766-CR

 

 

PD-1751-03

STEIN, THOMAS LEE FROM TAYLOR COUNTY - 11-02-00285-CR

 

 

PD-1766-03

GARAY, RUBEN VALENZUELA AKA MORENO, RUBEN GARAY FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00336-CR

 

 

PD-1767-03

MOSLEY, KEITH O'BRYANT FROM WALLER COUNTY - 07-02-00178-CR

 

 

PD-1775-03

OLGUIN, TRINA LYNN FROM ECTOR COUNTY - 08-02-00241-CR

 

 

PD-1780-03

FERREL, JAY LUIS FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00893-CR

 

 

PD-1781-03

JOHNSON, TORRANCE HABIT FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-00901-CR

 

 

PD-1782-03

GALINDO, MARIA CRISTINA FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00230-CR

 

 

PD-1784-03

JASSO, JUAN JOSE FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00231-CR

 

 

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

 

PD-0650-03

DELARUE, LANCE COREY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-01-01182-CR

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

 

PD-0916-02

GARCIA, ROGELIO GARZA FROM CAMERON COUNTY - 13-00-00752-CR

 

 

PD-1560-03

JOHNSTON, JACK ALLEN FROM COLORADO COUNTY - 01-01-01218-CR

 

 

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER::

(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT)

 

PD-0339-03

PORTER, JAMES HENRY FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 14-02-01027-CR

 

 

PD-0790-03

FULCHER, DENNIS LYNN FROM GALVESTON COUNTY - 14-93-00964-CR

 

 

PD-1451-03

TAYLOR, EX PARTE RAYMOND FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00252-CR

 

 

PD-1658-03

JONES, TERMAINE FROM LUBBOCK COUNTY - 07-98-00004-CR

 

 

PD-1678-03

FLORES, EX PARTE ROBERTO FROM EL PASO COUNTY - 08-01-00213-CR

 

 

PD-1791-03

MCQUEEN, RAYMOND JAMES JR. FROM DALLAS COUNTY - 05-02-01245-CR

 

 

PD-1807-03

DANIEL, JEFFRIE ANTERIES FROM BEXAR COUNTY - 04-02-00484-CR

 

 

PD-1808-03

CLARK, WILLIE JAMES FROM HARRIS COUNTY - 01-00-01235-CR

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-54,686-01

DIAZ, UBALDO STARR COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,361-01

CALLAWAY, DAVID WAYNE WICHITA COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,502-01

SIMMS, CLYDE L. VICTORIA COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,590-01

THOMPSON, MICHAEL JOHN TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,774-01

DAVIS, LEE A. JR. DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,779-01

HARRIS, RUSSELL HAMILTON BRAZOS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,871-01

SHUTTER, CLARK DALE HARDIN COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,916-01

BANDA, ROBERT DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,011-01

AYALA, ALBERT ANDERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,016-01

PEREZ, SERGIO TERRY COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,020-01

WHEAT, JIMMY B. HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,023-01

MARTINEZ, PEDRO JR. BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-36,526-02

UDOH, MICHAEL TOMMY TARRANT COUNTY

(JUDGES MEYERS, PRICE, JOHNSON AND HOLCOMB WOULD FILE AND SET FOR ORAL ARGUMENT)

 

 

WR-47,583-02

SANNA, MICHAEL CEPHUS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

 

 

WR-47,777-02

PRICE, GARY LEE TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,208-02

HAYNES, LEVI C HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,858-02

DEWBERRY, ANDRE'A DEMONT SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,871-02

SHUTTER, CLARK DALE HARDIN COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,916-02

BANDA, ROBERT DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,023-02

MARTINEZ, PEDRO JR. BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-17,746-03

DUNBAR, ARTHUR LEE JR. LEON COUNTY

 

 

WR-35,265-03

DABBS, HARRELL DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-46,083-03

SLATER, JOE FRANK ERATH COUNTY

 

 

WR-47,583-03

SANNA, MICHAEL CEPHUS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

 

 

WR-47,777-03

PRICE, GARY LEE TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

WR-10,564-22

DENBY, PERRY COMO HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (ON TRIAL COURT'S FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

 

WR-56,669-01

COUCH, FRED TYLER COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,385-01

GREEN, ANTHONY RAY HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,554-01

JOSEPH, DENNIS ANTHONY JR HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,570-01

JIMINEZ, CARLOS HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,600-01

WILLIAMS, GERALDMARA JERMAINE HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-01

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,651-01

BUTLER, JESSE RAY SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,661-01

PERRY, CHRISTOPHER DES MOINES HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,669-01

GAMARSH, JEFF STEVEN TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,690-01

JELKS, SHAQUAN J. HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,877-01

RAMIREZ, CESAR FRANCISCO WEBB COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,907-01

FERGUSON, RONALD LEWIS DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,013-01

JACKSON, ALVIN JAY DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-18,506-02

TOMLINSON, STEPHEN DOUGLAS HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,006-02

HEWITT, DONALD RAY JR. GRAYSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,356-02

MORGAN, GEORGE CLERON HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,669-02

COUCH, FRED TYLER COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-02

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,661-02

PERRY, CHRISTOPHER DES MOINES HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-18,506-03

TOMLINSON, STEPHEN DOUGLAS HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,669-03

COUCH, FRED TYLER COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-03

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,661-03

PERRY, CHRISTOPHER DES MOINES HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-26,153-04

SMITH, ANZETTA HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-53,078-04

ESTRELLO, CERVANDO SAM DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,030-04

HENLINE, JERRY LEE GRAYSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-04

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-53,078-05

ESTRELLO, CERVANDO SAM DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-56,030-05

HENLINE, JERRY LEE GRAYSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-05

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-53,078-06

ESTRELLO, CERVANDO SAM DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,645-06

PHAM, VUONG MINH JEFFERSON COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-57,453-01

SPIER, GARY DWAINE WALLER COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,628-01

GARZA, GILBERT MONTGOMERY COUNTY

 

 

WR-55,190-02

PEERY, JAMES KEVIN SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-19,388-07

MCCOIN, BEN LAMAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-19,388-08

MCCOIN, BEN LAMAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-19,388-09

MCCOIN, BEN LAMAR COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

 

WR-57,959-01

SALAZAR, RAMIRO JR. BEXAR COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,010-01

REYES, JOHNNY HALE COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (ART. 11.07, SEC. 4)

 

WR-46,083-02

SLATER, JOE FRANK ERATH COUNTY

 

 

WR-53,448-03

SHAW, DESIREE ANN ANGELINA COUNTY

 

 

WR-37,743-04

TANKSLEY, MYRON BERNARD DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-50,690-04

ARANDA, ROQUE TERCERO GAINES COUNTY

 

 

WR-30,869-06

THOMPSON, ROY T. HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-26,047-10

STRHAN, LARRY GENE DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-10,564-21

DENBY, PERRY COMO HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER: (TEX.GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081(b))

 

WR-56,375-02

WADKINS, JOHN ORANGE COUNTY

 

 

WR-31,657-05

SPENCER, KENDALL TREMAYNE CORYELL COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED FOR NONCOMPLIANCE WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-57,846-01

SLATON, PAUL LENARD HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,007-01

DULLENTY, DALE ALLEN DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,846-02

SLATON, PAUL LENARD HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-45,445-04

WILLIAMS, TONY HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

 

WR-56,858-01

DEWBERRY, ANDRE'A DEMONT SMITH COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-01

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,764-01

SMITH, EDWARD ERNELL DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,782-01

BAXTER, SHANNON SAN JACINTO COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-02

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,764-02

SMITH, EDWARD ERNELL DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-03

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-04

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-05

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-06

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-07

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,440-08

MONK, ROGER DALE HOPKINS COUNTY

 

 

WR-19,388-10

MCCOIN, BEN RED RIVER COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

 

WR-56,864-01

MABRY, ANDREW MICHAEL DENTON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,796-01

KINCANON, AARON LYNN AKA KINCANNON, AARON LYNN HUTCHINSON COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,832-01

LEIVA, EDUARDO TARRANT COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-56,856-01

GALLOWAY, BILLY JOHN HUNT COUNTY

 

 

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-47,160-02

WOOTEN, LARRY WAYNE LAMAR COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

 

WR-57,558-01

BATEMAN, WILLIE HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,000-01

CARTER, GREGORY DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

 

WR-57,546-01

HENDERSON, KENNETH ELLIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,862-01

PENA, JUAN PADRON COLLIN COUNTY

 

 

WR-58,003-01

JONES, ANTHONY RAY DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

WR-50,868-02

MILLER, LEE NICHOLS HARRIS COUNTY

 

 

WR-57,361-02

CALLAWAY, DAVID WAYNE WICHITA COUNTY

 

 

WR-15,002-03

SMITH, JR., WILLIE LEE

 

 

WR-17,746-04

DUNBAR, ARTHUR LEE JR. LEON COUNTY

 

 

WR-26,047-09

STRHAN, LARRY GENE

 

 

HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH A WRITTEN ORDER

 

WR-49,233-05

BOWERS, LLOYD GEORGE TARRANT COUNTY