THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS


OCTOBER 21, 1998







THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





72,254 REX WARREN MAYS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

AFFIRMED--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

73,099 EX PARTE WILLIAM WESLEY BATES FROM PARKER COUNTY

RELIEF GRANTED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE HOLLAND JOIN)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

PUBLISHED OPINIONS

73,100 EX PARTE WILLIAM WESLEY BATES FROM PARKER COUNTY

RELIEF GRANTED--OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE HOLLAND JOIN)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

PUBLISHED OPINIONS

HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT:

(NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)

73,200 EX PARTE RICHARD HERNANDEZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY

73,201 EX PARTE SYLVESTER ROBINSON FROM CORYELL COUNTY



ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1139 -97 KEVIN W. HASTY FROM TARRANT COUNTY

DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED--PER CURIAM OPINION

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE MANSFIELD JOIN)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

1335-97 PRIETO BAIL BONDS FROM EL PASO COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION

1182-98 EX PARTE SIDNEY EARL BRASHEAR FROM AUSTIN COUNTY

APPELLANT'S SECOND PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW IS REFUSED;

PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED ON COURT'S OWN MOTION;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS OF MAY 21, 1998 IS VACATED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS OF FEBRUARY 12, 1998 IS REINSTATED;

PER CURIAM OPINION

PUBLISHED OPINION

ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1481-97 BENNIE EARL ROBERTS FROM HENDERSON COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE MANSFIELD JOINS)

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE BAIRD

(JUDGE OVERSTREET JOINS)

PUBLISHED OPINION

ON APPELLEE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:

1401-97 QUENTIN LAVAN JORDAN FROM TARRANT COUNTY

APPELLEE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION







ON STATE'S MOTION FOR REHEARING:

0482-98 GEORGE LESLIE ADAMS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

STATE'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE OUT-OF-TIME REHEARING GRANTED;

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

(JUDGE BAIRD DISSENTS)

(JUDGES OVERSTREET AND WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

0483-98 JOHN P. CHAMBERS FROM HARRIS COUNTY

STATE'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE OUT-OF-TIME REHEARING GRANTED;

STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS VACATED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--PER CURIAM OPINION

(JUDGE BAIRD DISSENTS)

(JUDGES OVERSTREET AND WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

NON-PUBLISHED OPINION

APPELLANT'S MOTION FOR REHEARING ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DENIED:

0078-97 EX PARTE GARY WAYNE POPLIN FROM DALLAS COUNTY

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

1277-97 JESSE BRITTON SIMPSON FROM DALLAS COUNTY

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

0757-96 BARKER, DUDLEY SNYDER, JR. ERATH COUNTY 11-96-00005-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

1471-96 STEAD, EX PARTE HILARY FORT BEND COUNTY 14-96-00762-CR

1472-96 MORROW, JAMES RICHARD FORT BEND COUNTY 14-96-00736-CR

0161-97 AHLBERG, TREVOR LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01129-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0287-97 DARLINGTON, STACEY LYNN HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00997-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0343-97 KELLEY, SAMUEL CLAY FORT BEND COUNTY 01-96-00522-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0582-97 BLY, JAY ARTHUR FORT BEND COUNTY 14-96-01262-CR

0806-97 SOWELL, CHARLES WILLIAM DALLAS COUNTY 05-95-01220-CR

0906-97 KOLAR, DANIEL GARY FORT BEND COUNTY 01-97-00062-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

1111-97 WILKINSON, STEVEN A. BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-01011-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0007-98 TODD, JULIA RAMSEY ELLIS COUNTY 10-97-00182-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0165-98 KOHUT, PAUL WALTER DALLAS COUNTY 05-97-00291-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0708-98 ROSS, CHARLES KENNETH SMITH COUNTY 12-96-00355-CR

(JUDGES BAIRD AND OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

0952-98 JAMES, KURRY NORMAN POTTER COUNTY 07-97-00319-CR

(JUDGE BAIRD WOULD GRANT)

0985-98 TAYLOR, GLENN GARNETT HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00070-CR

0986-98 TAYLOR, GLENN GARNETT HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00071-CR

1065-98 PANTOJA, PHILLIP HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00832-CR

1096-98 FRANKLIN, ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00751-CR

1097-98 FRANKLIN, ANTHONY HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00752-CR

1105-98 YOUNG, KENNETH W. WALKER COUNTY 01-96-00464-CR

(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

1164-98 KITCHENS, WILLIAM NEWTON DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00452-CR

1192-98 WILLIAMS, TRACY PAUL SMITH COUNTY 11-06-00287-CR

1205-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01616-CR

1206-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01617-CR

1207-98 TORTI, GREGORY LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01618-CR

1228-98 DIXON, ROGER DALE NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-97-00093-CR

1231-98 COVARRUBIAS, JESSE BEXAR COUNTY 04-96-00921-CR

1232-98 CASTILLO, GERALD BEXAR COUNTY 04-97-00367-CR

1233-98 BRUNDRETT, MORGAN R. ARANSAS COUNTY 13-97-00328-CR

1236-98 TRACEY, NORMAN ALEXANDER DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00090-CR

1241-98 BOOHER, TEDDY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01126-CR

1242-98 RODRIGUEZ, JOHNNY HARRIS COUNTY 14-95-00691-CR

1257-98 CASTRO, JESSE CAMERON COUNTY 13-97-00136-CR

1314-98 WOMACK, PAUL GREGORY HARRIS COUNTY 13-97-00405-CR

1318-98 DOTY, STEVEN RAY TAYLOR COUNTY 11-96-00384-CR

1350-98 BRAGG, DENNIE MAC DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01433-CR

1351-98 STONE, JEFFERY STEVEN DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01810-CR

1352-98 STONE, JEFFERY STEVEN DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01811-CR

1354-98 BETHEA, OSCAR GEORGE DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01733-CR

1355-98 HUANG, MYONG SUK DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-00226-CR

1356-98 BASCOM, ERIC MICHAEL COLLIN COUNTY 05-97-00667-CR

1364-98 HECKARD, TROY HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00047-CR

1365-98 FISHER, JOE D. TARRANT COUNTY 10-97-00340-CR

1367-98 COPELAND, CHRISTOPHER BRAZOS COUNTY 10-97-00193-CR

1373-98 LAND, EMMETT ALVIN MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-97-00061-CR

1374-98 MARTINEZ, JESSIE HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-00938-CR

1391-98 HARRISON, WILLIE C. HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01264-CR

1393-98 DAVIS, FREDRICK VONDRAY HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-00406-CR

1394-98 PROFITTE, LAMONT JERROLD HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00859-CR

1396-98 YZAGUIRRE, CHAD RICHARD HARRIS COUNTY 01-97-01257-CR

1398-98 JONES, JOHNNY HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01437-CR

1399-98 BATISTE, CURTIS JAMES HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-01480-CR

APPELLEE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:

1334-98 DELEON, BENJAMIN LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-97-00385-CR

(JUDGE OVERSTREET WOULD GRANT)

APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:

0897-98 REYNOLDS, CALVIN JOSEPH HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00779-CR

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

1300-98 CHAVEZ, MARIA MARTHA ERATH COUNTY 11-97-00043-CR

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:

0000-98 DONALD R. FOREMAN DALLAS COUNTY 05-96-01600-CR

0000-98 MIGUEL ANGEL MARTINEZ EL PASO COUNTY 08-97-00221-CR

0000-98 ROCKY ALLEN MORRIS DALLAS COUNTY 05-95-01401-CR

0000-98 EDDIBERTO VAZQUEZ BEXAR COUNTY 13-97-00513-CR

0000-98 JOSUE DAVID BERNAL HARRIS COUNTY 14-96-01442-CR

0000-98 LARRY MCGLAUN HENDERSON COUNTY 12-97-00107-CR

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

21,138-02 ORAN WILLIAM O'BRIANT JOHNSON COUNTY

27,783-03 MICHAEL ARTHUR MAGOON BRAZORIA COUNTY

28,076-02 MICHAEL MERCADO TARRANT COUNTY

30,586-02 MICHAEL HOWARD BERTOK TARRANT COUNTY

35,722-02 DETRICK HOLLIS HARRIS COUNTY

35,910-02 WALTER B. MCDONALD HARRIS COUNTY

36,089-02 ALEX PENA KERR COUNTY

36,089-03 ALEX PENA KERR COUNTY

37,877-02 BILLY RAY STEELE JR. BELL COUNTY

38,603-01 LORENZA L. HODGES DALLAS COUNTY

38,603-02 LORENZA L. HODGES DALLAS COUNTY

38,648-01 JUAN EDUARDO MORALES EL PASO COUNTY

38,713-01 DWIGHT GERALD WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

38,859-01 ANTONIO ALLEN LAWTON KERR COUNTY

38,864-02 KENNETH L. SLATEN TITUS COUNTY

38,890-01 ROBERTO MONTALVO GALLO COLLIN COUNTY

38,949-01 LORENZO LOPEZ MARTINEZ TAYLOR COUNTY

39,100-01 MARCUS W. BROOKS MIDLAND COUNTY

39,106-01 HOWARD LEE HARRISON ARANSAS COUNTY

39,115-01 RUSSELL D. SMITH SMITH DENTON COUNTY

39,118-01 EDDY D. JENNINGS JOHNSON COUNTY

39,119-01 MAX MELVIN WALCK TAYLOR COUNTY

39,134-01 EARL ELGIN HOWE ANDERSON COUNTY

39,135-01 JAMES KENNETH BATTLE DENTON COUNTY

39,136-01 SAMUEL D. KILLEBREW ROBERTSON COUNTY

39,147-01 DON DANIELS MILAM COUNTY

39,150-01 CEDRIC M. MCHENRY TARRANT COUNTY

39,160-01 ROBERT EARL OAKES TAYLOR COUNTY

39,162-01 RANDY RAMIREZ ATASCOSA COUNTY

39,172-01 CALVIN GURLEY TRAVIS COUNTY

39,173-01 MAX JESSIE REYES DALLAS COUNTY

39,174-01 RONALD HOWARD SIMPSON DALLAS COUNTY

39,193-01 ROSAVELT DUFFIE BROWN COUNTY

39,220-01 TODD MUNSINGER CASS COUNTY

39,222-01 FAREED DEEN AL-JABAAR BELL COUNTY

39,228-01 JOSE ANTONIO VELASQUEZ SAN PATRICIO COUNTY

39,229-01 DARREL HULSHOUSER DENTON COUNTY

39,239-01 NATHANIEL ALLEN TARRANT COUNTY

39,247-01 JOSE OCTAVIANO MARTINEZ SR. HOCKLEY COUNTY

7,924-04 RALPH COLEMAN JR. TARRANT COUNTY

9,876-07 TOMMY VIRGIL THOMAS TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

17,068-04 RICHEY R. WOODS WILLIAMSON COUNTY

18,346-03 ROBERT FRANCIS KITTREDGE TARRANT COUNTY

20,611-03 ROBERT JEFFERSON CARTER TARRANT COUNTY

23,898-02 JOE RAYMOND HERNANDEZ HOCKLEY COUNTY

32,597-04 GEORGE ANDREW JOHNSON BEXAR COUNTY

36,208-03 GLEN BARNES HARRIS COUNTY

36,208-04 GLEN BARNES HARRIS COUNTY

36,503-01 JOHNNY TYRON HUNT DALLAS COUNTY

36,785-02 FREDDIE W. TAYLOR HARRIS COUNTY

37,488-02 HAROLD EDWARDS DALLAS COUNTY

37,669-01 ABRAHAM HANDY ORANGE COUNTY

38,363-01 ISAAC FRANK PERALES BRAZORIA COUNTY

38,363-02 ISAAC FRANK PERALES BRAZORIA COUNTY

38,370-01 JUAN ERNESTO CASTRO BEXAR COUNTY

38,534-02 WENDELL RAY POLLY DALLAS COUNTY

38,685-01 ZACHERICH SPEAKER HARRIS COUNTY

38,769-01 BACILLO C. LOPEZ DALLAS COUNTY

38,861-01 BARRY EUGENE LIVINGSTON TARRANT COUNTY

38,913-01 DONNIE MACK WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

38,933-01 PAUL STEVEN POLK NAVARRO COUNTY

38,958-01 OTIS RAY DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

38,973-02 REYNALDO PRADO BEXAR COUNTY

39,092-01 DAVID BRADLEY ASHCRAFT JOHNSON COUNTY

39,094-01 PAUL SEAN GAFFNEY GRAYSON COUNTY

39,099-01 NAPOLEON CASTANEDA TOM GREEN COUNTY

39,099-02 NAPOLEON CASTANEDA TOM GREEN COUNTY

39,099-03 NAPOLEON CASTANEDA TOM GREEN COUNTY

39,104-01 JOHN GREGORY CANTU TRAVIS COUNTY

39,114-01 JOHNNY DARRELL BAILEY NAVARRO COUNTY

39,130-01 RICARDO MALAGON DALLAS COUNTY

39,131-01 MARK BEASLEY TRAVIS COUNTY

39,156-01 SCOTT CHATAGNIER JR. JEFFERSON COUNTY

39,157-01 MITCHELL AUSTIN BAKER DALLAS COUNTY

39,158-01 PATRICK O. CROSSLIN TARRANT COUNTY

39,163-01 JERRY PEREZ TRAVIS COUNTY

39,164-01 KIMBERLY BROWN TARRANT COUNTY

39,166-01 JERRY LYNN NETTLES PARKER COUNTY

39,169-01 MICHAEL ALAN QUERTERMOUS DALLAS COUNTY

39,184-01 ARTURO SUNIGA JR. BEXAR COUNTY

39,187-01 JESUS GARZA EL PASO COUNTY

39,190-01 LEE ROY MCGRAW TOM GREEN COUNTY

39,198-01 DAVID LEE YOUNG HARRIS COUNTY

39,203-01 RAYMOND CORTEZ TOM GREEN COUNTY

39,208-01 LAWRENCE LASHEA JOHNSON COOKE COUNTY

39,218-01 ELLIS RAY WILLIAMS TARRANT COUNTY

39,221-01 JEFFREY PREVOST JEFFERSON COUNTY

39,223-01 CHRISTOPHER TERRELL SAM HARRIS COUNTY

39,224-01 RICHARD DANIEL GILBERT HARRIS COUNTY

39,225-01 JEROME HOWARD TRAVIS COUNTY

39,246-01 ROBERT GREEN LAIN DALLAS COUNTY

39,267-01 RICKY DAVE SEAGROVES DALLAS COUNTY

39,269-01 JOHN CROMWELL EL PASO COUNTY

5,467-51 DAN THOMAS BRAZORIA COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

26,804-04 CLYDE WESLEY STRINGER TARRANT COUNTY

32,597-03 GEORGE ANDREW JOHNSON BEXAR COUNTY

36,196-01 JERALD DALBRIT UNDERWOOD MIDLAND COUNTY

37,152-01 ROBERT RIVERA HOWARD COUNTY

38,869-01 FREDERICK FRANCOIS JEFFERSON COUNTY

39,125-01 ARMANDO LOPEZ CAMERON COUNTY

39,165-01 DOMINGO A. LLANAS MILAM COUNTY

39,214-01 MARCO ANTONIO SOLIZ WEBB COUNTY

39,219-01 FRANCISCO MENDOZA-DE LEON TARRANT COUNTY

39,270-01 L. C. STANCHIEL III MCLENNAN COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

39,126-01 MAURICE EVERTON JONES JR. BASTROP COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

15,999-04 JOHNNY JIMENEZ TAYLOR COUNTY

21,054-07 RAYMOND CLAYTON DALLAS COUNTY

23,091-13 KURBY GERALD DECKER WICHITA COUNTY

25,417-04 DAVID GLEN HARRIS TARRANT COUNTY

29,947-02 LORENZO ESTABON THOMAS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

30,116-02 TRACY DWAYNE STALLWORTH HARRIS COUNTY

30,447-03 TERRY LYNN FISHER WICHITA COUNTY

31,200-03 RONNIE GIST TOM GREEN COUNTY

31,759-02 JEFFREY HESS DALLAS COUNTY

31,788-03 JESSE LINDALE TAYLOR HARRIS COUNTY

32,756-03 DONALD RAY, JR. CAVITT BELL COUNTY

33,222-06 MICHAEL LEE WILSON DENTON COUNTY

33,865-02 RAY DONNELL JOHNSON HALE COUNTY

34,752-02 ROBERT LACKEY PRINGLE LIVE OAK COUNTY

36,208-02 GLEN BARNES JEFFERSON COUNTY

37,273-02 DARRELLEE D. DICKSON TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

34,256-01 LOREN KEITH FISHEL SHACKELFORD COUNTY

37,081-01 ELEAZAR AVILA-GUERRERA CAMERON COUNTY

38,283-01 CLYDE E. SOPHUS MADISON COUNTY

39,096-01 SCOTT LEE MOORE COLLIN COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

29,441-03 SYLVESTER ROBINSON CORYELL COUNTY

38,899-01 RICHARD HERNANDEZ BEXAR COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

12,342-09 TOMMY RAY STEWART BRAZOS COUNTY

27,413-04 LOUIS HOWARD CONFER MCLENNAN COUNTY

32,089-04 ALAN THOMAS HUNTER HARRIS COUNTY

37,488-01 HAROLD EDWARDS DALLAS COUNTY

38,682-01 PEDRO GUTIERREZ DALLAS COUNTY

39,120-01 RICHARD LARA TARRANT COUNTY

39,181-01 MARCUS SEBASTIAN EATON DALLAS COUNTY

39,192-01 TERRY DONALD HOWARD DENTON COUNTY

39,235-01 ANTONY WARD TARRANT COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

39,265-01 ADAN HERNANDEZ UVALDE COUNTY

39,201-01 MICHAEL EDWARD TURNER ROCKWALL COUNTY

AMENDED ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

10,395-03 JOSEPH STANLEY FAULDER ANGELINA COUNTY

(JUDGE BAIRD DISSENTS WITH NOTE)

(MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF PREVIOUSLY DISMISSED THIRD CLAIM DENIED)

ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:

37,979-01 JEFFREY TUCKER PARKER COUNTY


Return to
Court of Criminal Appeals