THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



NOVEMBER 29, 2000



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





73,127         BRITTANY MARLOWE HOLBERG FROM RANDALL COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

(JUDGE MEYERS NOT PARTICIPATING)

(JUDGE KELLER JOINED OPINION EXCEPT TO ITS DISCUSSION OF POINT OF ERROR NO. 40)

(JUDGE PRICE JOINED ONLY THE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT)

(JUDGE WOMACK JOINED OPINION EXCEPT TO ITS DISCUSSION OF POINT OF ERROR NO. 16)

(JUDGE JOHNSON JOINED OPINION EXCEPT TO ITS DISPOSITION OF POINT OF ERROR NO. 40, TO WHICH SHE DISSENTED)

PUBLISHED IN PART



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)



73,966         EX PARTE ROBERT EVE HOWARD FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,967         EX PARTE RICARDO GALLEGOS FROM DENTON COUNTY

73,968         EX PARTE ANDREW NORFLEET FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,969         EX PARTE GEORGE FREDRICK WARRINER FROM HARRIS COUNTY

73,970         EX PARTE OSCAR LONGORIA FROM TOM GREEN COUNTY

73,971         EX PARTE DANIEL BOOKER FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY

73,972         EX PARTE CARLOS LAVERNIA FROM TRAVIS COUNTY

(JUDGE WOMACK DISSENTS)



ON STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



1618-99         RODNEY DEE ROSS FROM AUSTIN COUNTY

   JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

                       (PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK DISSENTED)

                       CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

                       (JUDGES KELLER AND KEASLER JOINED)

    PUBLISHED OPINION



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1305-00         MICHAEL G. ROBLES (SPA'S #1) HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00548-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1305-00         MICHAEL G. ROBLES (DA'S #2) HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00548-CR

                       (NO ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1366-00         HAYHURST, THANE DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00178-CR

1472-00         WINN, KENNETH UPSHUR COUNTY 06-99-00035-CR

1516-00         CLANTON, PATRICK KEVIN HARRIS COUNTY 01-99-00848-CR

1517-00         CONLEY, JESSIE RAY BRAZOS COUNTY 01-99-00363-CR

1563-00         HINKLE, ROBERT CLINTON HENDERSON COUNTY 12-99-00129-CR

1565-00         LEE, ANNA TRAVIS COUNTY 05-99-00459-CR

1567-00         PATTON, JAMES EVERETT BANDERA COUNTY 03-99-00250-CR

1569-00         REEVES, LARRY WILLIAMSON COUNTY 03-99-00410-CR

                       (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

1572-00         MCCRIGHT, ALFIE K. DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01215-CR

1578-00         FAIR, BOBBY BOWIE COUNTY 06-99-00134-CR

1580-00         FINK, DAVID LOUIS HARRIS COUNTY 06-99-00149-CR

1604-00         WATSON, CHARLES RAY BRAZOS COUNTY 01-99-00364-CR

1605-00         WATSON, CHARLES RAY BRAZOS COUNTY 01-99-00365-CR

1607-00         DEROUEN, TROY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00632-CR

1608-00         TAYLOR, JEFFERY ANDERSON HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00633-CR

1609-00         RODRIGUEZ, RICARDO ROJAS HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00512-CR

1613-00         HENDERSON, JARAY HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01084-CR

1616-00         GUZMAN, JOHN RENEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01129-CR

1620-00         MCCLELLAN, JOHN FERRELL DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-00855-CR

1629-00         BORREGO, JOHN PAUL HARRIS COUNTY 01-96-00408-CR

1631-00         YBARBO, IAN SCOTT COLLIN COUNTY 05-98-01903-CR

                       (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

1632-00         BASINGER, JIMMY DARREL DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-01898-CR

1635-00         ESPINOZA, DOMINGO HARRIS COUNTY 13-99-00417-CR

1636-00         SALINAS, ALFREDO KLEBERG COUNTY 13-99-00226-CR

1637-00         FAVORS, ALEXIS RASHAAD TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00013-CR

1639-00         SOLIS, JUAN CARLOS HIDALGO COUNTY 13-97-00462-CR

1643-00         SINGLETARY, JOHNNY MATAGORDA COUNTY 13-98-00574-CR

1645-00         GUERRA, JUAN ANDRES HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00311-CR

1646-00         GUERRA, JUAN ANDRES HIDALGO COUNTY 13-99-00312-CR

1718-00         EDMONDSON, III, STITH REESE PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-99-00123-CR

1719-00         EDMONDSON, III, STITH REESE PALO PINTO COUNTY 11-99-00124-CR

1736-00         SENDEJO, DAVID NUECES COUNTY 13-98-00633-CR

1737-00         CROW, BARRY DON DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-02150-CR

1740-00         LEWIS, JAMES EDWARD HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00538-CR

1741-00         KELLEY, TERRANCE MARKEITH ELLIS COUNTY 10-99-00213-CR

1742-00         REID, WAYNE JOHN BOWIE COUNTY 06-99-00013-CR

1755-00         CHALMERS, WINSTON CHARLES DALLAS COUNTY 11-99-00085-CR

1756-00         CAPPS, ROY PAUL ERATH COUNTY 11-00-00108-CR

1817-00         MIMS, ANTHONY WAYNE HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01426-CR



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW DISMISSED:



1728-00         TOMMY E. MARTIN DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01892-CR

                       (MOTION TO SHOW AUTHORITY/MOTION TO STRIKE DENIED)



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



26,520-02         RICKY COLBERT HARRIS COUNTY

37,702-02         NATHANIEL LEAL TARRANT COUNTY

45,702-02         FREDERICK L. MCCORMICK HARRIS COUNTY

46,702-02         JAMES EDWARD LONDON HEMPHILL COUNTY

47,003-01         DIRKSON YOUMAN UPSHUR COUNTY

47,031-01         LANCE GERHARD EDWARDS HARRIS COUNTY

47,031-02         LANCE GERHARD EDWARDS HARRIS COUNTY

47,031-03         LANCE GERHARD EDWARDS HARRIS COUNTY

47,031-04         LANCE GERHARD EDWARDS HARRIS COUNTY

47,233-01         ROBERT CHARLES WILSON TARRANT COUNTY

47,371-01         JAMES LEE MULLINS II BOSQUE COUNTY

47,445-01         WILLIAM EDWARD DAVIS TARRANT COUNTY

47,515-01         BILLY WAYNE KERR ECTOR COUNTY

47,564-01         DOUGLAS R. GILLINGHAM TARRANT COUNTY

47,594-01         DENNIS BERNHARDT DALLAS COUNTY

47,621-01         DONALD DWYER CLAY COUNTY

47,666-01         CLYDE NEWTON SETTLES FALLS COUNTY

47,682-01         JIM WINDHAM DALLAS COUNTY

47,684-01         JEFFREY CLINTON VACCARO TARRANT COUNTY

7,132-02           DEWEY DAVIS GREGG COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)



20,021-02         ANTHONY JOSEPH JR. HARRIS COUNTY

24,762-02         RAUL GARCIA BEXAR COUNTY

34,978-02         MARK ANTHONY MILLER DALLAS COUNTY

41,345-04         EARL WAYNE DUNCAN JR. LUBBOCK COUNTY

45,152-03         MYCAL ANTONIO POOLE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

45,609-03         TRENT ALVON SMITH WOOD COUNTY

46,318-01         JAMES WHALEY MADISON COUNTY

46,697-02         DELBERT COFFEE TRAVIS COUNTY

46,773-01         LORENZO ARELLANO TARRANT COUNTY

46,880-01         ANTHONY BERNARD WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

47,012-02         ERIC TYLER WORTHEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,091-01         ILDEFONSO AGUILAR ELLIS COUNTY

47,136-01         ROSS THOMAS BRANTLEY DALLAS COUNTY

47,258-01         WILLIAM ADRIAN ANDERSON DALLAS COUNTY

47,276-01         ARLEN RAY MELTON DALLAS COUNTY

47,323-01         JESSIE MARTINEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,330-01         HIGINIO RAMON MARTINEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,442-01         TUNG MINH DUONG HARRIS COUNTY

47,462-01         KENNETH WAYNE ROSE DALLAS COUNTY

47,470-01         DERRICK E. MCCREE DALLAS COUNTY

47,613-01         LEROY MARTIN WHITE JEFFERSON COUNTY

47,622-01         ARTHUR ALMEIDA JR. HARRIS COUNTY

47,635-01         MARTIN RAMIREZ DALLAS COUNTY

47,709-01         ANTHONY CRIAGE GORDON HARRIS COUNTY

47,709-02         ANTHONY CRIAGE GORDON HARRIS COUNTY

47,809-01         LOUIS DALE TURNER HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

25,165-02         HORACE DEMAR HARRIS COUNTY

44,519-01         MONT JACK DEAL KAUFMAN COUNTY

45,964-01         DOUGLAS BLACKWELL TRAVIS COUNTY

47,219-01         RONALD WAYNE NEWLAND HARRIS COUNTY

47,250-01         JOSE NEVAREZ EL PASO COUNTY

47,250-02         JOSE NEVAREZ EL PASO COUNTY

47,416-01         JOHN LEWIS WILDER CAMP COUNTY

47,449-01         MARK ANDREW BLEVENS HARRIS COUNTY

47,500-01         DAVID LLOYD LOWE HARRIS COUNTY

47,527-01         TONY LOERA HERNANDEZ COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)



41,199-03         MICHAEL JEROME WHEELER DALLAS COUNTY

46,766-02         ROBERT COOPER DALLAS COUNTY

47,213-01         JOSEPH SLAUGHTER HARRIS COUNTY

47,426-01         JOHN ROBERT SANCHEZ BEXAR COUNTY

47,808-01         MURRAY CLAYTON FRANK HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)

20,364-05         ROBERT PERRY JR. WALKER COUNTY

20,815-06         ELLIOTT SEGINE WINFIELD TARRANT COUNTY

22,882-07         DAVID DUNN FREESTONE COUNTY

29,193-13         REGINALD CHRISTOPHER HARRIS WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

3,069-12           DONALD RAY WILLIAMS SR BRAZORIA COUNTY

34,353-02         ANTONIO RODRIGUEZ DALLAS COUNTY

36,879-02         LATHAN EARL WILLIAMS HARRIS COUNTY

37,822-04         DEBRA ANN GORMAN HARRIS COUNTY

41,396-02         WILLIE LEE SINGLETON HARRIS COUNTY

43,995-02         LOUIS D. TALBERT BRAZOS COUNTY

8,221-08           MICHAEL CHARLES HILL DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )

15,528-03         OSCAR LEE SAENZ JIM WELLS COUNTY

20,021-03         ANTHONY JOSEPH JR. HARRIS COUNTY

29,890-02         ALBERTO CANTU HARRIS COUNTY

37,752-02         TERRY SMITH HALE COUNTY

44,145-03         WAYNE HARVEL TALBERT POTTER COUNTY

44,145-04         WAYNE HARVEL TALBERT POTTER COUNTY

46,856-02         NATHANIEL ROLLINS LIBERTY COUNTY

47,228-01         WILLIAM ALLEN POSEY DALLAS COUNTY

47,312-01         IME OKON EKWERE HARRIS COUNTY

47,421-01         JAMES H. WASHINGTON TARRANT COUNTY

47,440-01         KEITH JOSEPH DEGRUY BELL COUNTY

47,457-01         COLOMBUS MCGRUDER HARRIS COUNTY

47,603-01         BERNIE SLABAUGH FALLS COUNTY

47,687-01         KENDRICK ROBERTSON BRAZOS COUNTY

47,693-01         KEVIN GEORGE BRADLEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,848-01         CHRISTOPHER SHAUN HERRON DALLAS COUNTY

47,852-01         DAVID AARON SMOOT TAYLOR COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

46,373-01         DANIEL G. VALDEZ KENDALL COUNTY

46,373-02         DANIEL G. VALDEZ KENDALL COUNTY

46,546-01         MICHAEL VAUGHN KING DALLAS COUNTY

                          (JUDGES MANSFIELD AND KEASLER WOULD DENY)

47,647-01         BILLY JAMES BLACKWELL TAYLOR COUNTY

47,702-01         JEFFREY A. RAMSEY DALLAS COUNTY

47,775-01         ALLAN WEBSTER TARRANT COUNTY

47,777-01         GARY L. PRICE TARRANT COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

15,993-07         CARLOS M. LAVERNIA TRAVIS COUNTY

29,398-02         ANDREW NORFLEET HARRIS COUNTY

35,774-03         GEORGE FREDRICK WARRINER HARRIS COUNTY

45,012-01         RICARDO GALLEGOS DENTON COUNTY

47,149-01         DANIEL BOOKER JEFFERSON COUNTY

47,674-01         OSCAR LONGORIA TOM GREEN COUNTY

47,704-01         ROBERT EVE HOWARD HARRIS COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

32,507-05         JAMES HENRY STONE SR. MADISON COUNTY

46,697-01         DELBERT COFFEE TRAVIS COUNTY

46,837-01         DAVID PAUL FISCUS GALVESTON COUNTY

47,444-01         MARIA ALCORN COUNTY

47,604-01         JUAN G. VILLARREAL LAMB COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

10,564-19         PERRY COMO DENBY HARRIS COUNTY

47,822-01         TROY DENNIS HARRIS COUNTY



MOTION FOR EN BANC RECONSIDERATION AND REHEARING ON APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



20,051-02         LEONARD NATHANIEL FRANCIS HARRIS COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



46,565-02         JEREMY ALANIZ UVALDE COUNTY

47,161-01         JEFFREY L. LEWIS DENTON COUNTY



MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



46,584-02         JOSEPH W. BOBINEAUX FORT BEND COUNTY

46,702-01         JAMES EDWARD DONDON HEMPHILL COUNTY