THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS

APRIL 21, 1999

THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:

72,638 JOHNATHAN MOORE FROM BEXAR COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGE MANSFIELD CONCURS IN POINT OF ERROR TWELVE AND OTHERWISE JOINS)

(JUDGES MEYERS AND JOHNSON CONCUR IN THE RESULT)

PUBLISHED OPINION

72,772 ERIC DEWAYNE CATHEY FROM HARRIS COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(JUDGE JOHNSON CONCURS IN THE RESULT)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

72,808 JOHN L. WHEAT FROM TARRANT COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE HOLLAND JOIN)

(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT:

NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS

73,372 EX PARTE JASON ANDREW RAINES FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,373 EX PARTE RICARDO VASQUEZ FROM NUECES COUNTY

73,374 EX PARTE JOHN EDWARD GOSSETT FROM WILLIAMSON COUNTY

73,375 EX PARTE MICHAEL EARL VINCENT FROM HUNT COUNTY

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

0881-98 TOMMY BUTTERFIELD FROM TRAVIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT--OPINION JUDGE KEALSER

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGES PRICE, HOLLAND AND WOMACK JOIN)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

PUBLISHED OPINION

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

0157-98 NELMS, GARY LEE FROM TOM GREEN COUNTY

(JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)

0004-99 GONZALEZ, NELSON MAURICIO FROM DALLAS COUNTY

0005-99 GONZALEZ, NELSON MAURICIO FROM DALLAS COUNTY

0194-99 GAMEZ, JUAN FROM DUVAL COUNTY

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

0367-98 VICK, JAMES LEE FROM LAMB COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0014-99 WARD, JESSE O'NEAL VAN ZANDT COUNTY 12-97-00294-CR

0016-99 RICHARDSON, RONALD EUGENE ECTOR COUNTY 08-97-00247-CR

0030-99 STEINBACH, HELEN BELL COUNTY 03-97-00773-CR

0088-99 RODRIGUEZ, RALPH BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00150-CR

0094-99 JURDI, JAY TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00135-CR

0095-99 JURDI, JAY TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00136-CR

0196-99 HUGHES, SIMON HUW HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00647-CR

0198-99 MOORE, EARL GARLAND HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00631-CR

0199-99 MOORE, EARL GARLAND HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00632-CR

0248-99 RUIZ, FREDDY BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00286-CR

0249-99 GONZALEZ, SANTIAGO BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00853-CR

0266-99 BUSHNELL, EDMONIA LIBERTY COUNTY 09-98-00097-CR

0429-99 BROOKS, MICHAEL TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00295-CR

0430-99 BROOKS, MICHAEL TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00296-CR

0435-99 MARTHILJOHNI, WELDON A. BEXAR COUNTY 04-98-00709-CR

0437-99 SILVA, ARMANDO CHAVERA FRIO COUNTY 04-97-00970-CR

0440-99 MELENDEZ, JAVIER ALBERTO HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01015-CR

0443-99 WILLIAMS, TEDRICK ROMOND HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01160-CR

0452-99 SIMPSON, EDRION DUSHON BRAZOS COUNTY 14-96-01575-CR

0458-99 SORTO, LUIS ORELLANO DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00701-CR

0465-99 OWENS, WESLEY THOMAS, JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-98-00109-CR

0472-99 BONNER, KEITH BASHAN DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00082-CR

0481-99 ANDREWS, STEPHEN FRANK TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00210-CR

0482-99 ANDREWS, STEPHEN FRANK TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00272-CR

0483-99 GARZA, JESUS ELIZONDO WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-97-00808-CR

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

0484-99 GARZA, RENE WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-97-00770-CR

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

0486-99 GARCIA, DANIEL CAMARILLO TOM GREEN COUNTY 03-97-00641-CR

0487-99 SHERLUND, STEVE MARK BURNET COUNTY 03-97-00226-CR

0491-99 COKER, JAMES LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00423-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1903-98 GAY, MICHAEL OWEN HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-01116-CR

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

1904-98 GAY, MICHAEL OWEN HARRIS COUNTY 01-95-01117-CR

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0000-99 COLLINS, JAMES CLYDE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00863-CR

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

0000-99 BUTLER, LARRY LEE TARRANT COUNTY 02-97-00605-CR

0000-99 DALE, CARLOS DEMOUR DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01738-CR

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0051-99 EUBANK, AARON BRET TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00459-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

(GROUND NOS. 2 & 3 REFUSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE)

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

1,435-04 GROVER RAYMOND BEAMON HARDIN COUNTY

12,825-06 LEON CALVIN PORTER DALLAS COUNTY

13,549-04 RUSSELL EUGENE GALER GRAY COUNTY

25,621-02 SEDRIC LEWIS GARDNER TARRANT COUNTY

25,930-02 DONNY JOE PAYNE TARRANT COUNTY

28,282-04 KIM WAYNE BURDEN CAMP COUNTY

23,673-04 RICHARD BELL DALLAS COUNTY

33,666-02 REGINALD HILL DALLAS COUNTY

34,749-03 RICKY L. MEADOWS ANDERSON COUNTY

37,378-09 JOHN JOSEPH DUFFY DALLAS COUNTY

38,836-02 BILLY F. VENTERS GREGG COUNTY

38,908-02 KEN EDWARD JONES DALLAS COUNTY

39,844-05 JOHN WESLEY JENKINS BRAZOS COUNTY

40,076-04 MICHAEL ALLEN DURHAM HARRIS COUNTY

40,674-01 HERB GAUFF LEWIS COLLIN COUNTY

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

40,757-01 KENNETH MATTHEWS TRAVIS COUNTY

40,763-01 WAYNE EARL JONES MILAM COUNTY

40,778-01 JOHN ROBERT MCCOMB IV. LIBERTY COUNTY

40,949-01 RODNEY LLOYD GRANVILLE BRAZORIA COUNTY

40,949-02 RODNEY LLOYD GRANVILLE BRAZORIA COUNTY

41,027-01 ANTHONY JEROME BYNUM DALLAS COUNTY

41,039-01 KEN MICHAEL COPELAND DALLAS COUNTY

41,040-01 SEANTRE BRIAN FAULKNER TARRANT COUNTY

41,048-01 TONY CURTIS BROOKS DALLAS COUNTY

41,062-01 CARLTON FERNANDO TOBLER BELL COUNTY

41,063-01 RICO D'SHAWN SHUMPERT BELL COUNTY

41,117-01 BODERICK DEVOE TAYLOR DALLAS COUNTY

41,145-01 DIESTE ANTONIO MCCULLOUGH DALLAS COUNTY

41,167-01 TOMMY DARRELL ALCORN HARRIS COUNTY

41,187-01 ROBERT MICHAEL KRUGH TITUS COUNTY

41,195-01 RICKY JOSEPH CEASER FANNIN COUNTY

41,198-01 JESUS LINERES MARTINEZ DALLAS COUNTY

41,291-01 JAMES DARRELL ELLIOTT TARRANT COUNTY

41,308-01 JERRY WAYNE POINTE JEFFERSON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

13,621-05 JAMES DAVID DANIEL TARRANT COUNTY

14,340-03 HAROLD LEE CARROLL CAMERON COUNTY

34,754-03 JEROME ALEXANDER BROOKS HARRIS COUNTY

38,847-02 OTIS LEE DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY

38,885-02 WILLIE LEE JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY

40,022-01 PEDRO FLORES TORRES HARRIS COUNTY

40,308-02 TONY LEE GORE HARDIN COUNTY

40,666-01 CHARLES COX TARRANT COUNTY

40,670-01 TRIALUS DEWAYNE HARRIS DALLAS COUNTY

40,968-01 MARK ANTHONY SALAZAR HARRIS COUNTY

41,036-01 MARLON WAFFORD DALLAS COUNTY

41,037-01 STEVEN GRANT WILEY DALLAS COUNTY

41,046-01 LARRY NEIL WEESNER SMITH COUNTY

41,063-02 RICO D'SHAWN SHUMPERT BELL COUNTY

41,073-01 RODNEY WAYNE CARTER HARRIS COUNTY

41,075-01 LOWELL LANCE GOODWIN HARRIS COUNTY

41,076-01 JOSE HERNANDEZ JIMENEZ DALLAS COUNTY

41,091-01 DWIGHT DOUGLAS PURDOM TAYLOR COUNTY

41,091-02 DWIGHT DOUGLAS PURDOM TAYLOR COUNTY

41,092-01 THOEDIS ANDREWS HARRIS COUNTY

41,093-01 CARLOS DEMETRIS MCNICKLES HARRIS COUNTY

41,093-02 CARLOS DEMETRIS MCNICKLES HARRIS COUNTY

41,095-01 BRIAN K. WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

41,203-01 ALAN LEROY HUNTER HARRIS COUNTY

41,217-01 HARLAN LEE WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

41,279-01 MATTHEW HOLMES HARRIS COUNTY

41,287-01 CARLOS GONZALES BEXAR COUNTY

41,309-01 ALLEN RAY GLEGHORN SCURRY COUNTY

5,531-15 JAMES CARTER HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

29,508-05 KURT WAYNE LOPER DALLAS COUNTY

40,258-01 TIMOTHY LEE MULLINS SMITH COUNTY

40,646-01 BOB AHMADI COOKE COUNTY

40,795-02 WOODROW WHITE DALLAS COUNTY

41,044-01 ALBERT RAMIREZ DALLAS COUNTY

41,086-01 FELIPE DELEON JR. DALLAS COUNTY

41,089-01 FELIX GUILLEN DALLAS COUNTY

41,151-01 MODESTO VILLEGAS-PLANCARTE DALLAS COUNTY

41,156-01 BRAD ZELL BISHOP BRAZOS COUNTY

41,157-01 HUGH GRANT AYNESWORTH DALLAS COUNTY

41,216-01 TANGUMA RAMIRO DALLAS COUNTY

41,225-01 MICHAEL EUGENE CALAHAN HILL COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

40,989-01 GREAN EARL COX DALLAS COUNTY

41,009-01 CURTIS LEE SMITH BELL COUNTY

41,105-01 MARCOS RIVERA HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

11,842-06 DAN BRUCE REEVES TARRANT COUNTY

24,872-04 GLENN RAY MACKS SMITH COUNTY

25,138-08 CECIL RAY PATTERSON DALLAS COUNTY

25,631-11 DONALD RAY FRENCH HARRIS COUNTY

28,122-03 ERNEST RAMOS JR. TARRANT COUNTY

33,274-04 SCOTTIE LOUIS GREER DALLAS COUNTY

36,347-02 REAGAN DUANE WATSON POTTER COUNTY

37,397-04 FREDDIE BURTS TRAVIS COUNTY

39,684-02 BERNARD HART UPSHUR COUNTY

9,699-05 O. B. SIMS JR. TRAVIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

20,397-04 JEFFREY MILES HASTINGS GUADALUPE COUNTY

40,771-01 JUAN JOSE MACIAS WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

40,895-01 AISHA MERCEDES SCOTT DALLAS COUNTY

40,901-01 KEVIN KEITH EARLS DALLAS COUNTY

40,903-01 KENNETH BLACK DALLAS COUNTY

41,031-01 ARNOLD PEARSON DALLAS COUNTY

41,033-01 BUDDY GLENN SMITH WOOD COUNTY

41,159-01 TONEY HAMMOND DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

37,949-01 MICHAEL EARL VINCENT HUNT COUNTY

40,769-01 RICARDO VASQUEZ NUECES COUNTY

40,847-01 JASON ANDREW RAINES HARRIS COUNTY

41,015-01 JOHN EDWARD GOSSETT WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

10,051-03 JOSEPH DONALD SMITH COUNTY

26,637-03 MICHAEL A. SMITH HARRIS COUNTY

30,885-09 DONALD RAY MOODY JEFFERSON COUNTY

41,149-01 ROBERTO SERBIN COUNTY

41,186-01 KENNETH GREVE CAMERON COUNTY

41,210-01 JUAN MARCIAL AGUILAR BEXAR COUNTY

41,237-01 DEVLIN JEFFERSON WILLIAMSON COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

40,874-01 ROBERT SMITH HARRIS COUNTY

41,168-01 CHARLES DEAN HOOD COLLIN COUNTY

(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

32,742-03 GILBERT HERNANDEZ HOUSTON COUNTY

40,082-01 CHRISTOPHER NUNEZ BELL COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

41,209-01 GREGARIO GARCIA NUECES COUNTY

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

38,355-02 DAVID LEE LEWIS ANGELINA COUNTY

Return to
Court of Criminal Appeals