THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS



DECEMBER 13, 2000



THE FOLLOWING ORDERS ARE ENTERED AND OPINIONS HANDED DOWN:





73,033         JAMES LEWIS JACKSON FROM HARRIS COUNTY

AFFIRMED--OPINION PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK

(JUDGE KELLER CONCURRED ON POINT OF ERROR NO. 11)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MEYERS

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGES PRICE, HOLLAND AND WOMACK JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



HABEAS CORPUS RELIEF GRANTED--OPINIONS BY THE COURT: (NON-PUBLISHED OPINIONS)



73,974         EX PARTE DONALD RAY MIDDLETON FROM HARRIS COUNTY SK

73,975         EX PARTE ENTRE NAX KARAGE FROM DALLAS COUNTY PW

73,976         EX PARTE GLOSTON E. MARION FROM HARRIS COUNTY CJ

73,977         EX PARTE DAVID HILLERY RAMSEY FROM BOSQUE COUNTY CJ

73,978         EX PARTE WALTER A. CONELY FROM TRAVIS COUNTY MK

73,979         EX PARTE GREGORY DWAYNE THOMAS FROM BEXAR COUNTY LM

73,980         EX PARTE GREGORY DWAYNE THOMAS FROM BEXAR COUNTY LM



ON APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW:



1254-99       BENJAMIN LEON BLUE FROM HARRIS COUNTY

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS REVERSED;

CAUSE REMANDED TO COURT OF APPEALS--OPINION JUDGE JOHNSON

(JUDGE MEYERS CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE MANSFIELD

CONCURRING OPINION JUDGE KEASLER

DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE KELLER

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE WOMACK JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION





ON COURT'S OWN MOTION FOR REHEARING:



1692-99       ZEDRIC MILLER FROM SMITH COUNTY

` PRIOR OPINIONS ARE WITHDRAWN;

MODIFICATION OF SENTENCE IS SET ASIDE;

JUDGMENT OF COURT OF APPEALS AFFIRMED--OPINION JUDGE PRICE

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK & JUDGE MANSFIELD CONCURRED IN THE RESULT)

CONCURRING AND DISSENTING OPINION JUDGE WOMACK

(JUDGE KELLER JOINED)

PUBLISHED OPINION



STATE'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW GRANTED:



1244-00       MILTON POWELL (SPA'S NO. 1) SABINE COUNTY 12-98-00049-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NO. 2 ONLY)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)



1244-00       MILTON POWELL (DA'S NO. 2) SABINE COUNTY 12-98-00049-CR

(GRANTED ON GROUND NOS. 1B, 2A, 2B)

(ORAL ARGUMENT PERMITTED)

APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1324-00         SARVER, RONNY LEE HARRIS COUNTY 06-99-00096-CR

                       (JUDGES MEYERS AND JOHNSON WOULD GRANT ON GROUND NO. 1 ONLY)

1648-00         SIMIEN, JOSEPH DONALD, JR. HARRIS COUNTY 13-99-00255-CR

1655-00         LANIER, JOE LEON PECOS COUNTY 08-99-00105-CR

1657-00         AUTRY, CHARLES BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00660-CR

1659-00         JOHNSON, TAVARIS D. TARRANT COUNTY 02-99-00161-CR

1660-00         TESARIK, CYNTHIA CHRISTINE DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01288-CR

1663-00         CLARK, DAVID LEE JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-99-00341-CR

1664-00         FONTNETTE, TERRY LYNN JEFFERSON COUNTY 09-99-00411-CR

1665-00         MULLINS, ROBERT LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01751-CR

1666-00         MULLINS, ROBERT LEE DALLAS COUNTY 05-99-01752-CR

1670-00         MORGAS, CARLOS ANTONIO HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01294-CR

1672-00         INFANTE, RAFAEL SOLIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01408-CR

1673-00         INFANTE, RAFAEL SOLIS HARRIS COUNTY 01-98-01409-CR

1674-00         SALAZAR, ROBERT BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00200-CR

1676-00         MARIN, DANNY HOLGUIN BEXAR COUNTY 04-99-00226-CR

1677-00         ROBERTSON, ROBERT LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00541-CR

1678-00         ROBERTSON, ROBERT LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00542-CR

1680-00         RAMIREZ, CHRISTOPHER LEE HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00418-CR

1683-00         HOWARD, SHANNON ROY HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-00651-CR

1684-00         TYLER, MICHAEL ANTIONE TARRANT COUNTY 02-98-00646-CR

1691-00         AGERS, KEITH DALLAS COUNTY 05-98-02052-CR

1703-00         CHAPNICK, BRYAN HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-01134-CR

1704-00         STULTS, THOMAS HARRIS COUNTY 14-98-01314-CR

1770-00         JOHNSON, LESLIE WAYNE JEFFERSON COUNTY 07-99-00395-CR

1784-00         SIMMONS, DAMON HARRIS COUNTY 14-99-00890-CR

1795-00         CYR, ROGER SMITH COUNTY 12-99-00373-CR

1797-00         ENGLAND, ARLIE DWIGHT HENDERSON COUNTY 12-99-00379-CR

1806-00         BERRY, NICHOLAS DANIEL NACOGDOCHES COUNTY 12-99-00376-CR

1807-00         ARNOLD, BRYONE SMITH COUNTY 12-99-00186-CR

1869-00         BURKE, STEPHEN A. CORYELL COUNTY 10-99-00260-CR

1874-00         SCHRADER, MICHAEL TRAVIS COUNTY 03-99-00780-CR

1885-00         HALL, DANIEL GUADALUPE COUNTY 04-99-00760-CR

STATE'S PETITIONS FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED:



1689-00         EVANS, JAMES ALLEN COLLIN COUNTY 08-97-00519-CR

                      (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)



1690-00         EVANS, JAMES ALLEN COLLIN COUNTY 08-97-00520-CR

                        (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)



APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW REFUSED AS UNTIMELY FILED:



2076-00         NEWSON, WILLIE GEORGE DALLAS COUNTY 08-99-00367-CR

2078-00         MORALES, ROLDOLFO CAMPOS HIDALGO COUNTY 13-98-00555-CR



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



11,523-03         OTIS BELSER BELL COUNTY

13,634-02         AARON KEITH GILKEY TRAVIS COUNTY

26,169-06         RAYMOND PETER GODAIRE TARRANT COUNTY

27,158-08         WALTER CRAIG MORRIS TYLER COUNTY

27,158-09         WALTER CRAIG MORRIS TYLER COUNTY

29,860-02         JOHN ALVIS WRIGHT DALLAS COUNTY

31,553-02         PERRY LEE OLSON NEWTON COUNTY

34,224-02         RANDY PEACE LUBBOCK COUNTY

38,020-02         GEORGE VENTURA EL PASO COUNTY

4,580-11           ROBERT RASBERRY JR. PANOLA COUNTY

41,810-01         JOHNNY B. STERLING NAVARRO COUNTY

42,795-01         CHARLES RAY PHILLIPS WARD COUNTY

42,933-03         KENNETH RICHARD ELZY DENTON COUNTY

43,444-02         GILBERT GOMEZ LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,652-01         WALTER BLACKSTOCK ANDERSON COUNTY

43,842-02         BARRY JOSEPH POWELL GREGG COUNTY

43,862-03         KENNETH WAYNE LITTLETON PANOLA COUNTY

45,259-01         RANDALL LAWRENCE COOPER DALLAS COUNTY

45,270-01         IKE WILLIAMS ORANGE COUNTY

45,660-01         WALTER LEE IRVING TARRANT COUNTY

45,908-01         ROBERT R. GRESSETT MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,041-01         RALPH W. KNOWLES III KAUFMAN COUNTY

                          (JUDGES MEYERS, PRICE, WOMACK & JOHNSON WOULD FILED & SET)

47,248-02         HENRY LEE KING DALLAS COUNTY

47,255-01         RUSSELL FORD JEFFERSON COUNTY

47,272-01         JOSHUA PARKS NUECES COUNTY

47,299-01         LEON FREDERICK FORT BEND COUNTY

47,406-01         ERNEST FITZGERALD TOLON POTTER COUNTY

47,406-02         ERNEST FITZGERALD TOLON POTTER COUNTY

47,406-03         ERNEST FITZGERALD TOLON POTTER COUNTY

47,618-01         ALLEN J. FALBY DENTON COUNTY

47,663-01         CARLOS DALE DALLAS COUNTY

47,664-01         LUZ MARIA MARQUEZ DALLAS COUNTY

47,696-01         RODOLFO RAMIREZ WILLACY COUNTY

47,714-01         PANDRA L. HILL DALLAS COUNTY

47,780-01         GARY DEWAYNE HENNINGTON DALLAS COUNTY

47,856-01         EDDIE EUGENE YOUNG CASS COUNTY

47,898-01         RAUL RANGEL JR. DENTON COUNTY

47,913-01         DARIN MICHAEL HAGEY DENTON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITHOUT HEARING)

17,639-05         GARLAND CLIFTON EPTING MIDLAND COUNTY

27,718-03         REGINALD NELSON HARRIS COUNTY

35,145-04         RACHEL LEE BROWN DALLAS COUNTY

39,176-02         RODNEY K. BURTON HARRIS COUNTY

39,358-02         ROGER DALE MEDFORD TARRANT COUNTY

43,362-03         NATHANAIL SHAW HARRIS COUNTY

43,964-03         ROBERT LEE LYLES HARRIS COUNTY

45,183-02         GREGORY LAWRENCE MOORE WOOD COUNTY

46,031-02         TERRY J. GILL HARRIS COUNTY

46,034-02         MIKE CRAIG COX DALLAS COUNTY

46,748-01         FREDERICK LEE PEOPLES ROCKWALL COUNTY

46,778-02         TIM D. TINLIN TARRANT COUNTY

46,808-02         CLARENCE E. EDWARDS ELLIS COUNTY

47,234-01         MICHAEL SLAUGHTER DE WITT COUNTY

47,308-01         BOBBY RAY GARRETT DALLAS COUNTY

47,395-02         LUIS ALONSO MARTINEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,447-01         DARREN DARCEL REMMER MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,507-02         GILBERT GILES HARRIS COUNTY

47,616-01         GARY LEE NELMS TOM GREEN COUNTY

47,664-02         LUZ MARIA MARQUEZ DALLAS COUNTY

47,683-01         TONY SANCHEZ BEXAR COUNTY

47,697-01         GEORGE LONGORIA WILLACY COUNTY

47,740-01         GLEN JOHNSON III WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                          (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

47,759-01         TRACY RAY SELEVY HARRIS COUNTY

47,761-01         ABDUL BRENT SEATON TAYLOR COUNTY

47,763-01         PREVIN LOVELL HEMPHILL HARRIS COUNTY

47,766-01         WARREN LASHAUN JACKSON HARRIS COUNTY

47,800-01         GERALD NELSON LEE WILLIAMSON COUNTY

                         (JUDGE WOMACK NOT PARTICIPATING)

47,804-01         DAIMION OSBY TARRANT COUNTY

47,814-01         RICHARD LEE SCHARDT LAMAR COUNTY

47,835-01         PATRICK ARNOLD WHITE HARRIS COUNTY

47,851-01         GLENN EVERETT CROFT DALLAS COUNTY

47,855-01         MARK ANTHONY VALERY HARRIS COUNTY

47,861-01         RONALD LEMONT LAWRENCE BELL COUNTY

47,865-01         TIMOTHY DARWIN EILAND HARRIS COUNTY

47,879-01         BASEM MICHAEL AZIZEH HARRIS COUNTY

47,885-01         GREGORIO RODRIGUEZ JR. DALLAS COUNTY

47,888-01         LARRY DON BAIRD LAMAR COUNTY

47,912-01         DWIGHT TUCKER HARRIS COUNTY

47,925-01         ROBERTO SANDOVAL DALLAS COUNTY

47,933-01         FREDERICO RAMIREZ YBARRA TOM GREEN COUNTY

47,961-01         CARL DWAYNE GODFREY HARRIS COUNTY

47,979-01         CARL EUGENE EADDY JR. TARRANT COUNTY

48,045-01         GARY BRIAN EDWARDS NUECES COUNTY

48,045-02         GARY BRIAN EDWARDS NUECES COUNTY

5,358-13         JOHN ROBERT GRAY HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ON TRIAL COURT FINDINGS WITH HEARING)

47,524-01         CEDRIC POWELL DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

13,345-02         KENNETH RAY BRANTLEY HARRIS COUNTY

41,739-01         HOWARD DAVID FISH CAMERON COUNTY

42,573-01         THOMAS SHIRLEY BOWIE COUNTY

43,270-01         ERIC PAUL COURTNEY TARRANT COUNTY

43,522-01         TROY DON ALEXANDER TARRANT COUNTY

46,252-02         JOSEPH C. GALVAN BEXAR COUNTY

46,618-01         CHARLES WILLIAM THOMASON EL PASO COUNTY

47,092-02         WILLIAM JAMES DANIEL HARRIS COUNTY

47,356-01         TYSON JOSEPH MARTINEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,724-01         WILBERT JOSEPH LEWIS HARRIS COUNTY

47,764-01         AZHAR EBAN MAYDUN HARRIS COUNTY

47,824-01         ENRIQUE M. CAMPOS HARRIS COUNTY

47,829-01         DAVID PINKNEY HARRIS COUNTY

47,837-01         SADAR DARKAR CADE HARRIS COUNTY

47,837-02         SADAR DARKAR CADE HARRIS COUNTY

47,837-03         SADAR DARKAR CADE HARRIS COUNTY

47,837-04         SADAR DARKAR CADE HARRIS COUNTY

47,840-01         RICHARD JOSE DELEON HARRIS COUNTY

47,928-01         GEORGE PRINCE HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(DIRECT APPEAL PENDING)

46,204-02         STEPHEN JAY MORRIS HARRIS COUNTY

47,619-01         RENDELL CARTER DALLAS COUNTY

47,770-01         KEITH ODELL CADOREE HARRIS COUNTY

47,935-01         THOMAS FREDERICK BONNER WOOD COUNTY

47,954-01         LEON A. WALKER BOWIE COUNTY

47,981-01         TOMMY LOGAN TRAVIS COUNTY



APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:

(ART. 11.07, SEC.4)



11,228-07         CARL ULYSSES MCAFEE HARRIS COUNTY

12,333-07         SIDNEY LEE WALKER HARRIS COUNTY

22,550-05         BARRY NEAL WOODS COLORADO COUNTY

23,090-05         LARRY HILL TARRANT COUNTY

24,307-03         RODERICK MAYS DALLAS COUNTY

25,550-04         MIKE CARTER HARRIS COUNTY

29,643-04         JAIRL LUTHER GRANT HARRIS COUNTY

29,981-04         CHARLES EDWARD KIMBROUGH HARRIS COUNTY

30,026-06         HAROLD LEE WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

33,923-10         CHESTER RAY JOHNSON BOWIE COUNTY

37,852-02         TYRONE DESHAN GARNER LUBBOCK COUNTY

41,444-03         KENNETH HAYDEN TALLEY TARRANT COUNTY

43,388-02         JAMES EARL MASON ELLIS COUNTY

43,821-02         ANDRE DUANE CALLAWAY ELLIS COUNTY

45,261-04         CECIL WAYNE TOLBERT DENTON COUNTY

45,300-02         JECOLE DEKEITH JACKSON DALLAS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER

(TEX. GOV'T CODE SEC. 501.0081 (b) )



12,150-04         JAMES ALFRED SINGLETON KAUFMAN COUNTY

23,054-02         KEVIN EDWIN MUELLER HARRIS COUNTY

27,158-06         WALTER CRAIG MORRIS TYLER COUNTY

27,158-07         WALTER CRAIG MORRIS TYLER COUNTY

42,779-02         BERNIE WALLACE ADKINS LUBBOCK COUNTY

43,489-04         KEVIN LEE MCCARROLL BAYLOR COUNTY

45,410-03         ERIC GERARD BURRELL HARRIS COUNTY

46,107-02         TERRY WILSON RANDALL COUNTY

47,583-01         MICHAEL CEPHUS SANNA MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,639-01         ALFRED GENE DAVIS JR. TARRANT COUNTY

47,680-01         TIMOTHY DRIVER BURLESON COUNTY

47,750-01         TERRY JEROME DOBBINS HARRIS COUNTY

47,757-01         RYAN E. GUNDLACH MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,793-01         MICHAEL ALLAN ARNOLD HARRIS COUNTY

47,802-01         JERRY E. BANDA BEXAR COUNTY

47,844-01         JERRY LEE LITCHFORD DALLAS COUNTY

47,857-01         STEVIE GORDON EL PASO COUNTY

47,864-01         TERRANCE DANIELS HARRIS COUNTY

47,887-01         ROBERT LEE CAMPBELL LAMAR COUNTY

47,891-01         JESUS VALADEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,891-02         JESUS VALADEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,891-03         JESUS VALADEZ HARRIS COUNTY

47,941-01         ALBERT LOUIS WILLIAMS SCURRY COUNTY

47,945-01         RICKY RAY SAMPLEY PALO PINTO COUNTY

47,948-01         CHRISTOPHER MUNOZ TARRANT COUNTY

47,950-01         ALBERT R. WILLIAMS MONTGOMERY COUNTY

47,952-01         JONATHAN ALLEN GLASS HARRIS COUNTY

47,957-01         KENNETH DALE MITCHELL HASKELL COUNTY

47,957-02         KENNETH DALE MITCHELL HASKELL COUNTY

47,958-01         MANUEL RAMOS DALLAM COUNTY

47,978-01         SEAN MUIRHEAD HARRIS COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS REMANDED TO TRIAL COURT:

47,518-01         LARRY EARL JONES TARRANT COUNTY

47,526-01         RICARDO CASTILLO GARZA COLLIN COUNTY

                          (JUDGE HOLLAND NOT PARTICIPATING)

47,651-01         BRODERICK SMITH DALLAS COUNTY

47,744-01         TYTON TERKEL HESTER FANNIN COUNTY

47,779-01         CHARLES RAY MOSLEY DALLAS COUNTY

                          (JUDGE KEASLER NOT PARTICIPATING)

47,846-01         GERALD GLEN NEIGHBORS VICTORIA COUNTY

47,846-02         GERALD GLEN NEIGHBORS VICTORIA COUNTY

47,929-01         CRAIG ALWIN JACKSON DENTON COUNTY

APPLICATIONS FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS ORDERED FILED & SET FOR SUBMISSION:

41,758-01         DONALD RAY MIDDLETON HARRIS COUNTY

43,493-01         DAVID HILLERY RAMSEY BOSQUE COUNTY

45,623-02         GREGORY DWAYNE THOMAS BEXAR COUNTY

45,623-03         GREGORY DWAYNE THOMAS BEXAR COUNTY

45,946-01         WALTER A. CONELY TRAVIS COUNTY

47,781-01         ENTRE NAX KARAGE DALLAS COUNTY

47,810-01         GLOSTON E. MARION HARRIS COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS DENIED WITHOUT

WRITTEN ORDER:

24,099-43         KEVIN LYNN REVELS HOUSTON COUNTY

24,805-05         GARY W. LOWE COUNTY

30,026-05         HAROLD LEE WASHINGTON HARRIS COUNTY

4,580-10           ROBERT RASBERRY JR. PANOLA COUNTY

44,933-03         GREGORY CHRIS ANGELO BELL COUNTY

46,031-01         TERRY J. GILL HARRIS COUNTY

46,204-01         STEPHEN JAY MORRIS HARRIS COUNTY

46,389-01         RAMON ALBERTO GARCIA HIDALGO COUNTY

47,077-01         STACY J. BELK DALLAS COUNTY

47,395-01         LUIS ALONSO MARTINEZ COUNTY

47,904-01         DAVID EUGENE BOYTER PANOLA COUNTY

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS HELD IN ABEYANCE

AND RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO FILE ANSWER:

11,926-02         TRAVIS ROLLINS COUNTY

26,517-04         HORACE VIRGIL CRANK DALLAS COUNTY

35,871-02         KENNO DESHON HENDERSON HARRIS COUNTY

44,992-02         BILLY DARNELL JACOBS COUNTY

47,350-01         MICHAEL C. SAMUEL COUNTY

47,939-01         RUSSELL PRYOR HARRIS COUNTY



MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITHOUT WRITTEN ORDER:



46,247-02         HIRAM MILES BEXAR COUNTY

46,247-03         HIRAM MILES BEXAR COUNTY



ARTICLE 11.071 APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DISMISSED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



33,586-02    CLAUDE HOWARD JONES SAN JACINTO COUNTY

(JUDGE HOLLAND WOULD DENY)

(JUDGE JOHNSON NOT PARTICIPATING)

(DISMISSED 12-7-00)



APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS DENIED WITH WRITTEN ORDER:



27,787-0     ERNEST WILLIS PECOS COUNTY

STATEMENT BY JUDGE WOMACK

(PRESIDING JUDGE MCCORMICK AND JUDGE PRICE JOINED)