THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS
OCTOBER 23, 2002
THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:
73,458 LARRY DONELL DAVIS FROM POTTER COUNTY
AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE PRICE
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE WOMACK CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)
74,452 EX PARTE KELSHON EUKI OLIVER FROM TARRANT COUNTY
74,453 EX PARTE JOSEPH LEON BELL FROM HARRIS COUNTY
74,454 EX PARTE MICHAEL SANCHEZ FROM TRAVIS COUNTY
74,455 EX PARTE MARCOS RIOJAS HERNANDEZ FROM BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
74,456 EX PARTE RICHARD DAVID BACA FROM RANDALL COUNTY
74,457 EX PARTE SALVADOR GUTIERREZ, JR. FROM CAMERON COUNTY
ON APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
1939-00 NEIL HAMPTON ROBBINS MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-99-00120-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER JOINED IN PART)
CONCURRING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
(JUDGE HOLCOMB JOINED)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
(JUDGES WOMACK AND JOHNSON JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
1756-01 RICHARD GLEN LEHRMAN TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00119-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
(JUDGES JOHNSON AND COCHRAN CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
1938-01 PIOQUINTO MENDOZA, III WEBB COUNTY 04-00-00521-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
PUBLISHED OPINION
2116-01 JONATHAN MANZI HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01308-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK
(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
(JUDGE PRICE JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:
1022-00 LEO STEELMAN TAYLOR COUNTY 11-99-00155-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB
(JUDGE WOMACK CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
(JUDGES MEYERS AND JOHNSON JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE HERVEY JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
(JUDGE HERVEY JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE KEASLER JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
1023-00 IAN STEELMAN TAYLOR COUNTY 11-99-00156-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE HOLCOMB
(JUDGE WOMACK CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON
CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
(JUDGES MEYERS AND JOHNSON JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER
(JUDGE HERVEY JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER
(JUDGE HERVEY JOINED)
DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE HERVEY
(PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER AND JUDGE KEASLER JOINED)
PUBLISHED OPINION
1730-00 JUAN JOSE SOULAS NUECES COUNTY 13-99-00002-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
1731-00 JUAN JOSE SOULAS NUECES COUNTY 13-99-00003-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
1732-00 JUAN JOSE SOULAS NUECES COUNTY 13-99-00004-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;
CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS–OPINION JUDGE COCHRAN
NON-PUBLISHED OPINION
0183-01 DONALD PETER SUNBURY HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01357-CR
JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED–OPINION JUDGE MEYERS
PUBLISHED OPINION
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:
0919-02 TIMOTHY EARL CARROLL POLK COUNTY 09-97-00501-CR
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
0933-02 JAIME CHARLES NONN HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00658-CR
(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)
(NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)
APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
2440-01 MUNIZ, RUBEN, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-00673-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
0621-02 MAXWELL, JASON WILLIAM HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00708-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
0640-02 MELANCON, ALBERT JOSEPH HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00204-CR
0731-02 BRYANT, WILLIAM REESE HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01373-CR
0801-02 JOHNSON, EDWARD CHARLES TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00427-CR
0850-02 WOODALL, THOMAS RANDALL TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00084-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
0911-02 TAYLOR, JAMES RUDY TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00307-CR
0912-02 JACKSON, DENNIS CHARLES TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00187-CR
0971-02 MCCOY, MICHAEL EUGENE NOLAN COUNTY 11-01-00182-CR
1014-02 VASQUEZ, FIDENCIO LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00232-CR
1084-02 ORTIZ, MARCOS LOPEZ GALVESTON COUNTY 14-01-00556-CR
1085-02 ORTIZ, MARCOS LOPEZ GALVESTON COUNTY 14-01-00557-CR
1097-02 LOGGINS, TRESTON CHENCLEY HARDIN COUNTY 09-01-00030-CR
1106-02 ABALOS, LAZARO HAYS COUNTY 03-01-00351-CR
1127-02 STUBBLEFIELD, JOSH, JR. GALVESTON COUNTY 06-01-00121-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1129-02 MARBUT, BONNIE SUE (PDR #1) HILL COUNTY 10-01-00091-CR
1165-02 THOMAS, DERRICK DEWAYNE DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01514-CR
1172-02 ROGERS, ANTONIO TARRANT COUNTY 03-01-00565-CR
1191-02 BOTTENFIELD, STEVEN EDWARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00487-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1192-02 BOTTENFIELD, STEVEN EDWARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-00-00488-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1209-02 EX PARTE RUBY WASHINGTON POTTER COUNTY 07-01-00286-CR
1229-02 GRACE, MANDA KERR WALLER COUNTY 10-01-00028-CR
1234-02 HAWKINS, JULIE SUE STEEN TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00016-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
1282-02 ROBINSON, JOHN L. SMITH COUNTY 12-99-00326-CR
1290-02 SAWCHAK, MICHAEL S. BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00802-CR
1291-02 SAWCHAK, MICHAEL S. BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00803-CR
1356-02 KOUMIJIAN, PAUL EL PASO COUNTY 08-01-00243-CR
1388-02 SYKES, MARCKIEST DEQUINE DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01280-CR
1402-02 BORDAGES, JAMES HARRY HARRIS COUNTY 10-00-00222-CR
1403-02 LEAL, ALBERT BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00591-CR
1404-02 CASTILLO, JESUS A., JR. DALLAS COUNTY 05-00-01522-CR
1409-02 BROWN, JOHNNY LEE TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00253-CR
1410-02 JIMENEZ, JOSE ANTONIO DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00738-CR
1411-02 JIMENEZ, JOSE ANTONIO DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00739-CR
1412-02 KENNAMORE, LARRY LYNN HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00699-CR
1413-02 CORDAWAY, CHRISTOPHER ERIC FORT BEND COUNTY 01-01-00335-CR
1414-02 HINES, QUINTON ANDRE HARRIS COUNTY 01-01-00224-CR
1450-02 MOORE, DANNY EARL HARRIS COUNTY 06-01-00179-CR
1454-02 KANE, THOMAS ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00484-CR
1455-02 KANE, THOMAS ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00485-CR
1462-02 REYES, JIMMY EDWARD TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00244-CR
1518-02 TOSON, VICTOR ANTHONY TARRANT COUNTY 02-01-00254-CR
1629-02 PARKER, KIMBERLY CHAVON DENTON COUNTY 03-01-00572-CR
STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:
0833-02 MARTINEZ, GUILLERMO BEXAR COUNTY 04-01-00323-CR
(JUDGE MEYERS WOULD GRANT)
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
1129-02 MARBUT, BONNIE SUE (PDR #2) HILL COUNTY 10-01-00091-CR
1335-02 ERNESTO GONZALES CAMERON COUNTY 13-01-00461-CR
1336-02 ANDREWS, GERALD NAVARRO COUNTY 10-01-00061-CR
1448-02 JARAMILLO, SEVERIANO A. LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00488-CR
1457-02 BENOIT, JOHN KEVIN HARRIS COUNTY 04-01-00035-CR
1536-02 CLARK, TOMMY WAYNE MONTGOMERY COUNTY 09-01-00480-CR
APPELLANT'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:
1824-02 RUIZ-HERNANDEZ, OLIVIA DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-01176-CR
1832-02 LEWIS, TYRONE LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-02-00054-CR
1834-02 ORTIZ, TOMAS NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00311-CR
APPELLANT’S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW ORDERED STRUCK FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
0750-02 HASSAN, SAID ALI HARRIS COUNTY 01-00-00876-CR
0873-02 SANDOVAL, NOE CRUZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00049-CR
0874-02 SANDOVAL, NOE CRUZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00050-CR
0875-02 SANDOVAL, NOE CRUZ HARRIS COUNTY 14-01-00051-CR
0927-02 RAMIREZ, CESAR FRANCISCO WEBB COUNTY 04-00-00496-CR
0966-02 BLACKMON, FRED KENNEDY HARRIS COUNTY 06-01-00157-CR
0972-02 CALDWELL, XAVIER DALLAS COUNTY 08-01-00036-CR
0988-02 HALE, MICHAEL ORLANDA ORANGE COUNTY 13-01-00251-CR
1148-02 COSPER, DOUGLAS SHANE CORYELL COUNTY 10-01-00045-CR
1445-02 MORIN, ESTANISLADO HIDALGO COUNTY 13-01-00001-CR
1449-02 LACKEY, RANDY MACK LUBBOCK COUNTY 07-01-00355-CR
1500-02 CRENSHAW, RONALD NUECES COUNTY 13-00-00692-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
APPELLANT’S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW ORDERED REDRAWN FOR NON-COMPLIANCE WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
0909-02 PRICE, JAMES EVERETT MIDLAND COUNTY 08-01-00073-CR
0920-02 SOWERS, COREY RASHONE COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-00753-CR
0921-02 SOWERS, COREY RASHONE COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-00754-CR
0922-02 SOWERS, COREY RASHONE COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-00755-CR
0923-02 SOWERS, COREY RASHONE COLLIN COUNTY 05-01-00756-CR
1138-02 WALSH, JAMES WAYNE DENTON COUNTY 02-01-00218-CR
1139-02 WALSH, JAMES WAYNE DENTON COUNTY 02-01-00219-CR
1140-02 WALSH, JAMES WAYNE DENTON COUNTY 02-01-00231-CR
1456-02 WILLIAMS, KEVIN RAY DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00342-CR
1461-02 HEARNE, KEITH LAMONT DALLAS COUNTY 05-01-00858-CR
PRESIDING JUDGE KELLER, JUDGES KEASLER AND HERVEY DISSENT TO THE ABOVE ORDERS:
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
18,276-02 LARRY LEE WINDHAM PALO PINTO COUNTY
18,276-03 LARRY LEE WINDHAM PALO PINTO COUNTY
18,276-04 LARRY LEE WINDHAM PALO PINTO COUNTY
39,054-10 PATRICK E. SANDERS TARRANT COUNTY
43,103-04 MICHAEL FREDERICK HEINE BELL COUNTY
5,944-06 LARRY WAYNE SMITH DALLAS COUNTY
51,715-02 DAVID URIBE TRAVIS COUNTY
52,989-02 PIERRE SMITH TRAVIS COUNTY
53,172-02 DOMINGO LOPEZ VICTORIA COUNTY
53,224-01 DANIEL L. MARTIN BEXAR COUNTY
53,224-02 DANIEL L. MARTIN BEXAR COUNTY
53,436-01 FINIS CHARLES LIGGETT DENTON COUNTY
53,436-02 FINIS CHARLES LIGGETT DENTON COUNTY
53,577-01 CHERYL ANN BUSH GREGG COUNTY
53,631-01 DOMINIQUE VANSHAN BOSTIC DALLAS COUNTY
53,680-01 ROY LEE NEW JR. ELLIS COUNTY
53,698-01 ERIC JUSTICE TRAVIS COUNTY
53,739-01 DEANGUS M. WRIGHT TARRANT COUNTY
53,769-01 PAUL DONALD GRIFFIN, JR. BRAZORIA COUNTY
53,775-01 RONNIE LEON MATHIS DALLAS COUNTY
53,798-01 DALE BLANE CLAYPOOL BRAZOS COUNTY
53,812-01 ALFREDO HERNANDEZ IBARRA CAMERON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)
10,569-09 SCHWINN CORVETTE HENRY HARRIS COUNTY
52,152-02 WENDELL EUGENE HENRY DALLAS COUNTY
52,765-01 JAMES EDWARD WATSON DALLAS COUNTY
52,765-02 JAMES EDWARD WATSON DALLAS COUNTY
52,765-03 JAMES EDWARD WATSON DALLAS COUNTY
53,254-02 ROBERT EARL SMITH ROBERTSON COUNTY
53,428-01 DONAVON RENARD WILSON WILLIAMSON COUNTY
53,517-01 CHRISTOPHER OMAR THOMPSON HARRIS COUNTY
53,553-01 STANLEY KENT GAUL MAVERICK COUNTY
53,577-02 CHERYL ANN BUSH GREGG COUNTY
53,634-01 SAMUEL JERIMIAS RAMIREZ TARRANT COUNTY
53,695-01 DAVID EARL GREEN HARRIS COUNTY
53,715-01 MICHAEL BRYANT TRAVIS COUNTY
53,717-01 RONALD BANKSTON HARRIS COUNTY
53,787-02 WILLIAM R. WALKER WILLIAMSON COUNTY
53,805-01 TRACY JAMES JR. HARRIS COUNTY
53,805-02 TRACY JAMES JR. HARRIS COUNTY
53,806-01 SEAN CAMPOS MONGOSING BELL COUNTY
53,806-02 SEAN CAMPOS MONGOSING BELL COUNTY
53,807-01 KENNETH WAYNE THORN JR. ELLIS COUNTY
53,859-01 BLAKE PARRISH TOM GREEN COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
29,360-12 SHAWN ERIC MCGEE DALLAS COUNTY
29,360-13 SHAWN ERIC MCGEE DALLAS COUNTY
4,404-09 LARRY JEROME GARRETT TAYLOR COUNTY
53,327-01 VERNARD DAVIS MCLENNAN COUNTY
53,460-01 ARMANDO ROMERO GAONA JIM WELLS COUNTY
53,671-01 TILMER ALDRIDGE TRAVIS COUNTY
53,734-01 SAMMY DWAYNE TURNEY HARRIS COUNTY
53,770-01 RONALD BERNARD BOSWELL COLLIN COUNTY
53,780-01 ASHLEY PAUL LEWIS HARRIS COUNTY
53,792-01 CARLTON STEELS ROBERTSON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)
53,787-01 WILLIAM R. WALKER WILLIAMSON COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)
16,010-07 DODSON LUGENE BALLARD CHEROKEE COUNTY
40,323-03 MICHAEL TODD SONTCHI HARRIS COUNTY
41,958-02 BRUCE DAVID CONLEY TARRANT COUNTY
46,362-05 FORREST LEE STOKES HARRIS COUNTY
46,794-03 ECKZAR JR. SALAME HOOD COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER
(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )
20,691-05 TIMOTHY HUGH QUEEN HARRIS COUNTY
53,615-01 ROBERTO GUITIERREZ JR. STARR COUNTY
53,726-01 MICHAEL A. RAY DALLAS COUNTY
53,786-01 WARREN JR. COLEMAN ANDERSON COUNTY
53,789-01 JOSEPH ANTHONY SHAW EL PASO COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE
AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:
27,435-03 MIGUEL ANGEL GONZALEZ EL PASO COUNTY
35,988-03 JEFFERY O. BROUSSARD HARRIS COUNTY
48,123-02 JOE LATHON FOWLER HARRIS COUNTY
53,001-03 RAY FRANKLIN NELSON HILL COUNTY
53,001-04 RAY FRANKLIN NELSON HILL COUNTY
53,704-01 DONALD LINDSEY HARRIS COUNTY
53,759-01 FRANCISCO E. CASTANEDA HIDALGO COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:
16,745-04 PATSY KAY TOWNES COLLIN COUNTY
33,195-02 CURTIS ELRUE THOMASON HENDERSON COUNTY
48,873-03 ROGER DALE SPENCER DENTON COUNTY
53,482-01 STEVE RANDALE KING TARRANT COUNTY
53,520-01 DARRELL WADE POLLOCK THROCKMORTON COUNTY
53,561-01 KIRMON LEMONS DE WITT COUNTY
53,632-02 RALPH WALLACE SHAMBLIN HARRIS COUNTY
53,656-01 DONALD RAY HOUSTON DENTON COUNTY
53,656-02 DONALD RAY HOUSTON DENTON COUNTY
53,701-01 ALBERT JR. JONES DALLAS COUNTY
53,732-01 RAFIQUE ALI HARRIS COUNTY
52,749-02 JULIAN DELACRUZ BURNET COUNTY
APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:
44,927-03 RICHARD D. BACA RANDALL COUNTY
52,444-02 MICHAEL SANCHEZ TRAVIS COUNTY
53,377-01 SALVADOR GUTIERREZ, JR. CAMERON COUNTY
53,716-01 JOSEPH LEON BELL HARRIS COUNTY
53,743-01 MARCOS RIOJAS HERNANDEZ BEXAR COUNTY
53,777-01 KELSHON EUKI OLIVER TARRANT COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT
WRITTEN ORDER:
18,204-04 CHARLES LEAMON GERMAN COUNTY
22,480-07 JEROME HUNTER BEXAR COUNTY
22,735-24 ALFRED LEE STONE POTTER COUNTY
45,445-02 TONY WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY
51,354-05 RONROYAL J. OWENS DALLAS COUNTY
51,354-06 RONROYAL J. OWENS DALLAS COUNTY
51,715-01 DAVID URIBE TRAVIS COUNTY
52,869-01 FELIX TIJERINA BEXAR COUNTY
(JUDGE HERVEY NOT PARTICIPATING)
52,989-01 PIERRE R. SMITH TRAVIS COUNTY
53,294-02 GARY O'SHAY JACKSON DALLAS COUNTY
53,605-01 JOHNNY MILLER DALLAS COUNTY
53,632-01 RALPH WALLACE SHAMBLIN HARRIS COUNTY
ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:
50,773-01 LIONELL GONZALES RODRIGUEZ HARRIS COUNTY
52,672-01 LARRY ALLEN HAYES MONTGOMERY COUNTY
52,775-01 LUIS RAMIREZ TOM GREEN COUNTY
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:
37,249-03 CHRISTOPHER J. PEOPLES HOOD COUNTY