THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS

JANUARY 26, 2000


THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:


73,193         ELROY CHESTER FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,686         EX PARTE OTIS FRANK CLAYBROOK FROM MONTGOMERY COUNTY

73,687         EX PARTE MANUEL GARCIA FROM CAMERON COUNTY

73,688         EX PARTE RICHARD JOSEPH MCMASTER FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY

73,689         EX PARTE ANTHONY ANTWAN GORDON FROM LAMAR COUNTY

73,690         EX PARTE WILLIE PAUL EDMOND FROM TAYLOR COUNTY

73,691         EX PARTE EMETERIO MARTINEZ FROM HIDALGO COUNTY

ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0614-99       RONALD C. CARMOUCHE FROM ANGELINA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

1781-99       SCOTT MATTISON LAWSON FROM DEAF SMITH COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON GROUND 1;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION




ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0362-98       SYBILLE WHALEY RAY FROM PANOLA COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION


1728-98       RAYMOND TAYLOR FROM EL PASO COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGE MANSFIELD DISSENTS WITH NOTE)

PUBLISHED OPINION

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

1840-99         JORGE HUMBERTO PESINA CAMERON COUNTY 13-98-00008-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1520-99         HUMPHRIES, JOSHUA JOHN ECTOR COUNTY 08-96-00269-CR

1586-99         DAVIS, TAMARCUS JERMAINE HARRIS COUNTY 10-97-00127-CR

1603-99         WITHERS, MARGARET (PDR #2) HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00803-CR

1762-99         BRAGA, JAMIE HIPOLITO HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01370-CR

1764-99         ABALOS, ALFREDO FORT BEND COUNTY 01-95-00734-CR

1766-99         HUNTLEY III, JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01205-CR

1771-99         FARRIS, CARL DWAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-00438-CR

1772-99         FARRIS, CARL DWAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-00439-CR

1864-99         BENJAMIN, ROD REAGAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01291-CR

1866-99         BURNS, CLIFTON ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00102-CR

1869-99         CASEY, HERMAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01254-CR

1870-99         ZUNIGA, DARIO HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01290-CR

1871-99         GUEVARA, DENNIS G. HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00903-CR

1872-99         BLAKE, RICHARD LEE, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01476-CR

1873-99         GUAJARDO, RAQUEL HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00522-CR

1877-99         MCCLOUD, KEITH ALEXANDER HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01321-CR

1878-99         GOODS, EUGENE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-01285-CR

1938-99         BANKSTON, RONALD HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00359-CR

1943-99         CATALAN, MOISES MONDRAGON DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01322-CR

1947-99         BULLOCK, JEFFREY LANE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00389-CR

1948-99         GREENWOOD, EMMANUEL HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00098-CR

1952-99         HERNANDEZ, FERNANDO, JR. BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00862-CR

1953-99         ROBERSON, KEVIN DAWAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00224-CR

1956-99         RIBELIN, GEORGE ALAN DENTON COUNTY 02-98-00187-CR

1957-99         RIBELIN, GEORGE ALAN DENTON COUNTY 02-98-00188-CR

1961-99         COOK, RICHARD L., JR. LLANO COUNTY 03-98-00494-CR

2045-99         KELLY, GARY L. TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00247-CR

2071-99         ALFRED, RICHARD LEE MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-98-00335-CR

2074-99         DAVIS, JOHN ROBERT DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00429-CR

2084-99         KING, RONNIE LYDELL DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00429-CR

2097-99         SAUER, KEITH ROBERT MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-98-00107-CR

2100-99         POLLER, ROBERT POLK COUNTY 11-98-00241-CR

2104-99         MORGAN, TIMOTHY DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00461-CR

2118-99         CRIDER, JAMES CHARLES MIDLAND COUNTY 08-98-00038-CR

2119-99         GARZA, RICARDO JACKSON COUNTY 13-98-00406-CR

2130-99         DRAPER, DREWARD A. DALLAS COUNTY 06-98-00304-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1555-99         GAILES, DERRICK MARK HARRIS COUNTY 13-97-00393-CR

1603-99         WITHERS, MARGARET (SPA'S #1) HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00803-CR

1707-99         JORDAN, QUENTIN LAVAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-96-00533-CR

                       (JUDGE MANSFIELD WOULD GRANT)

APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1722-99         BRUNI, FREDERICK BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00908-CR

                       (JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)

1723-99         BRUNI, FREDERICK BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00909-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0000-00         CALAHAN, SPENCER HEWELL VAN ZANDT COUNTY 12-99-00284-CR

                        (REFUSED 1-19-00)

0000-00         PRUITT, CURTIS VAUGHN DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-02028-CR

                        (REFUSED 1-19-00)

0000-00         VILLASANA, GONZALO COLLIN COUNTY 11-98-00304-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

                        (REFUSED 1-20-00)

0184-00         LANN, SIE JOE LA SALLE COUNTY 04-98-00812-CR

0191-00         FRAZIER, JAMES MILTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-02166-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

1698-99         BURDEN, RALPH CLINTON, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-01464-CR

                        (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

10,196-02         DAVID FRANK MORGAN HOWARD COUNTY

10,196-03         DAVID FRANK MORGAN HOWARD COUNTY

10,196-04         DAVID FRANK MORGAN HOWARD COUNTY

11,639-15         PETE BENEVIDES GALVESTON COUNTY

17,262-04         SAMUEL J. KEY YOAKUM COUNTY

22,768-06         JESSE JOE SOLIZ VICTORIA COUNTY

23,161-05         ERVIN LOUIS FLINT PALO PINTO COUNTY

25,725-02         DANNY MAC EASTERLY ROCKWALL COUNTY

3,099-08           MICHAEL CARTER DALLAS COUNTY

41,796-02         FRANCISCO JAVIER VALDEZ DALLAS COUNTY

43,263-02         GREGORY ALLEN KIDD TARRANT COUNTY

43,719-01         GARY PAUL ANDERS LIBERTY COUNTY

43,756-01         RICKY DEWAYNE HOWELL LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,996-01         WILLIAM LUTHER BURNHAM TARRANT COUNTY

44,151-01         HERBERT EUGENE ETIE HENDERSON COUNTY

44,152-01         JENNIFER LYNN FORBING ERATH COUNTY

44,184-01         ERNEST GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

44,195-01         CLEARANCE ALBERT DUPREE HOUSTON COUNTY

44,204-01         ROGER EDWARDS TARRANT COUNTY

44,221-01         HAROLD EUGENE MERCHANT DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

12,551-06         MICHAEL JOSEPH DERROW HARRIS COUNTY

15,863-03         ROY STURDIVANT HARRIS COUNTY

22,480-04         JEROME HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY

27,983-02         GARY FRANCIS COURTNEY BEXAR COUNTY

35,808-07         JEFF PAUL RIEDNER BEXAR COUNTY

35,808-08         JEFF PAUL RIEDNER BEXAR COUNTY

35,808-09         JEFF PAUL RIEDNER BEXAR COUNTY

35,808-10         JEFF PAUL RIEDNER BEXAR COUNTY

37,212-02         L.A. JONES DALLAS COUNTY

38,804-02         FREDERICK LEE MCLENNAN MCLENNAN COUNTY

40,718-03         JOE HEADRICK DALLAS COUNTY

43,588-01         CODY WAYNE WOLF BELL COUNTY

43,870-01         GARY EVAN PERDUE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                            (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,993-01         DAVID SCOTT SMITH CORYELL COUNTY

43,993-02         DAVID SCOTT SMITH BOSQUE COUNTY

43,993-03         DAVID SCOTT SMITH MCLENNAN COUNTY

44,054-01         RICHARD GRACE BEXAR COUNTY

44,100-01         ALFRED GARZA HARRIS COUNTY

44,105-01         MICHAEL JOE THURMOND GREGG COUNTY

44,113-02         MICHAEL S. MEYER BEXAR COUNTY

44,134-01         JOSE PALOS HIDALGO COUNTY

44,147-01         ELLIE HUGHES GREEN TARRANT COUNTY

44,158-01         JACK WAYNE MCNEAL JR. DALLAS COUNTY

44,159-01         CARLOS MIGUEL MORELAND MCLENNAN COUNTY

44,186-01         RAY ANTHONY HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY

44,194-01         SHANE PARDUE MIDLAND COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

21,054-08         RAYMOND CLAYTON DALLAS COUNTY

22,935-06         KENNETH WAYNE THOMAS RUNNELS COUNTY

23,161-06         ERVIN LOUIS FLINT ARCHER COUNTY

41,789-02         RODNEY EUGENE JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY

44,113-01         MICHAEL S. MEYER BEXAR COUNTY

44,179-01         JUAN RAPHAEL MERCADO BEXAR COUNTY

44,185-01         CARL N. GERHARDT HARTLEY COUNTY

44,207-01         GILBERT Y. MORALES BEXAR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

40,389-02         ROBERT TROY KNOTEN DALLAS COUNTY

44,119-01         JESSE TODD FREEMAN BEXAR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC. 4)

22,554-02         DOYLE DUDLEY TRIMBLE DALLAS COUNTY

26,078-02         GEORGE VASQUEZ WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                            (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

28,334-03         HERMAN LEE HALL TARRANT COUNTY

30,429-03         CHRISTOPHER L. CARTER ECTOR COUNTY

40,323-02         MICHAEL TODD SONTCHI HARRIS COUNTY

43,548-02         JAMES WESLEY CAMPBELL LAMAR COUNTY

9,820-07         ALFREDO HERNANDEZ DALLAS COUNTY

9,820-08         ALFREDO HERNANDEZ DALLAS COUNTY

 

 

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

43,489-03         KEVIN LEE MCCARROLL BAYLOR COUNTY

43,730-01         OSCAR ROSARIO HARRIS COUNTY

43,911-01         MARTIN HEPNER DENTON COUNTY

43,954-01         TIMOTHY JAMES WINTER MILAM COUNTY

44,005-01         JOSEPH DEWAYNE TILLEY CHEROKEE COUNTY

44,013-01         JONATHAN DEWAYNE CAIN DENTON COUNTY

44,016-01         JAMES RONALD WOLFE COOKE COUNTY

44,037-01         NAPOLEAN BURTON EL PASO COUNTY

5,225-02           ISABEL POLANCO LOZANO JR. MIDLAND COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

36,679-04         EMETERIO MARTINEZ HIDALGO COUNTY

41,693-01         WILLIE PAUL EDMOND TAYLOR COUNTY

43,250-02         RICHARD JOSEPH MCMASTER WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                            (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

43,318-01         OTIS FRANK CLAYBROOK MONTGOMERY COUNTY

43,610-01         ANTHONY ANTWAN GORDON LAMAR COUNTY

43,884-01         MANUEL GARCIA CAMERON COUNTY





MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

12,126-05         GARY WAYNE KIRKSEY TARRANT COUNTY

32,251-02         RICHARD ANCIRA TRAVIS COUNTY

38,618-03         ARTHUR BENJAMIN LEWIS HARRIS COUNTY

42,776-02         DONALD FOSTER ORANGE COUNTY

43,872-02         DAVID B. HERNANDEZ BEXAR COUNTY

44,187-01         JOE LOUIS ORTIZ DALLAS COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

43,694-01         JOHN BALTAZAR NUECES COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

2,477-10         TUCKER FINIS BLANDENSHIP COUNTY

43,504-02         MALCOLM ROY EVANS HARRIS COUNTY

5,483-15         MERIA JAMES BRADLEY HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

44,102-01         JOSE R. RODRIGUEZ V. GUADALUPE RIVERA, JUDGE FROM EL PASO COUNTY