THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
JUNE 23, 1999
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
71,887 RICKY LYNN LEWIS FROM SMITH COUNTY
AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD
(JUDGES MEYERS AND KELLER CONCUR IN THE RESULT)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
72,500 ANZEL KEON JONES FROM LAMAR COUNTY
AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
73,252 EX PARTE JOE DAVID CHILDRESS FROM HARRIS COUNTY
DISMISSED--PER CURIAM OPINION
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED
OPINIONS)
73,434 EX PARTE RANDY LEE DITTO FROM HENDERSON COUNTY
73,435 EX PARTE RICARDO MARTINEZ FROM EL PASO COUNTY
73,436 EX PARTE CARLA WILLIAMS FROM HARRIS COUNTY
73,437 EX PARTE JAMES M. NEW FROM DALLAS COUNTY
73,438 EX PARTE WILLIAM RAY WHITTMAN FROM POTTER COUNTY
73,439 EX PARTE EDWIN CUVILLIER FROM CAMERON COUNTY
73,440 EX PARTE PEDRO GUTIERREZ MUNOZ FROM PECOS COUNTY
73,441 EX PARTE PEDRO GUTIERREZ MUNOZ FROM PECOS COUNTY
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
0996-98 JERRY T. SMITH FROM GARZA COUNTY
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE HOLLAND
(JUDGE MANSFIELD DISSENTS)
CONCURRING & DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER
(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE KEASLER JOIN)
PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
1656-98 WASHBURN, FREDERICK H. DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00504-CR
0317-99 DOWDLE, PETER ELMER (PDR #1) BEXAR COUNTY 07-97-00264-CR
0397-99 VARGAS, DAVID ROMERO HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01352-CR
0438-99 KENNERSON, ERVIN JOSEPH GALVESTON COUNTY 01-96-00618-CR
0439-99 KENNERSON, ERVIN JOSEPH GALVESTON COUNTY 01-96-00917-CR
0445-99 CIFUENTES, WALLINGTON H. HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00643-CR
(JUDGE JOHNSON WOULD GRANT)
0577-99 WILLIAMS, CAD WAYLON HENDERSON COUNTY 12-97-00209-CR
0580-99 BONNER, JASON LAMONT MCLENNAN COUNTY 10-98-00046-CR
0582-99 HOLMAN, MARC DENNIS
AKA DENNIS, MARK DENNIS DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00635-CR
0583-99 HOLMAN, MARC DENNIS
AKA DENNIS, MARK DENNIS DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00636-CR
0584-99 HOLMAN, MARC DENNIS
AKA DENNIS, MARK DENNIS DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-00637-CR
0588-99 SILVA, REYES RODRIGUEZ COLLIN COUNTY 05-97-00157-CR
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
0589-99 SILVA, EDUARDO RODRIGUEZ COLLIN COUNTY 05-97-00158-CR
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
0590-99 RODRIGUEZ, GREGORIO, JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00359-CR
0592-99 RIGGS, JASON HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01360-CR
0595-99 RIVAS, DAVID PEREZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00091-CR
0596-99 RIVAS, DAVID PEREZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-97-00092-CR
0597-99 PRATT, WAYNE FLETCHER HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01450-CR
0599-99 HENDERSON, KENNO DESHON HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01459-CR
0600-99 MOORE, CALVIN RAY HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01359-CR
0606-99 BLACKMON, FREDDY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01246-CR
0607-99 BLACKMON, FREDDY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01247-CR
0608-99 TROTTIER, TRAVIS MCLEOD HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00081-CR
0609-99 JONES, CLIFTON WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00681-CR
0611-99 ECONOMY, CHRISTOPHER T. HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00404-CR
0612-99 AGUILAR, OSCAR ANTONIO HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00482-CR
0615-99 BIRDOW, RONALD TRENT TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00086-CR
0616-99 NOWLIN, OLIN RAY TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00190-CR
0625-99 FALBY, ALLEN JOHN DENTON COUNTY 02-97-00744-CR
0629-99 SANCHEZ, SIMON CULBERSON COUNTY 08-97-00230-CR
0630-99 ZANDBIGLARI, BARHAM TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00015-CR
0637-99 SCHOONOVER, CYNTHIA LEE TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00043-CR
0644-99 NGO, SU NGOC HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01306-CR
0679-99 CAMERON, PAUL HOUSTON BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00350-CR
0731-99 MORRIS, CRAIG STEPHEN NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-96-00063-CR
0733-99 ORTEGON, CESAR TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00165-CR
0738-99 CRAYTON, JAMES EARL BELL COUNTY 03-97-00643-CR
0739-99 WRIGHT, CURTIS DUANE DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00570-CR
0740-99 WRIGHT, CURTIS DUANE DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00571-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0190-99 LIGHTEARD, DAVID L. (SPA'S) BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00026-CR
(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK, JUDGE MANSFIELD
AND JUDGE KEASLER WOULD GRANT)
DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK
(JUDGES MANSFIELD AND KEASLER JOIN)
PUBLISHED OPINION
0301-99 LOY, STEPHEN GOODWIN HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01062-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
0362-98 RAY, SYBILLE WHALEY (SPA'S) PANOLA COUNTY 12-96-00257-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0316-99 RUCKER, DARYL K. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-97-00174-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0317-99 DOWDLE, PETER ELMER (PDR #2) BEXAR COUNTY 07-97-00264-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0389-99 JOHNSON, TOBY W. (SPA'S #1) TARRANT COUNTY 10-97-00390-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0389-99 JOHNSON, TOBY W. (DA'S #2) TARRANT COUNTY 10-97-00390-CR
(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0469-99 GILMORE, ERIC JEROME TAYLOR COUNTY 11-96-00383-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
0000-99 ERNEST HUTCHINS TRAVIS COUNTY 03-98-00162-CR
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
739-03 BILLY RAY PEARCE GALVESTON COUNTY
21,721-02 WAYNE ALAN WATSON MCLENNAN COUNTY
29,034-03 THOMAS GLENN JONES DALLAS COUNTY
38,738-02 THEODORE ROSKOWSKE JR. COLLIN COUNTY
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
39,859-01 ROBERT GARZA JR. TARRANT COUNTY
40,891-01 BRUCE SCOTT GARRETT TARRANT COUNTY
40,998-02 MITCHELL Q. GONNER LIMESTONE COUNTY
41,326-02 GARY WAYNE CRAWFORD BASTROP COUNTY
41,345-02 EARL WAYNE DUNCAN JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY
41,480-01 FRANK ARTHUR MARTINEZ PALO PINTO COUNTY
41,585-01 ISABEL R. CAVAZOS JR. FRIO COUNTY
41,608-01 FRANK BRADSHAW ARANSAS COUNTY
41,650-01 LOYD RAY HUMPHREY LEON COUNTY
41,675-01 LEROY J. KESSLER GUADALUPE COUNTY
41,688-01 GREGORY DEAN CULLUM TAYLOR COUNTY
41,722-01 JOSE GARCIA EL PASO COUNTY
41,754-01 JAMES ALLEN JOHNSON HARRIS COUNTY
41,763-01 DANNY RIVERA HARRIS COUNTY
41,763-02 DANNY RIVERA HARRIS COUNTY
41,806-01 JOSEPH LEE TURNER TARRANT COUNTY
41,828-01 MICHELLE NICHOLS TERRY TARRANT COUNTY
41,864-01 DAVID DUANE GREER GRIMES COUNTY
41,928-01 TIMOTHY ALLEN CETNAR COLLIN COUNTY
(JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)
41,930-01 LOUIS PRESTON PALMER HARRIS COUNTY
41,947-01 ROY JOE FARMER NACOGDOCHES COUNTY
41,964-01 AL KEMP III HUTCHINSON COUNTY
8,309-06 ROY LEE SMITH HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
13,053-02 JOHN ROLAND RANDLES HARRIS COUNTY
16,999-09 JON RAMONE KARLINY HARRIS COUNTY
16,999-10 JON RAMONE KARLINY HARRIS COUNTY
18,207-02 JAMES HENRY CARTER II LUBBOCK COUNTY
19,761-02 KENNETH RALPH RUCKER JR. TARRANT COUNTY
22,143-03 DIANA GAIL SCALES HARRIS COUNTY
33,036-02 GENTRY STEPHEN LEONARD DALLAS COUNTY
33,356-02 JERRY DON CHOICE SMITH COUNTY
34,790-02 ALBERT JENKINS HARRIS COUNTY
36,860-04 TERRY RENARD FISHER TRAVIS COUNTY
38,274-02 DARYL CONTRA SOWELL HARRIS COUNTY
38,449-02 MICHAEL RAY GENTSCH HARRIS COUNTY
39,364-01 TIMOTHY NEAL HINTON HARRIS COUNTY
39,896-01 RANDAL H. SCHLEMMER MONTGOMERY COUNTY
39,991-01 HEATH OWEN LONG LAVACA COUNTY
40,203-01 CIPRIANO VELA HALE COUNTY
40,322-03 ALEXANDER JOSEPH SEEGER HARRIS COUNTY
40,322-04 ALEXANDER JOSEPH SEEGER HARRIS COUNTY
40,556-02 TONY ALLEN DELEON DALLAS COUNTY
40,891-02 BRUCE SCOTT GARRETT TARRANT COUNTY
41,100-02 MARTY BARRAGAN BEXAR COUNTY
41,259-01 KELVIN TREMAYNE HINTON HARRIS COUNTY
41,416-01 REYNALDO CAICEDO TORRES HARRIS COUNTY
41,647-01 ARTURO M. CARDENAS BEXAR COUNTY
41,508-01 BENJAMIN EARL DAVIS HARRIS COUNTY
41,578-01 DUANE RONDELL HUTTON LAMAR COUNTY
41,597-01 TOMA DUPREE FULLER DALLAS COUNTY
41,633-01 WAYNE EARL JOHNSON DALLAS COUNTY
41,658-01 RONALD QUINN WAGNER DALLAS COUNTY
41,668-01 RODNEY LEWIS TURNER HARRIS COUNTY
41,699-01 BOWEN DANIEL GARDNER HARRIS COUNTY
41,723-01 VINCENT AMOS TARRANT COUNTY
41,751-01 CLYDE LEE RUSSELL TARRANT COUNTY
41,765-01 RANDAL E. HENSLEE LUBBOCK COUNTY
41,793-01 LEOPOLDO GALANG LISING DALLAS COUNTY
41,807-01 RICKEY J. BARNARD DALLAS COUNTY
41,818-01 VERNON LEE BAXTER DALLAS COUNTY
41,820-14 ALBERT BLANCO CASTILLO BEXAR COUNTY
41,820-15 ALBERT BLANCO CASTILLO BEXAR COUNTY
41,820-16 ALBERT BLANCO CASTILLO BEXAR COUNTY
41,820-17 ALBERT BLANCO CASTILLO BEXAR COUNTY
41,821-01 PHILLIP DONAHUE MCLENNAN COUNTY
41,834-01 KENNETH WAYNE EARL MCLENNAN COUNTY
41,844-01 SAMUEL WARREN STEWART MCLENNAN COUNTY
41,856-01 MICHAEL DENNIS WEBB MCLENNAN COUNTY
41,859-01 DANNY JAMES ENSIGN HARRIS COUNTY
41,859-02 DANNY JAMES ENSIGN HARRIS COUNTY
41,878-01 SAMMIE JOE WILLIAMS JR. GREGG COUNTY
41,885-01 DELVIN RAY CUNNINGHAM HARRIS COUNTY
41,894-01 KELVIN JONES DALLAS COUNTY
41,896-01 MICHAEL GLEN PENNINGTON HARRIS COUNTY
41,912-01 JUSTIN JAY LEE PALO PINTO COUNTY
41,914-01 FRED RODRIGUEZ JR. BEXAR COUNTY
41,917-01 JAMES CALVIN GOODEN HARRIS COUNTY
41,918-01 LEASAL RANDALL GREEN TARRANT COUNTY
41,933-01 SHELDON JACKSON BRAZORIA COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)
41,813-01 JOHN IKE COX SMITH COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
37,918-01 RENOIR EVERHART SMITH COUNTY
39,416-01 LARRY FLOYD PIERCE HUNT COUNTY
39,830-01 TIMOTHY THOMPSON POTTER COUNTY
39,998-01 SCOTTY ALAN JONES TARRANT COUNTY
40,894-01 RASHAAN G. PERRY MILAM COUNTY
41,205-01 LEONARD LOPEZ GUADALUPE COUNTY
41,401-01 MICHAEL JOEL MORALES HARRIS COUNTY
41,622-02 ANTHONY P. LOPEZ BEXAR COUNTY
41,767-01 JOHN MICHAEL RIVERA TRAVIS COUNTY
41,772-01 CURTIS RAY RAWLS TYLER COUNTY
41,893-01 ASHLEY D. WATERS SMITH COUNTY
41,921-01 JOSEPH VERNON METOYER JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY
41,962-01 TUAN D. BUI TARRANT COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
41,783-01 JOSE VALLEJO DALLAS COUNTY
41,797-01 KEVIN WAYNE BURROUGHS NAVARRO COUNTY
41,890-01 CHRISTOPHER KEITH THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC. 4)
10,924-07 RAY STEWART MARION MIDLAND COUNTY
17,455-03 BOBBY LEE STUCKEY POLK COUNTY
26,659-02 THOMAS JEFFERSON WILLIS HARRIS COUNTY
29,785-03 LARRY WAYNE SAMPLES DALLAS COUNTY
30,641-02 LARRY FISHER SMITH COUNTY
34,467-08 CHRISTOPHER KEITH HANDY HARRIS COUNTY
36,088-03 JORGE ENRIQUE COLON HARRIS COUNTY
36,088-04 JORGE ENRIQUE COLON HARRIS COUNTY
38,318-02 CHARLES ALAN HARGROVE DENTON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
41,512-01 STEVEN BERNARD NASH HARRIS COUNTY
41,693-01 WILLIE PAUL EDMOND TAYLOR COUNTY
41,718-01 QUANE THONGSAVATH POTTER COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
19,614-02 EDWIN CUVILLIER CAMERON COUNTY
38,181-01 PEDRO GUTIERREZ MUNOZ PECOS COUNTY
38,181-02 PEDRO GUTIERREZ MUNOZ PECOS COUNTY
38,298-01 CARLA WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
38,955-01 JAMES M. NEW DALLAS COUNTY
41,000-01 RANDY LEE DITTO HENDERSON COUNTY
41,690-01 WILLIAM RAY WHITTMAN POTTER COUNTY
41,790-01 RICARDO MARTINEZ EL PASO COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
28,942-05 DAVID LORENZA JOYNER HARRIS COUNTY
33,864-03 OLIVER LEWIS TARRANT COUNTY
40,101-02 WAYNE CURTIS HUGHES ROCKWALL COUNTY
40,190-02 MICHAEL CAMPBELL DALLAS COUNTY
40,365-01 SEAN MAURICE HAMILTON DALLAS COUNTY
40,995-01 GEORGE ELLIS BEXAR COUNTY
41,448-01 JUAN SOLIS MONTELONGO HIDALGO COUNTY
41,865-01 CURTIS W. QUINTON ANDERSON COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE:
20,856-03 JIMMY LEE DAVIS TRAVIS COUNTY
41,815-01 HERIBERTO SALINAS HARRIS COUNTY
41,922-01 JESUS VALDEZ PINA COLLINGSWORTH COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
40,890-01 EDWARD LEWIS LAGRONE TARRANT COUNTY
40,873-01 RICHARD WILLIAM KUTZNER MONTGOMERY COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN
ORDER (ABUSE OF THE WRIT):
36,331-02 EMANUEL KEMPT, JR. TARRANT COUNTY
40,574-02 JOHN L. WHEAT TARRANT COUNTY
Return to
Court of Criminal Appeals